Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout02-01-17 Online City Hall Survey Results - Short Term RentalsAll Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM Bozeman Online City Hall is not a certified voting system or ballot box. As with any public comment process, participation in Bozeman Online City Hall is voluntary. The responses in this record are not necessarily representative of the whole population, nor do they reflect the opinions of any government agency or elected officials. All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM, this forum had: Attendees: 768 Registered Responses: 177 Hours of Public Comment: 8.9 This topic started on December 19, 2016, 1:05 PM. All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 2 of 330 Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Responses Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? % Count Full-time Bozeman resident. 89.3% 158 Part-time Bozeman resident. 6.8% 12 Nonresident of Bozeman. 4.0% 7 Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? % Count Yes 73.4% 130 No 4.5% 8 Not sure 22.0% 39 If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? % Count I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. 43.4% 76 I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. 22.9% 40 I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. 19.4% 34 I feel STRs have no impact on my neighborhood. 10.9% 19 I have no opinion on how they impact my neighborhood. 3.4% 6 Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 3 of 330 If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) % Count It's an opportunity to meet new people. 43.2% 57 STR properties are usually well cared for. 84.1% 111 There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. 47.0% 62 Other 47.0% 62 If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) % Count Parking 64.6% 62 Noise 43.8% 42 Litter 18.8% 18 Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) 43.8% 42 Effect on supply of housing 56.3% 54 Safety issues 21.9% 21 Other 44.8% 43 Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees. % Count Agree 61.6% 109 Disagree 35.0% 62 Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 4 of 330 STRs should have a limit on the number of guests. % Count Agree 63.8% 113 Disagree 32.8% 58 There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block). % Count Agree 45.8% 81 Disagree 50.8% 90 The property owner should reside on-site. % Count Agree 26.6% 47 Disagree 68.9% 122 If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person. % Count Agree 79.1% 140 Disagree 19.8% 35 The City should not regulate STRs. % Count Agree 32.2% 57 Disagree 61.0% 108 Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 5 of 330 % Count Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single- household) 73.4% 130 Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single- household, some multi-household properties) 77.4% 137 High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi- household properties) 73.4% 130 Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) 80.8% 143 Commercial areas 59.3% 105 They should not be allowed in the City of Bozeman. 7.9% 14 How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? % Count Only when initially permitted 12.4% 22 Annually 33.9% 60 Every 3 years 22.6% 40 Never 31.1% 55 My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... % Count To make additional income. 28.1% 47 To pay the mortgage. 22.8% 38 Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 6 of 330 % Count I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. 13.8% 23 My business is owning / operating and renting out properties. 2.4% 4 I do not own / operate a STR. 60.5% 101 Other 13.8% 23 Please share any additional comments. Answered 110 Skipped 67 all also any been bozeman community do from had home house like live long more neighborhood one only out owner people property rental rentals s short so some str strs t term than them they time town vacation very who Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 7 of 330 Lisa Prugh inside Bozeman January 31, 2017, 8:52 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have no impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 8 of 330 No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 9 of 330 Nancy Johnson inside Bozeman January 31, 2017, 8:33 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - We have used STR around the US and Europe. It allows us to feel "at home" wherever we are. We get to participate in that community. We have used STR near our BonTon neighborhood home for visiting family. AND they are an affordable alternative to hotels. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Safety issues Other - We have experienced STRs on our block. They can have a negative affect on our neighborhoods sense of community. Also reduces housing opportunities for owner occupied homes which we prefer. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 10 of 330 How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Other - We have considered Airbnb if ever we are out of town for longer than a month to keep our home lived in. Please share any additional comments. I personally think there is a greater negative impact on a neighborhood from college rentals than there is from STRs. While reading these survey questions and applying them to both, I realized I would far prefer STRs to college rentals on my block. We have experienced both over the 30 years we have lived in this neighborhood, and, looking back on the experience of each, this is my observation. When a property was used as a college rental there was no (apparent) attention paid by the rental agency or the landlord in keeping the occupants at the legal limit of four unrelated adults in a rental (do they care?). Properties fell into disrepair, there was a LOT of noise from weekend parties, increased litter, congested street due to four or more additional cars, often a dog for each college student with little regard for leash laws or picking up after them, and absolutely no sense of community. STRs were kept in good condition (both the house and the yard), they were rented by families who wanted to experience neighborhood life and had regard for their temporary neighbors, they were quiet, there was no increase in litter, there was generally one car per rental, and, if dogs were allowed, the STR renter was more inclined to pick up because they were mature and thoughtful people. There are always exceptions, of course. We've had college renters that we wanted to stay forever because they were so wonderful and I'm sure there are terrible STR renters, although I haven't heard of any. STRs are somewhat self-limiting, as they are rated by their guests. If the rental property is poorly maintained it will get low ratings and people will stop renting and the landlord will lose income. It is in the landlord’s best interest to keep the property rentable. Does this happen with college rentals? No matter how poorly maintained the college rental is it will ALWAYS be rentable due to the lack of rentals in close proximity to the university. As the university grows (and that is another source of contention), it will only get worse. How often does the city inspect long term rental properties? Some of the rentals I've been in should have been condemned as health and fire hazards! I do think STR should be limited—but by how much? One per block? If there are too many rental properties in the neighborhood it will certainly affect the sense of community that any neighborhood enjoys. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 11 of 330 Tina Ovnic inside Bozeman January 31, 2017, 2:40 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. If STR's are to be subject to inspection, permitting and regulation, shouldn't all rental properties adhere to the same? I have two STR's on my block; both impeccably maintained, quiet and not overrun with multiple cars. Directly next door, I have a long term student rental...five cars at a minimum, not maintained in the least, parties Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 12 of 330 at all hours, fireworks, deer parts on the roof this fall/party-goers on the roof on warm summer nights. Not hard for me to conclude that STR's improve the quality of my neighborhood, whereas my adjacent neighbor not only detracts from it, the value of my property is negatively effected as well. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 13 of 330 Gloria Lindemeier inside Bozeman January 31, 2017, 2:03 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - Not sure there would be any positive impacts - would certainly not promote the feeling of being a neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Effect on supply of housing Other - There was a STR in this neighborhood which caused serious parking problems as it became a party house. Thankfully the City Code Compliance officer worked with us to change that. The owner of that home now compliant and only rents for 30 days or more. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 14 of 330 Please share any additional comments. STR should be subjected to the same taxing and licensing requirements as hotels, motels, etc. and the number allowed in any one area/neighborhood/subdivision should be limited. Too many STR in any one area will certainly change the feeling of neighborhood. Allowing STR rentals in neighborhoods with covenants seems to open up a who new set of problems for active homeowner associations. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 15 of 330 Beth Lee inside Bozeman January 30, 2017, 10:31 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Litter Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Safety issues Other - Very hard to know who belongs in the neighborhood anymore. Just to mention one current item: there is dog poop in the alley at the moment, and I believe it is a STR's responsibilty. . Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 16 of 330 When our neighborhood includes a critical mass of STRs, the sense of community is diminished, accountability is diminished, and people who would commit to be part of the community are prevented from living here. We in the U.S. undertake city planning, regulate and tax hotels, and set up land-use rules and districts for the protection of the consumer and the community. STRs consider only the personal betterment of the individual STR owner and bypass all that valuable civic work as though it were of no value. To allow STRs to undermine urban planning is also unfair to hotels and other businesses that operate under the rules and pay their fair share of their cost to the community. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 17 of 330 Lawrence Sampson inside Bozeman January 30, 2017, 9:28 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. Other - In my experience, people that use short-term rentals are genuinely excited about discovering Bozeman and the surrounding area. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To pay the mortgage. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 18 of 330 Please share any additional comments. For the questions related to the Cities involvement, please allow me to clarify: 1. If a permit or fee is required, the use of those funds should be voted on by the public. 2. STR should follow the City of Bozeman Codes for excessive noise or "public nuisance." The STR owner should be responsible for setting initial limits on the number of guests. I do with my house and am very strict about the number of people allowed on my property at any given time. It's worked out great. 3. I do think setting a density cap would help ease some general fear that STR can become out of control. That being said, I'm a firm believer in a system that takes into account the years that you have operated the property as a STR, if you are an absentee owner, and if you have consistently paid the state bed tax. 4. Although I live in the house I rent, I don't think the property owner necessarily has to live on-site. There is a house in my neighborhood in which the owner lives out of town. She has a local caretaker and she comes by the house routinely. There have been no issues with her renters. 5. I am very nervous of the City regulating STR's. When my ex-wife and I bought this house 15 years ago, we were brand new homeowners. We were as green as could be! We were able to purchase it because it had a long-term apartment, one that had been used for 70-80 years! However, shortly after we began to upgrade the electrical, the City inspectors came and scared us into believing that we had to bring our rental up to current codes. This was a decision that could have been devastating to us, financially. Finally, after many nervous months and working closing with the City, we were able to rent. In hindsight, it cost us undue hardship in lost rental because we only had to do a fraction of the daunting upgrade list. Currently, I use one of the online hosting sites, so between that and my insurance company there is sufficient regulation. If the City feels like it wants to get into the STR regulation business, I would insist that there would be ongoing dialogue to see how that can improve the system, not just scare people out of money. I will say, I am very hesitant to share my personal information for fear that it will be used against me. However, as a 15 year resident of Bozeman and a 22 year resident of Gallatin County, I am thankful that the City of Bozeman is willing to hear feedback and because of this, I am happy to add my voice. My story for using my house as a STR comes from two places: a need for the income and a genuine desire to share Bozeman with others. I have found both to be very rewarding! A few years ago I found myself in a situation that required me to look at alternative funding in order to keep my house. Truthfully, I was reluctant to do the STR because of many of the headlines painting the industry as chaotic, out-of-control, and with very few checks and balances for the home owner. For instance, the story of out of the owner returning to their destroyed property made me very nervous. The more I researched, the more I saw how serious these sites were about protecting and advocating for homeowners. I was also concerned with the potential impact my house may have on my neighbors. I live in a neighborhood that has several long-term rentals and have seen a consistent parade of parties that coincide with the new school year. It grows tiresome to have to continually police that as neighbors, so I was very sensitive that my neighbor's welfare should not be impacted. As I began to rent my place and better able to see how I could drive the type of guests that I wanted, ones that I felt would truly care for my place, my anxieties receded. However, part of my management is to continue to vet the affects of my STR on myself, my house, and my neighbors. It is an ongoing process and one that I take quite seriously. It should be noted that there are at least six STR's in a two block radius from me. You would be hard-pressed to distinguish those from a full-time, owner-occupied house. In contrast, one can easily spot the three long-term rentals in a one block radius based on the upkeep of the property and traffic flow, both human and auto. Also by comparison, the long-term rental have police regularly breaking up parties, whereas, in the three years I've seen the neighborhood STR's, none of those properties have had the police called. One last comparison has to Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 19 of 330 do with parking. I limit the number of guests that can stay in my house and the total number of people allowed on my property at any given time. Because of this, my guests generally have one car and sometimes two. I have a small off-street parking space, so I rarely take up any room on the streets (which falls in the guidelines for long-term rentals). One 5 bedroom long-term rental house in my neighborhood has no off-street parking but each renter has a car. Another long-term rental house has 7 bedrooms and enough off-street parking for two cars. Each renter has a car. In my view, the STR in my neighborhood do not contribute to noise complaints or parking issues. I have paid the State bed tax every quarter since I began my STR journey. I believe in being fair and am happy to do it. I do think this should be a consideration if the City institutes a density cap. I also believe, if the City assesses fees, that there should be two payment levels: owner-occupied and non-owner-occupied, with the later paying more. However, I do not believe that the City, at this point, belongs in the regulation business. In my view, the system of online ratings, guest feedback, neighbor feedback, homeowner insurance, and a State bed tax, work to regulate STR appropriately. I don't know the City can enrich the system, nor do I believe they truly want to get in the game. That being said, if the City chooses to get in the regulation business, the "how to's" should be open to public discussion and should include a section that outlines long-term rental regulations. Lastly, while I understand the general fear of STR (because I had my own), I will add that it has been a wonderful experience! People are so excited about our town and this corner of the world. I love hearing their stories of weddings, girl's weekends, real estate hunting, family vacations, seeing their daughter or son graduate, reunions, or literally just coming to unwind and do nothing! One thing that remains constant: their admiration for our town. My guests have loved Bozeman. The untold story of STR is the economic impact. I have no calculations on exact money being spent but these folks go to Bridger Bowl, eat and shop downtown, buy gas, groceries, and souvenirs. They visit locally owned retailers (I know because I see it in the trash). They spread the word about Bozeman. In the past I've participated in Ironman events. At all of the events they ask where you are staying, how many people are in your party, where you ate out and how many times. They want to know those numbers because they provide a service to these host cities. STR managers not only add a vitality to town that is, arguably, hardly noticed, they do so on a personal level. They help to "sell" Bozeman and that should not go unnoticed. By the way, not all STR's are created equal. I live in my house about 315 days of the year. Of the 50 or so days that I rent, I have to find alternate housing. I would argue that this is a greater impact on me than the City. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 20 of 330 Alison Olmstead inside Bozeman January 30, 2017, 8:52 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To pay the mortgage. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 21 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 22 of 330 Liesl Pessl inside Bozeman January 30, 2017, 8:06 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. Please share any additional comments. I'm mainly concerned with the lack of affordable housing for families. I can count 3 small homes in my Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 23 of 330 neighborhood that were bought and fixed up and sit empty the majority of the time, that would be perfect for young families. Maybe limiting the number of thes in a neighborhood would at least give a few more families affordable options in town. I also feel very strongly that corporations should not be allowed to buy rental properties as investments in Bozeman-that's about as far removed from community as it gets. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 24 of 330 Lisa Kirk inside Bozeman January 30, 2017, 4:26 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Effect on supply of housing Safety issues Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 25 of 330 Please share any additional comments. I live in R2 and objected to my next door neighbor renting their house on a daily basis. They were not permitted, but obtained a permit after I brought their business to the attention of the city. They moved to a 30 day rental platform and seem to do quite well. We appreciate the reduced chaos and have enjoyed meeting some of their guests. Night to night rentals are not appropriate for all locations. