HomeMy WebLinkAbout02-23-15 Woodcock Etha HotelFrom: Charlene Woodcock
To: Agenda
Cc: Kate Wiggins; Bruce Rinnert; Charlene Woodcock; jonnakurucz@yahoo.com Kurucz; ensennett@yahoo.com;
dougandjoyce@q.com Joyce Miller; posfig@gmail.com Junkin; Albertina Edelbut; fchhtanak@gmail.com;
jpjunkin@gmail.com; kcurotto@gmail.com; Jelt Belt; Reed Lehman; Barbara Allen; Jennifer Woodcock; Harvey
Wiggins; Tana Koelzer
Subject: National Guard Armory / Etha hotel
Date: Friday, February 20, 2015 10:27:11 PM
Having had no adequate reply to my question of how the city intends to compensate, or require the
Etha Hotel developer to compensate, all those Bozeman property owners and taxpayers whose
property value will be radically reduced by the construction of this speculative Mendenhall
development across the alley from 37 West Main Street, I resend my January 2 letter and
respectfully request a reply to this question. A city does not prosper by reducing the value of its
taxpayers' property.
Charlene M. Woodcock
From: Charlene Woodcock <charlene@woodynet.net>
To: agenda@bozeman.net
Sent: Friday, January 2, 2015 11:13 AM
Subject: National Guard Armory / Etha hotel
TO: The Mayor and City Commission
From: Charlene M. Woodcock
I own a condominium in the Hathhorn Building, 37 W Main D, occupied by my daughter and her
spouse. Its most valuable amenity is the view of the Bridger Mountains above the Armory and of
course the natural light from the north windows. I was horrified when I heard in 2013 about a
developer's plan to build a large hotel up from the handsome Willson-designed National Guard
Armory building and I sent a public comment then. Failure to obtain financing seemed to have killed
the project but I've learned that it was given a permit in November. Should this monster be built, it
would dwarf the Armory even if the facade is preserved, and it would block both natural light and
view of the mountains for the residents of multiple north-facing Main Street apartments, not to
mention increase traffic on Mendenhall and noise and congestion in the Main Street/Mendenhall
alley. Obviously property values and quality of life would be radically reduced for all those affected
by this project, and I would like to know what consideration the Commission gave to this
consequence of approval of the project? What are we to do with living spaces that lose their natural
light?
A new Westin Hotel will open this spring just a block away, conveniently located adjacent to the
parking garage. Should the city sacrifice a valued public building to duplicate an 8-story hotel in the
same area? Bozeman is so community oriented, it is disturbing that the Commission has approved
partial demolition of a public building and its conversion to private, for-profit development rather
than preserving it for public use as, for example, a community art museum, where its secure
construction would be an advantage.