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 26 of 330 James Macdonald inside Bozeman January 30, 2017, 2:58 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) They should not be allowed in the City of Bozeman. How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 27 of 330 Courtney King inside Bozeman January 30, 2017, 1:04 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? No If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. Other - Additionally to first 2, it allows both the owners and the visitiors the option of experiencing Bozeman at a reasonable cost and help owners afford their home. I rented to internationals visiting MSU. I've been a single mom for years, it helped! If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - Should be rules in place that you can loose the privilege if any of this is proven to be the case after 2 offenses. Each owner should market a fine to the renter if any of this happens. I have seen rents double in the last 4 years, not a direct result. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... Other - Each neighborhood should decide if it's allowed. I would to make additional money and when I need to be away, have it occupied by a respectable party. I may need to be away to care for my mom in another state. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 28 of 330 Please share any additional comments. I have seen rent prices go up due to supply/demand, but not a direct correlation to vacation rentals. Mountain View apartments used to be $700/mo for a 2 brm 4 years ago when my sister in law rented there, they're now $1400/mo. and are not vacation rentals. I believe these should be allowed by the city and neighborhoods can choose to disallow them. In the case of the downtown area, if there are more than 2 legitimate complaints, you can lose the privilege to rent short term. However, you can live in a neighborhood with an awful neighbor and be stuck with them as long as you/they live there, short-term renters leave in a few days/weeks. I would rather have the opportunity to meet new people, help me pay for the rising city taxes and have someone in my home or property that will be respectful. There are many more long-term rentals that are not respected or taken care of, you would be hard-pressed to find a slum for rent on VRBO/AirB&B. I have lived next to long-term renters that parked in their front yard and there was nothing I could do about it. Allow them, put parameters/rules in place, inspect them like any other rental/new home, have reasonable rules/fees to cover policing them only, maybe have a tax to cover their impact. However, realize they are also bringing tourism to our area as well as students to MSU because the family can visit and all stay together in a house. I recently visited a similar town, Fort Collins CO for my cousins wedding. We tried to find a VR, vacation rental for our family to stay in, but there was a festival that same weekend causing them to be booked. We had to stay 30 minutes away and drive a lot. We would have preferred to be able to stay in the area of the wedding and walk everywhere, visit with our family more. My extended family rented a whole house and were able to visit a lot more and walk all over town=more dollars left in town, less fossil fuel used, no drinking/driving and more time together. My mom lives in SC. I have been thinking about how I can be there more often when needed without selling or renting my house out here. It is not allowed in my neighborhood to have a VR. However, ideally, I would like to own a house that has the option to leave for a month and have someone pay to stay here a week or a month. I also have a client who is a veterinarian and would like to spend time in Bozeman until she can move here in a few years. She would like to be able to rent out her place short term so she can stay in it for 3 weeks in the summer, that's not possible with a full time renter, but it is with a VR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 29 of 330 Aaron Traxinger inside Bozeman January 30, 2017, 11:27 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - Increases affordability if landowner lives in same property by allowing the owner to offset mortgage costs by renting out under used spaces If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 30 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 31 of 330 Joseph Sands inside Bozeman January 30, 2017, 11:00 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 32 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 33 of 330 Charlene Luchsinger inside Bozeman January 28, 2017, 5:54 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. Other - I want to have a short term rental for income Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 34 of 330 Please share any additional comments. I think short term rentals are very important to the Bozeman economy, and it is an excellent way for me as a retired person, to have an income. I raised my children as a stay-at-home mom until I became single, and had to find a job. It was not a high-paying job, and thus my SS is very little. I am a single woman, and have retired, and would love to have an STR in my townhouse, which I am moving out of, and it is currently authorized to rent out in this area. I feel the City of Bozeman should NOT BE ABLE to restrict what I do with my property. I plan on keeping it a quiet place with rules in the STR, and not parties, unless they are quiet & respectful. This kind of thing usually cannot be controlled as easily with 12 month or longer rentals. Please give the people of Bozeman a way to have an income, and still provide a much-needed service for the Bozeman area. I believe it will also bring in more population, as people will be able to visit Bozeman, have a place of their own to stay while here, and perhaps come back time & time again, eventually leading to some moving here. This is not an unreasonable request to allow the middle class to make some much-needed income! Thank you! Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 35 of 330 Caroline Roy inside Bozeman January 27, 2017, 11:20 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have no impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Other - we do own long term rentals and do not oppose short term rentals. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 36 of 330 Bozeman Montana is a wonderful place to live and work. However, it is also a part of the country with low wages relative to the price of housing. As a lender here in Bozeman, i see how hard it is for many to afford a reasonable home in which to raise their families. Short term rentals allows many people to earn a bit more income from their property and in many cases allows them to live here when they otherwise might not be able to. I've found that many of the same people who dislike the rental arrangements are folks who may have been fortunate to have paid cash for their homes or have been here for a very long time. By disallowing this use, it is a barrier to entry for those in the middle to lower end of the income spectrum here. It creates exclusivity for many parts of our community, limiting diversity. By implementing a density limit you would only be fostering that barrier to entry and creating a commodity to be bought or sold, much like our liquor license system here in the State. Many would agree that that system prevents our economy from expanding because of limited access to that service. This density proposal would act in much the same way. Instead, i support a licensing and a bed tax so that it is fair competition with area hotels. I personally own a Vacation rental in Idaho. It is inspected every two years. We pay a renewal fee at that time and then pay Idaho sales tax for each nightly rental. We have a maximum number of people in the house of 10. All public ordinances are posted in the home so that renters are always aware. Because we do not live there, we are required to supply a local resident who could respond to a true emergency outside of fire/police etc. We also own a long term rental in Bozeman in addition to our primary residence and would like the opportunity to offer it as a STR if we chose to do so. In summary, I feel that Vacation rentals offer additional income and prevent long term vacancies. They allow many to afford our town that otherwise could not. Reducing this system to a commodity plays favorites and creates a barrier to entry that favors those with more resources and excludes those who cannot buy their way into an existing system. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 37 of 330 Matthew Brailsford inside Bozeman January 26, 2017, 4:45 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. Other - I also have student rentals. I hate to charge kids who are always short of money over the Summer when they are not there. I can provide STR to tourists instead. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 38 of 330 No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 39 of 330 Geoffrey York inside Bozeman January 25, 2017, 2:26 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - Allows residents to augment income and stay in Bozeman If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - I have seen more negatives with poorly managed properties regardless of their use Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To pay the mortgage. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 40 of 330 Please share any additional comments. I think a much broader discussion is needed on neighborhoods and community writ large. Change is upon us whether we like it or not, but how do we retain the look and feel of our neighborhoods. Traffic flow (speeds, aggressive driving) are becoming an issue across town as is parking (both availability and impact on both flow and maintenance with dual side parking). When I see complaints about STR's I think- these are issues that potentially exist at owner occupied properties, long term rentals, and commercial properties across town as well. In my neighborhood, I have had more issues with the management of long term and commercial operators than with STR's (generally among the best managed and maintained in the neighborhood). Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 41 of 330 Jaimi Boyd inside Bozeman January 24, 2017, 10:51 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. Other - It allows residents to supplement their income without spending time away from home at a 2nd or 3rd job. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 42 of 330 Please share any additional comments. I don't feel there should be any restrictions on STR where the home owner lives on site and should not need a permit to do so. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 43 of 330 Brandon Edwards inside Bozeman January 24, 2017, 2:49 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 44 of 330 My family has stayed in many Bed and Breakfast rentals over the years. I also have friends who own them and friends who live next to them and I see them as a very positive experience for all involved and do not want to see them regulated. In my experience, customer reviews do a great job of regulation within online companies like AirBnB. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 45 of 330 Teri Ball inside Bozeman January 23, 2017, 4:23 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - Homeowners have the opportunity to make some money when they will be away for an extended period of time. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Litter Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 46 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 47 of 330 Miles Nolte inside Bozeman January 23, 2017, 2:11 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) They should not be allowed in the City of Bozeman. How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Housing and rental prices in Bozeman have become far too high far too quickly. STR properties are contributing to an already significant problem of housing being snatched up by wealthy real estate investors rather than average citizens. This negatively impacts our community. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 48 of 330 Annie Sites inside Bozeman January 23, 2017, 12:24 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Other - Harder to get to know who is renting Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. We have a small house so if If we built an STR it would be so our children could live there while going to college, company or older parents needing more care. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 49 of 330 Aimee Hanson inside Bozeman January 23, 2017, 10:55 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I have no opinion on how they impact my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - As long as the property owner is doing their part when screening potential renters, it should be okay. There are current residents that act and treat their homes like renters, so I see no difference with allowing STR's. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Other - If I did own/operate an STR, my reason would be - I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 50 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 51 of 330 Eli Anselmi inside Bozeman January 23, 2017, 10:32 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. Other - positive economic impact for Bozeman If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 52 of 330 The whole STR issue is being made into something bigger than it is. City is furthering eroding individual property rights by instituting additional red tape/requirements/fees/regulation that it is NOT needed. Both VRBO and AirBnB already stipulate and control most of the issues being brought up. If city wants feels that they "need" to permit/inspect homes that are into STR, then do so, but do not require additional fees or cumbersome process to do so for a property owner to exercise his/her own private property rights. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 53 of 330 Mikki Van Vuren inside Bozeman January 20, 2017, 1:44 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 54 of 330 Vanessa Hanson inside Bozeman January 19, 2017, 3:33 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - It provides an additional income source to home owners - rental space close to home for family members and friends visiting, and well cared for rental units for renters looking for something nice while they search and settle for longterm housing options. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) They should not be allowed in the City of Bozeman. How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 55 of 330 To pay the mortgage. Other - Zoning in this neighborhood allows for ADU rentals which many homes here were built with. While inspections make sense I do not believe restrictions do. It's an income resource that goes a long way towards home ownership in Bozeman. Please share any additional comments. STRs should be treated just like any other rental property. While upkeep on long term rentals can pose many challenges and property maintenance is often limited to being reactionary, STRs on the other hand are proactively well maintained which is crucial in order to survive on the STR rental market. I find it rather absurd that the City of Bozeman is considering restrictions towards STRs while many longterm rentals appears to be of more concern in Bozeman as it relates to maintenance, appearance, and code requirements. STRs should be considered favorable in that regards compared to longterm rentals. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 56 of 330 Ted Hanson inside Bozeman January 19, 2017, 10:22 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 57 of 330 Please share any additional comments. Short term rentals allow for people of various incomes to remain in the city of Bozeman. They provide extra income towards their mortgage. I live in a neighborhood where there are several short term rentals and the I haven't noticed any impacts. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 58 of 330 Cheryl Tusken inside Bozeman January 19, 2017, 7:30 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Nonresident of Bozeman. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... No response Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 59 of 330 Benj Ramsey inside Bozeman January 18, 2017, 10:12 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 60 of 330 No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 61 of 330 robert ross inside Bozeman January 18, 2017, 9:14 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. Other - It is an opportunity for my neighbors to maximize the potential of their home If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 62 of 330 m m inside Bozeman January 18, 2017, 9:03 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 63 of 330 Please share any additional comments. I believe that the natural market will regulate the need and general use of STR's and does not require outside regulation from the city to control the nature of this type of use in our neighborhoods. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 64 of 330 Joanna Breault inside Bozeman January 18, 2017, 7:39 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 65 of 330 I feel that STRs should be treated like any other rental property in town. They are no different and should not be held to higher standards. If the city wants to start charging fees and requiring permits for long term rentals then requiring that of STRs seems fair, but trying to ask those things of only STRs is very unfair and unnecessary. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 66 of 330 Ed Tompkins inside Bozeman January 18, 2017, 12:26 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 67 of 330 We feel like we have been ambassadors for people visiting the city of Bozeman. We give them a feel for what life is like here and recommend things to do, and restaurants and shops to visit. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 68 of 330 Cory Benge inside Bozeman January 18, 2017, 10:38 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 69 of 330 Mark Spencer inside Bozeman January 17, 2017, 4:41 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? No If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Other - Visitors have no responsibility to character of neighborhood, have no desire to "fit in" Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 70 of 330 Deb Haydon-Canfield inside Bozeman January 17, 2017, 10:55 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Litter Other - Don't know who belongs in neighborhood which is important with the rise in property crimes in neighborhood Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 71 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 72 of 330 Karina Tanguay inside Bozeman January 17, 2017, 10:37 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 73 of 330 We use STR everywhere we travel. It is a wonderful option for families with little kids. The city should not interfere anymore than they would with a regular rental. If the tenants are a problem then the owner should be notified and correct their policies just like if it were a regular rental. I am trying to get my parents to move here and being able to rent out their place part time would make it more feasible for them to afford to own a part-time home here. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 74 of 330 Tim Lockie inside Bozeman January 16, 2017, 4:58 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 75 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 76 of 330 Richard Canfield inside Bozeman January 16, 2017, 11:51 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) They should not be allowed in the City of Bozeman. How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No ADUs in single family neighborhoods (R-1 & R-S & R-2) Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 77 of 330 Lynne Conkling Benton inside Bozeman January 16, 2017, 10:01 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Part-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - introduces potential new residents to a family neighborhood; provides a family home for vacationers instead of hotel rooms, allows use of property that might otherwise sit vacant; if STR guests are unruly, they will be gone within 7 days or so. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 78 of 330 To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. Other - Allow other families to enjoy our wonderful home in Bozeman, instead of having to stay at hotels. Please share any additional comments. We have STRs in the Florida Keys (Key Colony Beach). The annual inspection is simple (focused on safety issues - checking smoke alarms and pool alarms). Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 79 of 330 Leif Wickland inside Bozeman January 16, 2017, 8:37 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. Other - STRs in my neighborhood are excellent advertising for enticing visitors to become residents of Bozeman. Visitors experience a pleasant residential setting instead of a vanilla hotel. When I've used STR in other cities the experience has been very positive If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 80 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 81 of 330 Jay Hauwiller inside Bozeman January 14, 2017, 9:40 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Other - I believe short term rentals encourage purchasing houses as an investment for non residents. I worry this will mean a lack of interest in the concerns of the neighborhood. For example, traffic calming efforts would not be a concern for non residents. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 82 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 83 of 330 Roger Fischer inside Bozeman January 14, 2017, 9:08 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. Other - These are positive for the property owners because it is an opportunity to generate income. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Effect on supply of housing Other - Properties that are used as STRs are not available for local residents to rent or buy. Since the lowest- priced properties are most likely to attract people looking to buy investment properties, the effect is less affordable housing for community members. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 84 of 330 Please share any additional comments. I am very concerned about the trend of property owners purchasing an additional residence for use as a short- term rental or other form of income property. Bozeman is already experiencing a shortage of affordable housing for those in lower income brackets. Since the lowest-priced properties are most attractive to persons intending to use them as income properties, the shortage of affordable properties for permanent residents is exacerbated. It is the function of government to protect those who are most vulnerable. The City of Bozeman needs to act decisively. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 85 of 330 M Martell inside Bozeman January 13, 2017, 3:45 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Part-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To pay the mortgage. I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. Please share any additional comments. We moved to Bozeman 20 years ago to live and breathe the mountains with our children. Along the way, we have happily been involved in this community both small and large. I have a short term rental in my home (for Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 86 of 330 10 years) managed with the excellent skills of a local vacation rental management company which has specialized in vacation rentals since the 1990's. We register our vacation rental with the city, meet fire and health regulations and I currently maintain one million dollars in specialty insurance (not a big deal -- it does not cost as much as many would assume). We have created jobs and hired local architects, contractors, landscapers, local guides and have used many other local businesses in our endeavors. I have had many types of people staying in my home. I have hosted medical students, some of whom have gone onto work in this community. I have had people visiting family for holiday as well as business people, artists and tourists. My neighbors are aware and happy with our practices. Many of my neighbors have long term rentals as part of their ownership. Our guests spend money in local festivals and businesses on Main St. and beyond. I support regulation. I support taxes. I support the community. I agree that vacation rentals are a new entity and require scrutiny. I believe we can work together to wisely incorporate this evolving phenomena which is a vibrant aspect of our community. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 87 of 330 Doug Chabot inside Bozeman January 13, 2017, 12:19 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. Other - Homeowners should be allowed to turn an extra room or apartment into cash. Just like homeowners can already declare a room in the house for business, I see no reason that the option shouldn't allow for rental. It fits a need in the community too. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 88 of 330 Please share any additional comments. The reason the City should have a stake in STRs is that it effects the neighborhood. Parking is a serious concern; services like plowing are effected. Yet the City should not lump STRs in with hotels in regards to inspection, etc. A multi-year permitting system to cover the basic health and safety of the space seems adequate for STR. Although I do not have a STR, I may in the future and am interested in some regulation, but not something overbearing that takes away my rights as a homeowner. I would also like to only see STR in homes where the owner uses the house as his primary residence, even if they are not present year round. This would keep people from buying homes specifically to turn into a STR which would negatively effect the nature of the community. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 89 of 330 Susanna Darr inside Bozeman January 13, 2017, 11:50 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 90 of 330 Candice Wilson inside Bozeman January 13, 2017, 9:25 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. I make a living cleaning short term rentals, and i know many other people that do as well. Short term vacation Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 91 of 330 rentals are good for the local economy. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 92 of 330 Gloria Banta outside Bozeman January 13, 2017, 8:22 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - They pay a bed tax, employ locals to clean and maintain property and help locals to make some income on their property. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 93 of 330 Please share any additional comments. I live right next door to a STR that has had a very busy rental history for many years. We have never had a problem with any of the guests and as a matter of fact the ones we have met have been delightful and very respectful of the neighborhood. Mostly they are families getting together to have a wonderful Montana experience, this experience would not be the same as staying in a hotel. A STR allows a guest to feel almost like a Montanan local for a week. My own family likes to stay at a STR when we go on vacation and feel that it is a wonderful option and all of our experiences were far superior to staying in a hotel. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 94 of 330 Michelle Thiel inside Bozeman January 13, 2017, 7:22 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 95 of 330 Reno Walsh inside Bozeman January 12, 2017, 8:41 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - Rentals may offer permanent Bozeman residents and opportunity to earn an income and have a real estate based retirement plan that will allow them to stay in Bozeman rather than move somewhere where they could earn a better income with a retirement plan. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Effect on supply of housing Other - Long term rentals for many of our long term residents are getting harder to find and more expensive. Short-term rentals are only part of the problem but part of the problem none the less. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 96 of 330 My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To pay the mortgage. Other - We operating our short term rental as a side business that will pay the mortgage on the property. Please share any additional comments. I don't believe the property owner needs to live on site but I do think it is worth considering the idea of requiring a property owner to live in Gallatin County or the State of Montana. This may increase the possibility of the owner being more accessible and involved even if he or she does decide to work with a property management company. This may increase the chances of the owner reinvesting their earnings back into our local communities rather than doing so elsewhere. Are there any projections on what the total earnings from the 7% bed tax may be if all currently listed properties were to pay and if their properties were occupied 50% of the time? Some property owners are more casual about their rentals than others. If friends come to town, they have space for them but from time to time they also rent out a room or other space via airbnb or craigslist. Others are attempting to pay a mortgage and work hard to fill their property with paying guests as much as they can. Should the city consider various permit options? Knowing the city would probably not be able to police the permits and the various requirements would varied permits only cause more problems? Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 97 of 330 Lynn Swain outside Bozeman January 12, 2017, 8:20 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Nonresident of Bozeman. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - Cheaper and more intimate surrounding choice with the ability to meet local people and get a feel for the area which you cannot get at a large hotel. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 98 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 99 of 330 Heather Drake inside Bozeman January 12, 2017, 11:46 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Other - We value having permanent neighbors that we see on a regular basis, to share in events with and for our kids to play with. We own a home in a residential neighborhood; I would like to keep it that way. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 100 of 330 Please share any additional comments. If I were to run a commercial kitchen or retail business from my home, I would be required to get an approval, inspection, permit, and to pay fees and taxes. Operated as a business, particularly within a residential neighborhood, STRs should be regulated in the same manner. Short term rentals, utilized as a source of income, are essentially bed and breakfast operations without a host. I also feel that an STR operated NOT as a business and the homeowner is the PRIMARY resident deserves its own category. This would include a homeowner renting out an ADU seasonally or for a minority portion of the year, or renting his/her home while on vacation to keep the dwelling occupied and/or defray the cost of travel/mortgage/utilities. Much like having an occasional garage sale, this type of rental would not support a consistent income. These should still require a limited use permit, with a nominal fee to cover any administrative costs and to assist the city in maintaining regulations on STRs. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 101 of 330 Andrea Rosenstein outside Bozeman January 12, 2017, 7:57 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To pay the mortgage. Other - My son lives there part time working remotely and I don't want to leave it empty Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 102 of 330 It's important to Know that people I usually rent to are families who have families that live in my neighborhood. They are there to attend weddings, holidays and family gatherings. I also rent to the families of college students who come to attend their students graduation or help them settle in For the year. They are wonderful families and leave the house immaculate. It is been a wonderful experience all these years. I have a permit and pay taxes. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 103 of 330 Deanna Campbell inside Bozeman January 11, 2017, 11:34 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have no impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 104 of 330 Andy Hintzpeter inside Bozeman January 11, 2017, 10:29 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 105 of 330 Anne Foster inside Bozeman January 11, 2017, 6:29 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Safety issues Other - I live directly behind a STR house. On summer nights, vacationers party on the back porch and in the yard with bright lights that illuminate the back of my house. Light pollution is most unwelcome when my are windows open and I'm trying to sleep. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 106 of 330 Please share any additional comments. In the years since the house behind me has become a STR house, we have a steady parade of noisy people, often with dogs who are allowed to bark incessantly (police have been called) and who return from their day's activities, flip on all the back lights, and start a party on the back porch and in the yard, in the wee small hours of the morning. When those nights are warm, our windows are open and sleep becomes impossible. It seems terribly unfair that, in a single-family part of my neighborhood, vacationers seemingly without any cares, are permitted to disturb the peace and intrude on neighbors' peace and quiet. Several of the adjacent neighbors have small children, so this makes the disturbance even worse. We did not buy our home in the belief that our neighbors would open up a small hotel in our backyard! We were here first. Please impose some standards and restrictions in deference to adjacent homes' occupants. Thank you. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 107 of 330 Carl Yeoman inside Bozeman January 11, 2017, 5:47 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To pay the mortgage. Other - As a teacher I am only paid 9 months of the year, short term rentals allow me to pay the mortgage and survive Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 108 of 330 Please share any additional comments. If any of the above mentioned issues (safety, parking, litter, housing supply) truly exist they should be quantified and compared to non-STR or disregarded as unsubstantiated concerns. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 109 of 330 Joshua Richards inside Bozeman January 11, 2017, 2:48 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 110 of 330 Barton Churchill inside Bozeman January 11, 2017, 2:24 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - They give homeowners an opportunity to offset rapidly rising property taxes. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 111 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 112 of 330 Jennifer Britton inside Bozeman January 11, 2017, 1:11 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Safety issues Other - Privacy as an adjacent property owner. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) They should not be allowed in the City of Bozeman. How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 113 of 330 Please share any additional comments. We didn't know when we bought a house in Bozeman, especially for price of Bozeman, that we would be living next to mini-hotels. In the summer it's constant turn-over. Cars have blocked our garage, barking dogs, and we have had people come into our back yard looking for their rental. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 114 of 330 Matt Kemmer outside Bozeman January 11, 2017, 10:48 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Litter Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Safety issues Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 115 of 330 Please share any additional comments. We had an STR in our Creekwood neighborhood. Largely the property managed itself, but when there were issues, there wasn't a person to call to deal with it. For example, when there many people staying in the house, parking became an issue for us, across the street in our own home. There were some instances of people blocking access to fire hydrants, and of course we could call Parking Enforcement to address that, but in most cases the issues that arose were more of a nuisance than anything. We witnessed some littering by short-term guests, which of course is hard to enforce. And, while there were never any issues, I felt safety in my neighborhood could have been compromised. We definitely lost the some level of comfort not knowing who was our neighbor for the night or weekend or whatever. I'm not a fan of short-term rentals, but understand they serve a purpose, both for people visiting Bozeman, as well as for property owners who might need to make a reasonable income to pay their mortgage or supplement our ridiculously-high property taxes. But the STR's need to be regulated. Part of that regulation should include a mechanism for neighbors to complain without tying up emergency services (funded by the fees collected for STR permits). Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 116 of 330 Christian Black inside Bozeman January 11, 2017, 9:47 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Other - Unmaintained landscaping and snow covered sidewalks. Garbage bin left out on street for many days. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... No response Please share any additional comments. I feel that STR's work nicely in condo's where the property is maintained by the COA. The COA then can pass the additional cost of the STR on to the owner. The STR that is a single family residence in my neighborhood is Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 117 of 330 poorly cared for. The sidewalks are rarely shoveled and in the summer the yard is usually unmaintained. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 118 of 330 Susan Fraser inside Bozeman January 11, 2017, 7:50 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have no impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Noise Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 119 of 330 Mark Corner outside Bozeman January 11, 2017, 7:18 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? No If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Safety issues Other - I am a Realtor in Bozeman and have clients that have specifically moved out of high rental neighborhoods. They never know who their neighbors are! It becomes very transient! Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... No response Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 120 of 330 Bozeman is a world class destination location. There is a lot of demand for lodging by people visiting here. And that demand is growing each year. Short Term Rentals need to be limited, regulated, inspected and taxed by the same lodging taxes as hotels in Bozeman. I am so happy that you are taking action now before this problem gets more out of control. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 121 of 330 Jes Falvey inside Bozeman January 11, 2017, 5:38 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. Other - Income for my neighbors. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 122 of 330 The long term rentals in my NE neighborhood can be awful, 5 very tiny off street parking spots for a 3 unit (total 8 bedroom) house. They had 1a.m. fireworks and a party on the porch with 3 cars parked in front of my house last weekend, I got up for work at 5 a.m. and there were still 7-ish people talking loud and smoking cigs on the porch. That's the house to the west. To the south is a house that has been STR. Once someone parked in front of our house, I asked the owner to ask his renters to park on 'his' side, it NEVER happened again. I have his number if there's a problem, he's over mowing or doing upkeep once a week or more. It's the nicest looking place on the street. IF there's problems the city (police) can handle it. We don't need gov't interference because one neighbor is fussy about nothing. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 123 of 330 sara dee inside Bozeman January 10, 2017, 1:17 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Litter Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 124 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 125 of 330 Fiona Buckley inside Bozeman January 10, 2017, 11:08 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 126 of 330 I work part time at the hospital and live in my house when I am working. When I am not working the house is empty, sometimes for weeks or even a month. Having short term rentals in the house when we are not there means that the mail is being picked up, the sidewalk is being shoveled, and the grass is being mowed. Even if there are not renters in the house, being part of a rental agency ensures that regular maintenance and upkeep is enforced. Because of the standards of my rental agency (Bozeman Cottage) I keep the house and yard in even better condition than I would for myself. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 127 of 330 Jennisse Schule inside Bozeman January 10, 2017, 11:05 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - Fills a need; allows more flexibility in housing uses. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. My business is owning / operating and renting out properties. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 128 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 129 of 330 Cecily Johnson inside Bozeman January 9, 2017, 6:12 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - STR renters tend to be more affluent, seek homes rather than motels bc they plan to engage in the unique character of our town and spend money doing so. Owners have to attract them by enhancing their property and select appropriate renters. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... Other - I don't have property to do STR, but I would if I did. I would for all the above reasons, which is exactly why people are. As far as management, people either can afford a company or they can't, in which case, they Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 130 of 330 themselves manage, so why require it? Please share any additional comments. I think the only way the City should be involved is to turn the information over to the state to make sure the lodging tax of 7% is paid. I don't believe in this tax, but it seems we need to tax people whenever we see them engaged in an activity that involves money, even though the gain will come back around to affect our economy positively--possibly more so--if we don't collect taxes and fees at every turn. This is money in our community, not only for the property owner, but for every shop and restaurant and gas station in town because these people have somewhere to stay with their families while visiting our town and want to sample what we offer, and those are big dollars in our town that would otherwise go to a chain motel and move on to another town. Why do we tax property owners so heavily and then tax them for renting, and then tax them on income and charge them fees for inspections and on and on? The inspection is just another job for civil servants coming out of our pockets and is a tax in disguise. If an inspection is needed, one time ought to do it. The argument that STR's affect the fabric of our community is unfounded. These very people seek the fabric of our town. Monthly or yearly renters are every bit as much transient people, and generally aren't contributing to our economy. They are often packing up and moving on when school or their job is over. This is a self regulating type of business. If a renter is bad, neighbors complain and their venture may be shut down. If a property isn't kept up, they won't get a good review. When you are traveling, do you want to stay in a Super 8? Or do you hope to stay in a house where your children and grandchildren can stay, and cook some meals, go out for some meals, have money for ski tickets...If all you got to see was a motel on the outskirts of town where you had to drive to downtown for every get together, you'd pick another town where you could enjoy the local flavor. These people enjoy it more than some of our own residents. Non issue here. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 131 of 330 Leslie Snively outside Bozeman January 9, 2017, 5:08 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Part-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To pay the mortgage. Please share any additional comments. Owning an STR in Bozeman allows us to spend more time in town than we would be able to if we didn't. Between our visits, and those of the guests that use our STR, the property is occupied more than 50% of the Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 132 of 330 time, meaning that we provide the city with at least a half-time residency, including the goods and services that our purchased while we or others are there. We also pay the full property, school, and other tax assessments as a full time resident, but since we only use the services those taxes provide about half the time, the city has a net benefit to our ownership of the STR compared to a resident owner. We're happy to contribute the extra revenue to the community in return for the opportunity to spend more time in the area. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 133 of 330 Amanda Harris outside Bozeman January 9, 2017, 3:43 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Part-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - Economic value of visitors downtown for Bozeman If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 134 of 330 Please share any additional comments. In my neighborhood seasonally empty houses reduce the vibrancy of the place and mean less revenue for downtown shops, restaurants and businesses. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 135 of 330 Leah Belair outside Bozeman January 9, 2017, 2:04 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Part-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To pay the mortgage. I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 136 of 330 Please share any additional comments. We have been operating an STR for a few years. It allows us to cover expenses while we get ready to move permanently to Bozeman. Our son and his family live in Bozeman and we visit every couple of months. We love the town and have made many friends there and look forward to becoming a more permanent part of the community. We have a property manager who complies with all regulations and also collects taxes. Without this option we would not be able to plan our retirement to Bozeman. Our experience is that guests are respectful and follow the rules.We communicate clearly with our neighbors and even rely on them for feedback about our guests and they let us know if anything is amiss. We also have an STR in CA which we operate ourselves. The county regulates it, requiring us to collect and pay taxes, have a local manager( a neighbor volunteered ), pay for a yearly permit ($75), provide a diagram of the property, and also regulates the number of guests based on the number of bedrooms and parking availability. Communication with the neighbors is key and we restrict the number of people allowed at the rental to help maintain the character of the neighborhood. We strongly urge the City of Bozeman to enforce the regulations that are already in place before enacting new ones. We also own other property in Bozeman that are full time rentals. We pride ourselves on being good landlords and provide solid housing at fair market rate. The reason we don't turn those properties into an STR? It is a lot more work that a long term rental and we have no need or desire for personal use of those properties. Generally STRs are much less viable sources of income than full time rentals, especially in a climate like Bozeman. I think you will find that most STRs are owned by people like us: older people who want to eventually settle in Bozeman and need to cover expenses on a property purchased for that purpose, while also having access to that property when needed for personal visits. The myth of out of town investors running STRs is just that: a myth. Too much work for the return on investment. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 137 of 330 Frederick Zarndt outside Bozeman January 9, 2017, 12:40 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Nonresident of Bozeman. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I have no opinion on how they impact my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 138 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 139 of 330 Danae Giannetti inside Bozeman January 9, 2017, 12:14 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - You are giving the opportunity for others to see how beautiful our community is and gain an equal appreciation for it as residents have. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 140 of 330 Please share any additional comments. STRs are the future of travel for most. I have utilized STRs in my travels and I think they're a wonderful option. It would be good to have some light regulation to insure there some accountability for property owners to maintain safe facilities but overall I think it is a self-regulated industry due to the option to rate and review not just users of the STRs but the providers. If someone isn't doing a good job keeping a place safe and clean, it will be known and they will have to change or close up shop! Please allow STRs. It is the future! Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 141 of 330 Shaney Evans inside Bozeman January 9, 2017, 11:23 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Litter Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Safety issues Other - Inject tourism into residential areas; party homes ruin neighborhood values; noise disruptions for working familes and school children; increased traffic with no disregard for children/pets; aesthetics Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Commercial areas They should not be allowed in the City of Bozeman. How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 142 of 330 Please share any additional comments. Short term rentals are ruining residential areas by drastically changing the character and value of neighborhoods. People purchase homes in a neighborhood and expect a quiet, safe place to raise children. Short term rentals bring loud music, unattended barking dogs, partying all night, parking issues, and people driving with no concern for the children playing outside...this is happening on my street. I shouldn't be sleep- deprived for work so that someone can make money on their rental property. Tourism needs to stay out of our family neighborhoods. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 143 of 330 David McWethy inside Bozeman January 9, 2017, 10:46 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Litter Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Safety issues Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Other cities in the western US have successfully addressed some of the negative impacts of short term rentals Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 144 of 330 (parking, noise, litter, change in the feel of the neighborhood) with density caps (e.g., 1 per block). This is a simple and effective way of allowing a small number of short term rentals and still maintaining character of long- term residential neighborhoods. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 145 of 330 Michael Barrett inside Bozeman January 9, 2017, 10:45 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 146 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 147 of 330 Donna Lutey inside Bozeman January 6, 2017, 11:35 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - I also have a lot of long term rentals in my neighborhood which house college students. Frequently there are loud parties at late hours, obscene behaviors, beer cans left on the boulevard, etc. I much prefer short term rentals. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... Other - I own two historical homes which were built and owned by my ancestors. A short term rental allows me continuous access and complete control of the preservation of the property not afforded by longer term leases Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 148 of 330 with tenants who may harder to remove. Please share any additional comments. Many of the properties in my neighborhood are owned by absentee owners. Most are 1950 era homes and have fallen into disrepair. They command high rents and are filled with groups of college students. Public sidewalks are blocked by cars extending into the public right of way and are seldom cleared of snow. Loud parties are common with beer cans and vomit left behind. There is general disregard for the upkeep of the properties as well as consideration for the more permanent residents. The one vacation rental around the corner from my home is well kept, the guests are polite and considerate, and there is no negative impact on the neighborhood. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 149 of 330 Joe Giannetti inside Bozeman January 6, 2017, 9:29 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have no impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - Alternative income If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 150 of 330 Big government get out of my home! Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 151 of 330 Kryssa Bowman inside Bozeman January 6, 2017, 6:32 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - Short term rentals are always well maintained so they benefit my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Short term renters, otherwise known as guests, are highly motivated to get their deposits back and therefor Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 152 of 330 don't tend to damage the property. In addition, short term rentals themselves are cleaned very regularly, after every departing guest, and tend to remain in very good condition because of that. Managers and owners of vacation homes and short term rentals are highly motivated to keep their homes in pristine condition and clear all walkways and provide pleasing landscaping. In short, the only downside to having vacation homes and short term rentals in Bozeman is the potential decrease in long term rental housing. But when you consider the damage done by long term renters, this issue becomes moot. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 153 of 330 Marjorie Smith inside Bozeman January 6, 2017, 1:55 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. Other - I am an STR owner and manager. Income from this enterprise has allowed me to supplement my social security income and remain an active, contributing member of my community. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. Other - To allow me to use the apartment as housing for out-of-town relatives when they visit and to make it available to donate for the Intermountain Opera's visiting artists, both of which would be impossible if it were a Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 154 of 330 long-term rental. Please share any additional comments. I sympathize with neighbors of large STR houses which will only be rented out for family reunions or wedding parties and the like and therefore be dark much of the time and noisy party scenes when rented out. I believe that during the eight years I have been operating my STR it has had very little if any impact on my neighbors due to the layout of my building on the block and the fact that I provide an off-street parking space. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 155 of 330 Amanda Garant inside Bozeman January 5, 2017, 6:47 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. Other - STRs can help home-owners afford their mortgages and pay for their property. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Noise Effect on supply of housing Other - Effect on the price of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. As a renter in Bozeman, I have felt the impact of the increasing price of rental units and the decreasing amount of available affordable units. It is very hard to find housing in this town and STRs are not helping the situation. I empathize with home owners who are seeking supplemental incomes to pay for mortgages and for increasing Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 156 of 330 property taxes. However, rather than an STR, it would be better for the fabric and strength of our community to create more long term, affordable rental units for our fellow Bozemanites. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 157 of 330 Brodie Bergeson inside Bozeman January 5, 2017, 5:28 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have no impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. There is a STR directly behind our house with open space in between each other. We have never experienced any negative experiences and generally the guest have been friendly and entertained by our crazy children running free. The property is always maintained. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 158 of 330 Bobby Bear inside Bozeman January 5, 2017, 3:06 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Other - Renters tend to leave exterior lights on longer and/or more frequently. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 159 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 160 of 330 Geoff Stephens inside Bozeman January 5, 2017, 7:45 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - Source of income for owners If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Litter Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 161 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 162 of 330 Patricia Simmons inside Bozeman January 4, 2017, 6:40 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have no impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Usually rentals of houses in a residential neighborhood of any kind are a problem in Bozeman because there is no enforcement of rules and people cheat and have far more renters that is allowed in a single family home. Parking is usually a major problem because street parking is limited due to other people's vehicles, fire plugs, no parking zones and renters tend not to use the garage and they often have 3-4 vehicles. This probably doesn't apply to the STR, but is a major problem in Bozeman. If the Police and other enforcement people Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 163 of 330 inspected and observed neighborhoods with rentals on a regular basis and tell the occupants about the rules of Bozeman (quiet, parking, parties, being considerate of neighbors, take care of landscaping, etc.) and then give fines and stop being so easy on people, especially college students. Our society needs to require people to behave and be considerate, and charge for doing the enforcement & inspections so there is money to cover the service. My last single family home neighborhood slowly was being taken over by rentals to college students, ruining the neighborhood. We've moved to a condo complex where the rules are enforced, and there are few rentals, although we have one next door (they don't do the landscaping so hopefully the owner will get fined, soon) Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 164 of 330 Emily Mason inside Bozeman January 4, 2017, 9:38 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) They should not be allowed in the City of Bozeman. How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... No response Please share any additional comments. I moved from Boulder, CO almost 3 years ago where STRs are only allowed if it is someone's primary residence. I think this is an intelligent decision. Housing in Boulder is very expensive (Bozeman is not far behind) and very limited. If the house is a second home, the house can only be rented for longer term rentals, a minimum of one month. My mother owns a town home that she rents out (she resides in Maryland) except for Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 165 of 330 one month in the summer. She rents the home to families who are remodeling a home and to visiting scientists at NIST/NOAA and professors doing research at CU. People tend to rent the home from 4-12 months at a time. This helps to maintain a level of neighborliness and does not have a tremendous rotation of people coming and going. We still own a home in Boulder that we rent out for a minimum of 1 year. Our next door neighbors would be very upset if we turned our home into a STR (if that were possible) and we would never do that to them. It's important that we help maintain the neighborhood feel back in Boulder. In a town with such limited housing stock, Bozeman should adopt the same regulations that Boulder passed. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 166 of 330 Elsbeth Grosfield outside Bozeman January 3, 2017, 10:10 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Nonresident of Bozeman. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - Job opportunities, tourist revenue If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... Other - I have my job thanks to vacation rentals. I have been the bookkeeper for the business for 3 years. The only money I make from the vacation rentals is my hourly wage as the bookkeeper. Please share any additional comments. Though I do not live in Bozeman, my husband and I own a house in Bozeman. We have permanent renters who have lived in our house for 5 years. We personally do not want to own a vacation rental, but very much depend on the part time income I make as a bookkeeper for others who own vacation rentals. I must admit to Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 167 of 330 still being new at my job as a bookkeeper for short term rentals (only three years), but it seems to me that the City of Bozeman has an opportunity to make money from the short term rentals rather than get rid of these numerous small businesses funneling tourists into the city. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 168 of 330 Eileen Hosking inside Bozeman January 3, 2017, 8:10 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Other - Bozeman used to be a place where people lived, not a commodity. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 169 of 330 No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 170 of 330 Nikolas Grosfield outside Bozeman January 3, 2017, 4:52 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Nonresident of Bozeman. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - As a native Montanan and a former Bozeman resident, I see economic benefits for owners and operators of the STR (and thus the community as well). Further community economic benefits come through the hosting of longer-term guests / tourists in the area. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - Any of the above problems are possible, but they are possible from standard renters and homeowners as well. STR owners and operators have direct financial incentives to establish and maintain quality property and neighborhood relations for their business. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. My business is owning / operating and renting out properties. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 171 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 172 of 330 Zachary Grosfield outside Bozeman January 3, 2017, 4:13 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - Extremely well kept and manicured properties, provide many jobs in the community (cleaners, maintenance, snow removal, lawn care, etc), allows larger groups of people to travel to Bozeman together, thus benefiting our whole economy. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 173 of 330 To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. Please share any additional comments. My wife and I have owned 1 vacation rental and managed several others for seven years now, including 2 in the city limits of Bozeman. In 7 years with multiple properties, we have gotten only ONE complaint from a neighbor. We immediately resolved the issue. Many neighbors do not have any idea there is even a vacation rental in their neighborhood because it is a well-maintained property with quiet guests. The only way for a short term rental to be found among thousands of listings on websites like VRBO or AirBNB is to get lots of positive reviews. Vacation rentals only get positive reviews if they are extremely well-kept, clean and make an excellent first impression. For this reason our vacation rentals are, bar none, the best kept and best looking houses in the neighborhood. The landscaping is always neat, the exterior and interior are always well maintained and taken care of. Our our small vacation rental business provides full time or part time jobs for the following local Bozeman residents: 3 different house cleaners, property maintenance, a book-keeper, snow removal, a lawn care/landscaping specialist, and yours truly, the vacation rental managers. What many opponents of vacation rentals don't realize is the amount of money it takes to run a successful vacation rental. If a property grosses $40,000 per year, for example, approximately $28,000 of that is directly reinvested back into the community in the form of the paid wage earners listed above. Additionally, vacation rentals are fully furnished, mostly from local furniture suppliers. A 4 bedroom short term rental easily spends $15,000 - $20,000 in furnishing the property. Again, this is money which is directly reinvested into our local economy. In actuality, the owner of a successful short term rental doesn't keep much more (and sometimes less) money than he would if he rented the property out on a 12 month lease. This is because so much of the money made by a successful vacation rental, by necessity, is reinvested back into local jobs and the local economy in the ways mentioned above. Of course the owner of the short term rental benefits by having a home in Bozeman which is well cared for and which he/she can visit whenever they want. Regarding the 7% "Montana Bed Tax," I believe this is not the responsibility of the city of Bozeman. We have registered every one of our vacation rentals with the state Department of Revenue and have had each one inspected and licensed by the county health inspector. We have always paid our Lodging Facilities Sales and Use Tax to the state. Regardless, I still believe the city of Bozeman has no business trying to regulate the Montana Department of Revenue's collection of its own tax. That is the responsibility of the State of Montana. Let the State of Montana do their own investigations and regulations of their own tax. To say "Because some vacation rental owners do not pay their state tax, the city of Bozeman will penalize all vacation rental owners including those who have dutifully paid their tax for years" is not only bad business and unfair, but it lacks integrity as well. If the city of Bozeman finds a restaurant which is violating health codes, it would be unfair and wrong for the city of Bozeman to punish all restaurants in town for the actions of just that restaurant. I think we would all agree that to punish all for the sins of a few goes against the standards of our country, our state, and our city. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 174 of 330 Finally on a personal note. I have been a Montana Highway Patrol state Trooper for 3.5 years. I dutifully served my state and my community until September, when I left under honorable terms with an open invitation to come back any time in my future (I am pursuing another opportunity). I also own a vacation rental. My wife has severe health issues which are extremely expensive. If my wife and kids and I had not had the income from this vacation rental and from managing the several others, we would not have made enough money from my Trooper's salary alone to make ends meet and there is no way we could have afforded to live in Bozeman. My wife is a Mandeville (5th generation Bozeman family), and I am a native Montanan (fourth generation). I will go out on a limb to say that we are the kind of people you want to have in your community. I believe if the city of Bozeman begins sanctioning and closing down vacation rentals for the sins of a few, we will not be able to afford to stay in Bozeman, and I don't think we are the only good citizens who can say that. Many of the individuals we pay to maintain the property, do the book keeping and snow removal etc. supplement their income through these vacation rentals the same way we do. They need it and so do we, and so do many others in the valley. Please consider this issue carefully and with wisdom. Please have faith in your fellow citizens' ability to make good decisions about what to do with their own property. Thank you. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 175 of 330 Vicki Davies inside Bozeman January 2, 2017, 9:55 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - The city should support small businesses and allow its residence to supplement their incomes. Gentrification has arrived. Property owners pay a hefty tax both city & county. STR are well kept and peer reviewed. A Poorly managed ill kept STR can't compete. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. Other - I was a long term landlord for 16+ years. Now with STR I feel more connected with house and the neighborhood. I am physically at the property 95% more than when it was a LTR, I have complete control - the Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 176 of 330 home and property has never looked better. Please share any additional comments. Short term rentals in the city limits are less than 1% of total housing units. I wonder why this is even an issue , it's shutting down local tax paying residents trying to make ends meet. These STR landlords are great ambassadors for people visiting Bozeman and promote downtown businesses and restaurants. Staying in local neighborhoods amongst local people is a unique and authentic travel experience , that leaves these travelers with a positive impression and a strong desire to return. This sentiment can be found over and over in the glowing reviews these people leave on STR websites about Bozeman STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 177 of 330 Tom Olliff inside Bozeman January 2, 2017, 4:33 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? No If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - They are likely to be just as good or better than some of the current long-term renters in the neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 178 of 330 Tom and Peggy Olliff 813 South 5th Bozeman, MT 59715 Dear Assistant City Manager Chuck Winn, We are writing to speak out AGAINST the ban on short-term rentals in Bozeman (VRBO, AirBnB, etc.). It seems so much like a solution seeking a problem. In our opinion, it would be much more productive to address long-term rentals. We have three rentals to on our seven-house block, and seven if you round the corner. Some of the renters of great; some are very difficult. For example, when the new renters moved in across the street this fall, we and our neighbors lodged at least 3 noise complaints in the first week. We have called in numerous noise complaints on renters in the last several years—always for loud, raucous parties that extend into the wee hours of the morning. The bad renters fail to shovel their walks in the winter, park anywhere and everywhere, and allow garbage to spill from overfilled cans. We have personally had two cars hit; almost everyone in the neighborhood has had a car hit, generally by a drunk driver trying to get home from a party. Again, only some of the renters are bad—we have a house on the corner that has had fantastic renters for 3 years now and other rental houses that have great occupants. However, given the choice, we would take a short-term rental any day. At least if you have a bad neighbor you only have them for a week or so. The next short-term renter is likely to be better. If you feel strongly that short-term rentals must be regulated, then consider regulating only stand-alone homes. If a homeowner lives in a house with an ADU out back, the homeowner can address any problems with the short-term renter. A second option would be to regulate only in the most restrictive zoning areas, R1 and historic. Frankly, we don’t see the need for such regulations at all. Rentals are already a problem in many neighborhoods. Short-term rentals would, in many cases, be an improvement. Thank you, Tom and Peggy Olliff Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 179 of 330 Otto Pohl inside Bozeman January 2, 2017, 4:06 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Part-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - Increases revenue for downtown businesses; Helps give visitors a great experience, building revenue and positive long-term growth of the city; encourages density and combats sprawl; Helps local homeowners make ends meet If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To pay the mortgage. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 180 of 330 I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. Please share any additional comments. Short-Term Rentals are a non-issue. I believe sensible, low-impact management of the issue is all that is needed. Let’s look at the facts: LOW VOLUME: According to Commissioner Mehl, that there are over 19,000 houses in Bozeman, and estimated that there may be approximately 300 vacation rentals in the town. That’s 1.5%. That’s not an epidemic—it’s pretty much a non-issue. In a city block with 10 homes, there is an 85% chance that there’s not a single vacation rental on the block—and even if there is it’s still a high likelihood that it won’t be rented all year, since most vacation rentals are offered by traveling homeowners looking for a little extra income to help cover the mortgage. NOT A PROBLEM: According to city records, there have been three complaints recorded over the decades. THREE! I bet there have been more complaints about virtually any other issue, including pets, city sidewalks, parking, you name it. WHAT ABOUT PROTECTING “THE NEIGHBORHOOD FABRIC”? That sounds like one of those mom and apple-pie type things to defend, but what does it really mean? People are moving in and around all the time. In rental blocks there is constant turnover. Are travelers coming to town are ripping apart this mythical fabric in a way that renters don’t? Many of the vacation renters are parents visiting their children who are studying at MSU, former residents visiting local friends, or couples trying out neighborhoods before committing to a long-term lease or a home purchase. Just because they’re staying at an address less than 30 days doesn’t mean you’re not part of the greater community fabric. SO WHY IS THIS EVEN AN ISSUE? It seems that there happens to be one block on Cleveland Avenue with several vacation rentals, and there happen to be a few very vocal, upset neighbors. Maybe that’s something that needs to be dealt with, but it seems to hardly rise to the threshold where government is justified in limiting homeowner rights. CURRENT REGULATIONS COULD USE WORK: Let’s streamline the registration process. Using the CUP process is a square peg in a round hole. It should not require thousands of dollars, months of time, or individual Commission scrutiny to permit a vacation rental. There should be a simple issuance of a business permit and license. The default position of the city should be to allow vacation rentals. By the way, the state already acts that way—it takes minutes to register with the state of Montana to collect and remit bed tax. That’s the way it should be. WHAT ABOUT COMPLAINTS? The complaint process should also be streamlined, and any vacation rental with a sufficient number of complaints should be subject to fines, or perhaps having a license revoked. To the degree that you feel it’s worth commission time to work on this non-problem at all, this is where I would spend the most time. The city does not limit homeowner rights if a long-term renter creates a disturbance, so why should a short-term renter trigger that? It seems like an issue of fundamental fairness. However, it seems like some sort of recourse for properties with persistent noise complaints may be valid. REMEMBER MONTANA’S LIVE-AND-LET-LIVE HERITAGE: Creating onerous legislation for this non-issue Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 181 of 330 would be a classic case of government overreach, and at odds with the governing philosophy here in Montana. Let’s streamline the current registration process, monitor the situation, and move on to important issues. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 182 of 330 Sara Erickson inside Bozeman January 2, 2017, 2:45 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - It brings income from tourism to our area. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 183 of 330 Please share any additional comments. Short term rental customers should be required to follow all the same rules and regulations as regular residents. Individuals that are not following rules should be dealt with individually. Bringing Short term rental customers to an area can be great for tourism and increase our economy. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 184 of 330 Lincoln Erickson inside Bozeman January 2, 2017, 12:03 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 185 of 330 Short term rentals should be allowed. They should be treated similar to commercial business in Bozeman and should require a permit/license yearly inspection etc. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 186 of 330 Penny Murray inside Bozeman January 2, 2017, 10:18 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Other - too many in one area decimates the neighborhood density Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Other - I understand all the reasons above Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 187 of 330 Please share any additional comments. Given the limited number of hotel rooms in Bozeman and the ongoing high demand for temporary housing and vacation rentals, homeowners should be allowed to operate a STR as a business. However, they must pay the bed tax, be licensed and insured and inspected as any other lodging business. Too much STR density will reduce the vibrancy and community of our neighborhoods and have an effect on affordable housing and long term rental housing availability. Bozeman has always been short on rental housing and it has always been expensive. STRs could certainly exacerbate the problem by reducing the limited inventory and raising prices if allowed to run rampant. No one wants to see residents pushed out by STRs. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 188 of 330 Jan Davis inside Bozeman January 1, 2017, 5:08 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have no impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 189 of 330 No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 190 of 330 Kathy Powell inside Bozeman January 1, 2017, 4:02 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Litter Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Safety issues Other - Revolving door of people; loss of real neighbors & that could be part of neighborhood, people don't know are staying over nite in neighborhood more frequently, with more STRs in a neighborhood the neighborhood changes from residential to motel district Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 191 of 330 Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Any STR should have a current permit (including Health & Safety, fire inspection) and that permit should run with the owner, not the property. Permit or license should be renewed annually with a fee. Should be financial penalty if STR is not licensed. License can be revoked if there are problems. STRs in R1 should be few to none. In R2 could have some but density is key. Too many turns a neighborhood into a motel district. Maybe a lottery when an opening comes up in an area with density cap? On-site owner is best. Property managers are often not available (voice mailbox full) or don't respond in timely manner. Enforcement is key - whatever ordinance is adopted, it must be able to have enforcement follow thru. And that includes checking Air BnB, VRBO, etc to see that listings do have valid permits. Maybe list permit number on websites where posted as STR. Also, finding a place to rent and live in Bozeman is a challenge. Some regulated STRs seem reasonable, but STRs can reduce the long term rental options that are available - both affordable and those more expensive. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 192 of 330 Ashley Kloster inside Bozeman January 1, 2017, 3:23 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 193 of 330 Short term rentals bring in more tourism dollars to the city and help locals pay their mortgages. They have no negative impact on a neighborhood. The whining of a few elitist individuals shouldn't overrun someone's property rights. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 194 of 330 Rachel York inside Bozeman January 1, 2017, 3:18 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 195 of 330 No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 196 of 330 Adam Nolastname inside Bozeman January 1, 2017, 3:14 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - It's good for the economy If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - I don't believe there is any negative impact Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 197 of 330 Please share any additional comments. The city should not interfere with an individual's personal property rights unless the use of the property overtly and negligently affects others. Short term rentals generally do not negatively affect others but may be an annoyance to the vocal over-privileged few with the free time to worry about such trivial things. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 198 of 330 Kathleen Rabel inside Bozeman January 1, 2017, 12:17 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 199 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 200 of 330 Kathryn Manning inside Bozeman January 1, 2017, 11:46 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - Gives people a chance to make money while they are traveling or away. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Effect on supply of housing Safety issues Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 201 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 202 of 330 James Walseth inside Bozeman January 1, 2017, 11:29 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Part-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - Provides a source of income for some neighbors. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Other - Short term rentals are often empty, the neighborhood feels depopulated. Short term occupants also have no real involvement with the neighborhood or city issues, resulting in a dilution of community. There is increasing anonymity and depersonalization. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 203 of 330 I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. Please share any additional comments. Thank you for working on this complex issue. There is no clear cut solution that solves the issues so a compromise is needed. The flexibility of the short term rental has many benefits for owners and visitors, but we do not want Bozeman to become one giant hotel, which is the end game of the commodification of the home. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 204 of 330 george thompson inside Bozeman January 1, 2017, 9:56 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - Short term rentals only benefit absentee landlords. We buy homes to raise our families and enjoy the benefits of long term friendships with our neighbors. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Other - Our homes and neighbors are a sanctuary in midst of work life balance. Living next door to a motel was an option we declined. We depend on neighbors to help our elderly, keep a watchful eye on each others kids, and notice strangers in the area. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Commercial areas They should not be allowed in the City of Bozeman. How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Other - Simply provides a revenue stream detrimental to quality of neighborhood Please share any additional comments. If someone wants to buy a retirement home in Bozeman, they can have 12 month leases. STR's are simply a way to to skirt motel zoning regulations, resulting in change of zoning which neighbors did not buy into. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 205 of 330 Jenifer Lower inside Bozeman January 1, 2017, 8:08 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. Please share any additional comments. These types of rentals provide great opportunities for families and friends to vacation together. I have had Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 206 of 330 parents visit students and very much enjoy a more homey environment. It is a positive experience for most visitors and they frequently return to spend money in our beautiful town. I also travel using vacation rentals for the same reasons. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 207 of 330 Michelle Clark-Conley outside Bozeman December 31, 2016, 1:04 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Nonresident of Bozeman. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - Brings tourism money into the local economy If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 208 of 330 We are also having this issue in Big Sky. Many Big Sky Area employees used to look to Bozeman for affordable and/or dog friendly housing options. STRs have made long term housing issues more difficult in both places. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 209 of 330 jane klockman inside Bozeman December 31, 2016, 12:06 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Litter Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Safety issues Other - Makes afffordable houses less available. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 210 of 330 Please share any additional comments. Short term rentals obviously are profitable. If unchecked, I see Bozeman following towns and cities in the US and abroad, cities that offer popular vacation venues, becoming yet another BIG tourist town, not our still cordial city of neighborhoods. I hope that the Commissioners have the guts to say "no" to a commercial take-over and "yes" to pleading residents like me. Jane Klockman Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 211 of 330 Laura Murphy inside Bozeman December 31, 2016, 8:59 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Safety issues Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) They should not be allowed in the City of Bozeman. How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. We have hotels, motels and short term cabin rentals outside the city limits. Residents with lower to middle class Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 212 of 330 incomes have a hard enough time securing a place to live. Opening up available housing to well to do visitors who can afford to rent outside the city limits or stay in our fancy new hotels will ruin the atmosphere of the community of Bozeman. We do not even have enough safe housing for residents and students. I have seen rentals of basements that are not even legal in Bozeman. No egress windows or escape routes. The city has not addressed these issues, yet they want to cater to wealthy non-residents who do not care about their impact on our neighborhoods? If they have enough money to vacation for a month, they have enough money to stay somewhere else. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 213 of 330 Michael Herring inside Bozeman December 30, 2016, 10:21 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Other - When the owner is not present, it becomes a short-term hotel-house. I don't get to know these people over time, and they don't get to know me. The cohesive sense of a neighborhood ("we're in this together") is lost.That's not what led me to move here Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 214 of 330 Please share any additional comments. I have no problem with a resident renting out a well-maintained room or 2 in their home/on their home property, as long as there are regulations about noise/number of tenants. My concern is about short-term rentals with no owner present, and the way they impact a neighborhood's character. Given the choice between 1)purchasing a home on a block where all the other homes are owner-occupied, or 2)purchasing a home on a block where half of the houses are owned by absentee owners who rent them out, I think that most people would prefer to live on the block where the neighboring houses are owner-occupied. To proponents of short-term rentals without the owner present, I would ask which neighborhood you would prefer to live in.... I would certainly prefer to live among long-term neighbors that I know than among an endless parade of one- nighters. While I understand that VRBO's can give visitors a nice sense of what it would like to live in one of our nice older neighborhoods, I don't feel obligated to provide them that experience if doing so alters the character of our town. Which, I believe, it does. And I don't understand why we are limiting the discussion to R0 through R2 districts. If we have to change zoning ordinances now to allow for prohibition of short-term rentals, why can we ONLY change zoning in these districts? Why not R3 and R4? I would argue that the character of my R4 neighborhood is just as important to me as the southside R1 residents is to them. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 215 of 330 Joanna Harper inside Bozeman December 30, 2016, 8:02 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 216 of 330 No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 217 of 330 Jane Hamner inside Bozeman December 30, 2016, 6:12 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Safety issues Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) They should not be allowed in the City of Bozeman. How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 218 of 330 Jim Drummobnd inside Bozeman December 30, 2016, 2:59 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. We have several short term rentals in my neighborhood in SE Bozeman. Prior to being rentals, they were rented to groups of students who created traffic problems, noise, never mowed the lawn or shoveled the walks, barking dogs, left garbage on the lawn, etc. Since being converted to STR's, they are well maintained, clean Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 219 of 330 and quiet. The only way to determine that they are a STR is by looking at the license plates of the cars parked out front. That said, I don't think we want to see STR's lining each street (intersperse with other family owned SFR's), and they should pay the same lodging fees/tax as other lodging to support tourism promotion and public expenses. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 220 of 330 Ray Pratt inside Bozeman December 30, 2016, 1:52 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Litter Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. I live on a block with 4 rental units and have had to call police many times because of noise, beer bottles, smoke from huge fire pits, parking of multiple vehicles, and people in street or on sidewalks at late hours.. My Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 221 of 330 wife has been threatened by renters who followed her home after she complained of noise. A house behind us is often used as a short term rental and creates parking problems, trash, and noise and smoke from grills. It appears the Commission is largely favorable to owners using property for this purpose while long term residents (I have lived and owned my house for 33 years) suffer the consequences. This is not the kind town I want to live in if only owners of rental units and large scale developers are those most listened to by the Commission and not adequately regulated for peace, quiet, and good public order. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 222 of 330 Dianne Click outside Bozeman December 30, 2016, 11:42 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. Other - It allows homeowners assistance with financially keeping their house but perhaps spending part of the year in another climate or traveling. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 223 of 330 The market will dictate the condition and cleanliness of a STRs by the online feedback it receives through the various hosting sites. Over-regulation of these STRs will just create more work for the city and greater cost to the Owner. I do believe that each STR should be registered with the City for security reasons and renewed annually to stay on the radar. There are travelers that will only stay in hotels/motels, and then there are travelers that want the community feel. Why turn away potential future Bozeman residents? Perhaps these individuals who rent STRs are just trying to get a feel of what it would be like to live in Bozeman. A test drive of sorts. Owning a STR is work and comes at a cost if done correctly. The market will tell us if saturation has occurred. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 224 of 330 Sara Goulden inside Bozeman December 30, 2016, 11:07 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Litter Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Safety issues Other - no regulation (e.g, health and safety) Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 225 of 330 Please share any additional comments. Income property management companies and absentee landlords are destroying neighborhoods in Bozeman. It appears that the city supports those interests at the expense of other community members. People who are just passing through have no long-term investment in the neighborhoods. Having lived in Bozeman for over thirty years, I have noticed a trend in the the behavior of short-term and long-term renters: A disregard and disinterest in municipal ordinances concerning noise, trash, loud parties, unsafe pit fires, parking violations, number of legal residence violations; a general attitude of entitlement. A family in our neighbor recently moved because of the noise, trash, verbal insults, drunken parties in the rental property next door to them. This is unacceptable. Good people should not be driven from our communities! Enforcement of municipal ordinances would be a help to deal with the problem. We may be driven from our neighborhood, but not without having our concerns voiced. I have called the police, enforcement officers (parking/safety and health ), contacted landlords, written letters etc. I have not been passive on this issue. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 226 of 330 Suzanne Held inside Bozeman December 30, 2016, 10:49 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - STRs where there are homeowners on-site are fine. We had an STR without a home owner on site and we had problems with noise. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Noise Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Other - If there are STRs, it does change the neighborhood character. I know my other neighbors and feel that we watch out for each other. It isn't the case with STRs. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) They should not be allowed in the City of Bozeman. How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. I think these regulations should apply to all R zoned areas versus just R1, R2, R3. I feel there is no difference Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 227 of 330 between my neighborhood feeling like a neighborhood (R4) and an R1 or R2 - they are all neighborhoods and should be regulated similarly. The concerns are similar across R zoning. I am fine with owner-occupied STRs - we have an owner-occupied STR across our alley and it has been fine. We had an STR not owner-occupied across the street and it was noisy (to where we had to call the police at 2 in the morning) and the people staying there did not respect the neighborhood. Thanks for taking comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 228 of 330 C Spojis inside Bozeman December 30, 2016, 9:54 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 229 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 230 of 330 Erin Mandeville inside Bozeman December 30, 2016, 9:01 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I have no opinion on how they impact my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. This is not a housing issue. Short term rentals don't prevent long term rentals, it's a totally different type of Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 231 of 330 lessor. It is more intensive for the owner than long term rentals, but provides a holiday option for families who want to see Bozeman, but can't afford/don't want every meal out. We rely heavily on short term rentals traveling. Additionally, with the cost of housing in Bozeman, many folks are able to do Air B&B or rent their own home whilst traveling. This is a benefit of home ownership and isn't the city's business to regulate. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 232 of 330 Martin Coleman inside Bozeman December 30, 2016, 8:45 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. Other - It's a way to allow long term residents to stay in their homes If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Other - If the owner is not present the renters don't know how to coexist in the neighbor. For example, leash laws, noise; parking Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 233 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 234 of 330 April Scharen outside Bozeman December 30, 2016, 8:06 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Nonresident of Bozeman. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - They provide a ruchet, more "localized" experience for visitors. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Litter Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 235 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 236 of 330 L K inside Bozeman December 30, 2016, 7:32 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Litter Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) They should not be allowed in the City of Bozeman. How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. I feel STRs have a significant effect on housing; renting in Bozeman is extremely difficult. Rentals are difficult to come by and are very expensive. Allowing STRs in Bozeman will eventually make it too difficult for Bozeman residents to live here, unless they are fortunate enough to already own a house. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 237 of 330 Wes Gilbert inside Bozeman December 30, 2016, 6:20 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. I believe STRs can have a positive impact if done correctly. They provide a temporary means of housing for individuals who want to stay in Bozeman for extended periods of time without having to stay in a hotel. My family recently stayed in a VRBO home while visiting us for Christmas and it was a wonderful experience. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 238 of 330 Drew Thate inside Bozeman December 30, 2016, 2:20 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Part-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have no impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 239 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 240 of 330 Charlene Owens outside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 10:17 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have no impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 241 of 330 Joy Schroeder inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 9:40 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. Other - It's a creative way for people to use their property to earn extra money. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 242 of 330 Please share any additional comments. The market regulates the STR because of the ratings. Owners are motivated to keep their ratings up. Also, STRs generally have less negative impact on the properties because of the shorter stay of renters. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 243 of 330 Katherine Dayton inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 8:38 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. Other - The houses get upgraded and owners can make some income. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. Other - To keep the places in better condition than when they were long-term, mostly college, rentals. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 244 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 245 of 330 Michael Dougherty inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 8:21 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... No response Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 246 of 330 Matt Trebella inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 7:49 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. Other - It gives people moving to the area to get a feel for the neighborhood prior to moving here If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 247 of 330 Our STR has been in place for about a year now, and we've always fully complied with inspections, business licenses, and paying the occupancy taxes. We want to make sure that others running STRs are doing the same. Our experience has been that many guests are using STR for mid-term housing ranging from a few weeks to months as they are here for a semester or are in the process of moving to Bozeman, or building a house. We feel that this niche fits exceptionally well for STRs, and these people should not have to use a hotel for such an extended stay. In addition, we feel that our STR guest have been more courteous, taken better care of the property and neighborhood than all of our previous long-term renters. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 248 of 330 Sandy Feeney inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 7:33 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To pay the mortgage. Please share any additional comments. City regulation should be minimal, permitting and collecting the bed tax. I had a vacation rental for about 4 Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 249 of 330 years and we were legal, paying for the permit and collecting the bed tax (done by my property manager). We recently sold that property. One of the reasons we sold was because so many more properties became rentals and a lot of them are flying under the radar. If a location is not legal they should be stopped from having the rental. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 250 of 330 Sue Mills inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 7:19 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 251 of 330 Lori Lawson inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 6:36 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - Long term rentals are more of a concern to me. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 252 of 330 We attempted to get a permit years ago for both a long term and short term rentals but there are prohibitive restrictions (one parking space per bedroom with only one one vehicle allowed on-street allowed - eg a 4 bedroom home needs 3 certified parking spaces - and you can not stack cars in the driveway so the rule requires a 3-car garage or official parking space) That rule will exclude most every home owner in downtown Bozeman from being granted a permit - so that needs to be dealt with first. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 253 of 330 Robert Harris Harris inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 6:09 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Part-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 254 of 330 There is little evidence that short-term rentals negatively effect housing options to any great extent. Typically a short-term rental is a viable option for a homeowner who needs intermittent use of property for themselves or for a homeowner who travels a good deal and does not want the property to be empty during intermittent extended periods. This is typically a situation that is not conducive to long-term rental. Despite the fact that long-term rentals are generally more profitable and easier to manage than the more maintenance/care intensive short-term rental, long-term rentals are often simply not viable for many homeowners based on their own use of their homes. If short term rental is not an option in some zones, the result will be under-utilized residences and a decrease in the vitality of the Bozeman Community. It seems that lower density R1 & R2 neighborhoods with larger lots and generally larger setbacks provide greater property buffers and are very well suited for vacation rentals and attractive to families visiting Bozeman. I understand the need for certain controls but, do not understand the justification for eliminating the short-term rental option in these zones. Despite some concerns based largely on anecdotal evidence (and/or simple NIMBY reactions) short-rentals are largely better maintained and kept to a higher standard of care than other types of rental properties. They provide a positive community service both homeowners and visitors, and help make Bozeman a friendly, diverse, and enjoyable community. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 255 of 330 Carl Strong inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 5:55 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Other - Many STR are owned by out of state owners, often Trusts or LLC. There is no point of contact if troubles arise. There is also a loss of sense of neighborhood. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 256 of 330 Please share any additional comments. I think it's important to recognize that there are several types of STR. There are the owners that rent space in their house but also live in it. There are those who rent their house while they are absent for extended periods of time, and there are those that are not used by the owner and operated as a commercial enterprise. I think that the requirements of the units that are being operated as a purely commercial business should have greater restrictions than those of an owner trying to augment their income. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 257 of 330 Julie Wrobel inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 5:54 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? No If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Noise Litter Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Other - My kids are free to run from house to house because we have taken the time to get to know the families on our street. I don't want strangers moving in and out and jeopardizing the safety/climate/closeness of our neighborhood. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Commercial areas They should not be allowed in the City of Bozeman. How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 258 of 330 Please share any additional comments. We moved to Bozeman 2 years ago from another community that allows STRs. I watched STRs severely restrict the housing supply for middle income families, noticeably widening the gap between upper and lower incomes. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 259 of 330 SYLVIE KERN inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 4:32 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Part-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I have no opinion on how they impact my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Effect on supply of housing Safety issues Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 260 of 330 Shar Carraway inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 4:23 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 261 of 330 Emily Hooker inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 4:09 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Noise Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Safety issues Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. We own an ADU above our garage for which we received a CUP when we built it. We have never used it as a STR. Our children stay there when visiting. That being said, why allow an entire property to be rented as a Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 262 of 330 STR while at the same time require the owner of an ADU to be living on the premises if it is rented as a STR? Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 263 of 330 Alyssa Hitchcock inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 4:00 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 264 of 330 No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 265 of 330 Mary Ellen Wolfe inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 3:25 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Other - Loss of neighbors who we know. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 266 of 330 No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 267 of 330 Diane Ingalls outside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 3:15 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have no impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. Please share any additional comments. I own a vacation rental in Valley West, When asking a neighbor about their experience with a vacation rental next-door, her response was positive. I feel that it is a homeowners right to have a vacation rental as an investment as long as it does not impact the neighborhood. Vacation rentals are meticulously maintained, Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 268 of 330 better than Long term rentals adjacent to our property. Furthermore, do not feel that hotels should have a monopoly, Bozeman is a tourist town and our pain guests should have options to fit their needs. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 269 of 330 Dick Stefani inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 2:56 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? No If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have no impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 270 of 330 Candice Mendenhall inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 12:41 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? No If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. My adult children use STRs frequently when traveling on vacations and find them much more comfortable than Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 271 of 330 hotels. An owner of a home/apartment should have the flexibility to utilize STRs as a way to offset their costs. The risk of STR renters causing problems are vey minor in my opinion...the benefits far outweigh the risks. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 272 of 330 Erin McHenry inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 12:29 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have no impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. I don't think you should prohibit or limit but I do think its reasonable to have them inspected. For a lot of folks the Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 273 of 330 option of a short term rental might help with the exceedingly high cost of living in Bozeman. In case you don't know -its really expensive to live here. A reasonable fee to register (maybe $75 -$100 yearly) would allow people to be honest and yet still benefit. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 274 of 330 Beth Antonopulos inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 12:07 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Litter Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Safety issues Other - R1&2 should be about making homes not making business opportunities.Investors are buying homes to cash in on rising prop. values & using VRBOs to pay expenses in meantime.This use has nothing to do w/ residential neighborhoods & no benefits for the city! Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 275 of 330 Please share any additional comments. If we want to preserve Bozeman's small-town feel, even in the face of growth, we need to maintain neighborhood quality. Changing our residential neighborhoods' focus from permanent residents' needs to catering to the desires of out-of-town investors and visitors will make us into a resort town in a hurry. Please consider the full-time residents, not just those of wealthy visitors, second-home owners, and realtors. We have zoning regulations for a reason, and we should enforce them. The occasional renting out of a room or the several-weeks-a-year STR of a home that has a permanent resident is not really a problem in my mind because the resident owner has a clear interest in being a good neighbor. However, the granting of COPs to allow permanent mini-hotels really should have no place in R1/2 zones. There is no benefit to the community in allowing these, and how do you say "yes" to a few and "no" to everyone else? We need residential neighborhoods full of engaged citizens who care about their homes and environment, not transient visitors. Hotels, hostels, and guest houses in properly zoned areas supply plenty of choices for guests to Bozeman. Leave the residential neighborhoods for year-round residents please! Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 276 of 330 Jack Tyler inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 12:04 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. The glaring error in the current STR policy is the assumption that higher density residential neighborhoods are so unimpacted by STRs that a) no CUP is necessary, and so b) less oversight or control is exercised by the Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 277 of 330 City. E.g. most R-1 streets have few parked vehicles. My area is mostly R-3 and R-4. The cost of housing (and so rentals) is so high that many higher density residences house multiple unassociated renters. Each renter brings their own household 'stuff' with them, and garages quickly fill up. This leaves the streets for resident parking, with each renter resident having at least one vehicle, sometimes two. Normally, STRs often bring more than one vehicle into the STR's neighborhood. In higher density residential zones, there is by definition more noise and other physical impacts to all the area's residents. Now add STRs' popularity during significant athletic events, during graduation ceremonies, and at special civic event times. Celebrating is a natural part of visiting Bozeman at times like these. High density area residents suffer the most at these times. One wonders: How could the City have possibly concluded there is no need for STR oversight in higher density residential areas?! Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 278 of 330 Kent Madin inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 11:30 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. Other - This non-traditional use of homes is inevitable and offers great financial benefits to homeowners. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Other - Neighborhood character doesn't have to change, it depends on how greedy owners are and how diligently owners set a firm and clear tone for behavior. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 279 of 330 Please share any additional comments. We own an STR but it is B3 zoned, so much of this issue does not directly effect our STR. That said, these are my thoughts regarding the larger issue given our own very positive experience so far as owners. The STR question is analogous to the infamous "Commons" and it's tragedy wherein both laziness and individual greed destroy the very resource everyone shares. The way to address this is with regs that codify the more tangible standards (code compliance, tax collection, noise regs) and also the less tangible issue of the overall "character or tone" of STR renting in Bozeman. To the latter end, I would ban "instabook" across the board (in the long term, this could be a positive marketing move as well. It never hurts to make your product just a little more exclusive). Both the major players, VRBO and Airbnb, offer a version of "instabook" where anyone can confirm a rental without any vetting by the owner. This ease of use/lazy procedure moves the process away from responsibility and diligence on the part of both renter and owner. Being willing to invest the time and know SOMETHING about the potential renter, their purpose in visiting bozeman, etc. is a first level of screening out undesirable uses and of establishing for the incoming renter that this is not just a cheap motel where they can behave badly. The simple step of disallowing Instant booking will weed out some of the lazy and the greedy owners and would insure that fewer "hidden costs" in the form of bad actors, unsafe situations, curdled neighborhood feelings, police calls, are born by the owner, not the community at large. Banning instabook means that the original notion of Airbnb (promoting people getting to know each other and hence respect the process and place) is reinforced. If an owner can't find the time to vet their potential renters, then they are not serious about their responsibility to the larger community in terms of setting a positive "tone" for rentals in Bozeman. Banning instabook, as a way of fostering responsibility and accountability on both parties parts, is as understandable as requiring safe, code compliant spaces, transparent tax collection and payments, etc. All of those things, if enforced by a combination of regs and "tone" will ensure the long term sustainability of the str market. In this STR matter, the Commission has an opportunity to foster a distinctive "character" surrounding STR rentals in our town. Over time, word gets around that Bozeman and all it's STR owners share a common vision that balances safe, reasonable rentals with controls on the negative impacts. All STR rentals would benefit from the "buzz" on Airbnb and VRBO that Bozeman is a little different. If you are going to come here you need more than your credit card and a couple of clicks. You'll need to acknowledge the expected standards of behavior by the simple act of interacting with your host before being booked. And, if it is a regulation that no one can use instabook and be legal, then the playing field is flat. And to that end, I would suggest the City work up some kind of pledge or statement of purpose that any owner agrees to comply with and foster.. Something along the lines of "Bozeman is my home, a great place to live and work and visit. As a community we welcome STR guests who respect our rules and appreciate the small town values that we all hold dear" (anyhow, you get the idea...). This would then be featured on all the individual rental sites, could even have a checkbox to insure people have read it, like a terms of service agreement. If every STR in Bozeman, on all STR rental sites, featured that kind of pledge, it would be good marketing. It would also establish, from the gitgo, that we don't rent out "Animal houses" with their attendant headaches. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 280 of 330 Chris Hill outside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 11:18 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Litter Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Safety issues Other - It would adversely affect our feeling of community by removing longterm residents. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 281 of 330 Please share any additional comments. STRs would hurt Bozeman neighborhoods, including their home values and feeling of community while also hurting our lodging industry (hotels, motels and the local businesses surrounding them). Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 282 of 330 Fern Hoolan inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 11:18 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have no impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. Other - I currently do not own or operate a STR. I am very interested in converting my apartment into a STR for the reasons stated above. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 283 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 284 of 330 Paul Durham inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 11:07 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - It encourages diversity by helping low-income people to stay in our increasingly expensive neighborhood by allowing them to supplement their incomes. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 285 of 330 Please share any additional comments. I'm familiar with STRs as I use them when I travel and my friends offer them. They are self-regulating and offer almost no risk for the property-owner or neighbors, because the guest's reputation (access to the STR service) is on the line. In addition, Airbnb and other STRs offer millions of dollars in insurance guarantees to hosts and anyone affected by a guest's presence. In short, a house or apartment inhabited by a guest via STR is less likely to be a source of trouble and is more highly insured and protected than one inhabited by the owner or tenant. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 286 of 330 Kipjaz Savoie inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 11:00 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have no impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 287 of 330 Dan Porter outside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 10:58 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? No If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I have no opinion on how they impact my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 288 of 330 Kingsley Murphy inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 10:51 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. Other - Income for property owners If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 289 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 290 of 330 Beth Hallaren-Hilles inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 10:50 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have no impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 291 of 330 Bill Clem inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 10:47 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - Enables additional income for some in this high-cost housing market. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Effect on supply of housing Other - I think effects of Parking, Noise, Litter and Character are simply excuses hiding Bigotry by some in the neighborhood. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 292 of 330 I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Personally my family does not stay in hotels anymore when on vacation as we would rather be part of the community. We have found the ability to rate owners and their STR and their rating of us as renters, to be much more conducive to a good experience for ourselves. We try very hard to be a burden to the neighborhood, community or city. There are always some bad apples in both visitors and neighbors. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 293 of 330 Scott Dreblow inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 10:43 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - The income may help owners continue to own their properties. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Effect on supply of housing Other - Raises cost of rentals in addition to removing supply of rental units Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 294 of 330 Please share any additional comments. I feel the City must play a role in monitoring and regulating STRs, and ensuring that permitted properties are acting responsibly towards other residents and their neighborhood. Once the City has information on the number of properties and the problems encountered, it can consider what type and level of regulation is needed. My greatest concerns with STRs are reducing the amount of available housing for residents, and driving rental costs up for residents. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 295 of 330 shannon fair inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 10:38 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - Opportunity for my relatives to visit close by when my guest room is full. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... Other - I do not operate a STR but wold like the option if I needed to. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 296 of 330 Please share any additional comments. For many people this is a way for them to keep their homes when they fall into hard times. Also, properties are well maintained because their rental capability is dependent upon good reviews. I don't see a need for the city to collect fees and regulate STRs and I think STRs are good for the community. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 297 of 330 Thomas Wells inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 10:29 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Effect on supply of housing Safety issues Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 298 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 299 of 330 David Gianforte inside Bozeman December 29, 2016, 10:26 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - They allow homeowners to do what they want with their own homes. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 300 of 330 Carolyne Calvin inside Bozeman December 28, 2016, 7:38 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - They help homeowners offset mortgage costs. Tourists visiting like the homelike feeling of short term rentals over hotels If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Litter Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 301 of 330 To pay the mortgage. I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. My business is owning / operating and renting out properties. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 302 of 330 M. Beland inside Bozeman December 27, 2016, 4:54 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - My property I should do with it what I choose. Bozeman is unaffordable and it's a way for homeowners to subsidize the outrageous cost of living. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 303 of 330 I was born in Bozeman and educated elsewhere. Upon return to be closer to my family, it's alarming that the cost of Bozeman rivals urban enclaves (yet lacks much of the cultural infrastructure to make the costs worth living). If you want to attract and maintain the best in Montana, you'd better do what's necessary to incentivize living here. One way to do that is to allow home owners to subsidize the outrageous cost of living with Air B&B (if they so choose). We have enough insanity in this world without bored local government trying to take more of our money and regulate a tourist industry that should be available to anyone seeking entrepreneurship. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 304 of 330 Robert Dougherty inside Bozeman December 27, 2016, 11:46 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. Please share any additional comments. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 305 of 330 There are far fewer STR's in the city limits than has been reported: around 100 vs the city reporting 450. These 100 rentals represent less than a hundredth of a percent of the housing stock in Bozeman. The STR market is self regulating, thru competition and guests reviews. Most of these rentals are very well kept, much more than long term rentals, which are the real problem in our quaint neighborhoods. There are no regulations for long term rentals, and the slum lords in this town rarely work on their properties. The most desirable neighborhoods are surrounding downtown, and primarily have a R-2 zoning. If the city regulates STR to R-3 R-4 zoning districts they will have affectivley killed STR because that is not where people want to stay. I have told my guests that the city considers them not worthy of staying in our best neighborhoods, and they are shocked and offended. A small bed tax is acceptable and a health inspection should be required. This issue is being blown out of proportion. The city has so many real issues they should be addressing, but once again find a non-issue to distract from the overall gentrification of Bozeman, and the general mismanagement of the city services. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 306 of 330 Molly Yarnell inside Bozeman December 27, 2016, 9:07 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. Please share any additional comments. I encourage you to gather data to make informed decisions, not based off of emotional, exaggerated stories Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 307 of 330 from neighbors. Over 40% of the bookings on sites like Airbnb and VRBO also include long term stays (over 30 days). So these units are utilized as both short and long term. The classification is unclear. Why are we not evaluating/putting restrictions on all rentals? Both short and long term? Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 308 of 330 Kyler Harris outside Bozeman December 25, 2016, 8:29 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I have no opinion on how they impact my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - Short term rentals help both the tourism and real estate industry If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Let the free market work like it's supposed to. The reason there are a lot of short term rentals is because the Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 309 of 330 market demands it. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 310 of 330 Chris Torsleff inside Bozeman December 24, 2016, 11:28 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. My business is owning / operating and renting out properties. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 311 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 312 of 330 lisa thompson inside Bozeman December 24, 2016, 4:32 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Noise Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Safety issues Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) They should not be allowed in the City of Bozeman. How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. I can'tell stand living next door to a short term rental. The occupants are up really late, very loud and could care less they are in a neighborhood that has rules. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 313 of 330 Quinn Ellingson inside Bozeman December 23, 2016, 7:02 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. Other - Renters have always been respectful and often can be rated like the property owner. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - I don't thineed of them as negative, most people truly don't know there neighbors anyway, it's a excuse against it with no valid argument behind it. Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 314 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 315 of 330 Jason Delmue inside Bozeman December 23, 2016, 9:54 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. Other - A not insignificant portion of the renters are people who know they are moving to Bozeman or are considering it. It's nice to be able to let them know what the neighborhood and the community are like if they are not from a similar place. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 316 of 330 Other - My rental is adjacent to my house, and the backyards connect. It's very nice when my friends or family visit that they can stay right next-door and I can open up the fence and have a shared yard. Please share any additional comments. I made a spreadsheet to compare the profitability of my short-term rental versus renting it long-term. The return on investment was the same because the long-term rental avoids the landlord having to pay all the bills. With a short-term rental, I have to pay for utilities, cable, internet, and power plus cleaning and supplies like sheets and towels, cloth napkins, spices, and other cooking staples like flour, sugar, olive oil. Anyway, the return on investment was the same – and it was not high for either approach, only 4+%. I'm glad that you are gathering data. I have been discouraged to see so much opposition to short-term rentals being anecdote-based and suppositional (and incorrect). I was happy that former Director Thomas gathered data from the police department. It showed that short term rentals are no more likely than regular rentals to have emergency medical calls or need police assistance. This was contradictory to the suppositional anecdotal public comments which were to the effect that short-term rentals are often crammed full of out-of- town partiers with no vested interest in being good neighbors. Please make data-driven decisions, as opposed to being overly responsive to the vocal minority, which seems to be reacting out of fear and not necessarily supported by facts and data. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 317 of 330 James Tobin inside Bozeman December 22, 2016, 2:04 PM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Not sure If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have no impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 318 of 330 Mary Lou Osman inside Bozeman December 22, 2016, 11:16 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a negative impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Neighborhood character has changed (please explain in the "other" box) Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. My concern is for the character of the neighborhoods. Community is nurtured by the people who actually live there and share in the care of the neighborhood. If you do not know your neighbors, you can't really call it a neighborhood. You can be friendly with people who stay for 3 or 4 days but then they are gone and replaced Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 319 of 330 with new guests and you cannot build the connection that is a community. We choose to live in these neighborhoods because we value the connection with close neighbors. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 320 of 330 Susan Kirkland outside Bozeman December 22, 2016, 10:24 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Part-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Annually My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 321 of 330 Brett Hartnett inside Bozeman December 22, 2016, 8:56 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Part-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... To make additional income. To pay the mortgage. I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 322 of 330 Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 323 of 330 Gail Cary inside Bozeman December 22, 2016, 8:53 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have both positive and negative impacts on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) It's an opportunity to meet new people. STR properties are usually well cared for. If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Parking Effect on supply of housing Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Agree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. No response Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 324 of 330 Amy Ference inside Bozeman December 22, 2016, 8:48 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have a positive impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) STR properties are usually well cared for. There are fewer empty/dark houses in my neighborhood. Other - The quality of lodging offered combined with proximity to downtown has made this a more desirable neighborhood, as evidenced bff the 13% growth rate seen in home prices versus the 6% seen throughout the rest of the city in the same time span If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) Other - No negative impacts that aren't the same or worse when renting a room or apartment long-term without proper background checks Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Disagree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Agree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Only when initially permitted My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 325 of 330 I do not own / operate a STR. Please share any additional comments. Many of the concerns I've heard at city commission meetings and in public forums on this topic have revolved around a "me, me, me" mentality and have relied heavily on anecdotal data to support their position. I have personally lived in close proximity to young adults who have had the police over on numerous occasions, refused to turn down their music, etc, and these were people who had a one-year lease. Yet I don't believe based on my bad experiences that we should ban young adults from renting, or put undue burdens on landlords to be held personally responsible for the behavior of their tenants. I also once managed the old hostel on Olive where I met a large number of temporary visitors, from tourists to temporary construction workers to temporarily homeless families. I loved seeing my town through their eyes, sharing what makes Bozeman so magical, and seeing them fall in love just as I once had. I have used vacation rentals extensively when traveling as a way to be closer to the family members who travel to join us, relied on them heavily to house out-of-town guests at my wedding, and found them to be a great way to visit a new city and meet some locals who are willing to show us the best of their region. By and large, these rentals are already regulated by the federal government in that they are required to pay taxes and report earnings. I'm not exactly sure what the city of Bozeman would do regulation-wise, but I am concerned that it will over-complicate things, that it will be expensive to enforce, and that it will negatively impact our ability to bring our high cost of housing to an affordable level for the average family, as most families wouldn't dream of renting a room full-time but could easily offer that room for a few weeks in the winter and a few in the summer and get nearly the same return, allowing them to buy into a market that is quickly pricing out all but the millionaire class. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 326 of 330 MYOB MYOB inside Bozeman December 22, 2016, 8:07 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have no impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Agree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Disagree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Disagree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) Commercial areas How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Every 3 years My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... Other - I live with my partner and we both own our own places. It's easier to make my place a vacation rental (vs. long-term) as I don't have to remove the furniture. STR is great because there is less wear and tear on my property Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 327 of 330 Please share any additional comments. Please stop dawdling am make some decisions about STRs. It's not that hard - all it would take is to investigate a few places that have guidelines for STR and use this as a starting point for creating something for Bozeman. We're not the first community to deal with this and we could learn from others who have gone through the process. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 328 of 330 Gregory Gilpin inside Bozeman December 22, 2016, 8:06 AM Are you a full-time, part-time, or nonresident of Bozeman? Full-time Bozeman resident. Are there Short-Term Rentals in your neighborhood? Yes If you live in Bozeman, what is the impact of Short-Term Rentals (STRs) in your neighborhood? I feel STRs have no impact on my neighborhood. If you believe Short-Term Rentals (STRs) have positive impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response If you believe Short-Term Rentals have negative impacts, why? (select all that apply) No response Do you agree or disagree with the following regarding Short-Term Rentals (STRs)? STRs should require a permit and be assessed fees.: Disagree STRs should have a limit on the number of guests.: Agree There should be a density cap (only a certain number of STRs allowed per area/block).: Disagree The property owner should reside on-site.: Agree If the property owner is not on-site, there should be a local property manager / responsible person.: Disagree The City should not regulate STRs.: Agree Short-Term Rentals should be allowed in the following locations. (select all that apply) Low-density residential neighborhoods (mostly single-household) Medium-density residential neighborhoods (some single-household, some multi-household properties) High-density residential (mostly apartments, condos, multi-household properties) Mixed-use areas (some residential, some commercial) How often should Short-Term Rentals be inspected? Never My primary reason for owning / operating a Short-Term Rental (STR) is... I live there part-time and don't want to leave it empty. Please share any additional comments. When you have a big family and go on vacation, str makes it affordable. I rent out my house allows my family to afford a stay in someone else's house. We do this for three weeks of the year. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 329 of 330 Also, the market regulates itself. Noisy people get bad reviews then they can't rent again. We typically have had just a few people in our house. Lastly there isn't enough houses on str status to regulate. A few hundred is nothing. This is a non issue. Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana Short Term Rentals in Bozeman, Montana All Registered Responses sorted chronologically As of February 1, 2017, 12:17 PM http://www.peakdemocracy.com/4175 Page 330 of 330