Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout01-23-2012 edc memo, revised 1-20-12 Commission Memorandum qtt 88 9TlN co.gyp$ REPORT TO: Honorable Mayor and City Commission FROM: Aimee Kissel, Citizen Advisory Board Coordinator Stacy Ulmen CMC, City Clerk SUBJECT: Appointments to the Economic Development Council MEETING DATE: January 23, 2012 (Memo revised on 1-18-12 and 1-20-12) MEETING TYPE: Action RECOMMENDATION: Appoint up to two people to the Economic Development Council for a three year term. BACKGROUND: Two terms on the Economic Development Council expire February 1, 2012. Neither applicant has reapplied. Tie Fbuf Five new applications have been received. The creation and appointment of an Economic Development Council was recommended and described in the Economic Development Plan adopted by the City Commission on August 3, 2009. In February, 2010, the seven member Council was appointed. Shortly thereafter, the Council brought forward Ordinance No. 1784 adding Chapter 2.86 of the Bozeman Municipal Code for the official creation of the Economic Development Council and establishing the duties and responsibilities thereof. After initial appointments, council members shall serve three year staggered terms. Excerpt from the implementation matrix found on page VIII of the Economic Development Plan (EDP): 5. c "Establish an Economic Development Council, consisting o£ business leaders, city staff, economic development leaders, and others; to advise the City Commission on economic development issues and to review the implementation of this City of Bozeman Economic Development Plan." Applicants Gary Gannon John Hoagland— applicant added -18-12 Bryan Klein Teresa McKnight Jerry Pape—applicant added 1-20-12 Attachment: Council Applications mom fbeii CITY OF BOZEMAN, MONTANA APPLICATION FOR THE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COUNCIL Date: B 12-011 Name: � �y CANNO/\/ Physical Address: 4770 RtUMa RM M6,4-0 Mailing Address (if different): 0. /0S 3 Nf4N tW�" S97J j Email: NON, (;hR r e*0 Phonc(s): /0 G- Sp6 Length of time in the Bozeman area: Occupation: B IPe-55 owner leiv 2ElV&`Z. - Employer: C i� X12 je /NC, V6 (J& L-j G Ur&-S Have you ever served on a City or County board? MO (If so, where,what board, and how long?) X- ham.P -rD o(Z�►,4 u VZV- LOCAL 5V<VCTMUAr5 t a t-A-g +✓ Cl ri t�S C Lo e+Rt.Ly fOC v 5e dl o n 5 a LV c,3� 00M-?V<)< tYrRA 4 Q 6 0aW?16. Please explain your relevant qualifications, interests, and experiences. • L mt�-Tr r- �`-x pene n" b of vi)K? e 6r*AjrN� &5wesse5 W off.K Yt S'6�r up C-,Lo eAt Q rer przXrevwS ror '!�xiceAt canIF4rr C tT?�-5 • l4AVV- PAS 5'o,\ 46"-r 8o Zo-/VANJ zP0�MW-n A( -q-,50r� On NA160 W tmr-ct r4h*5 P V4wielkiq w/ MSu ON iNtTA-nQ0-5 "M 6VILd References (Individual or Organization)Name: Phone: 43«< snpmf2r 57? -o334 PAO ft<4AU1, VeAN m5V CoLL96V o-�; f309AC.S Q'A'4- �4�3 �kA78L 19- N1916-T r C t)Y or 80ZG�Afq 5's a - 23 I -:� This application is considered public record. Application contact information may be displayed on the City of Bozeman website. PLEASE NOTE. Per Ordinance No. I759, revising Chapter 2.01 of the Bozeman Municipal Code, all board members are required to attend a yearly ethics workshop provided free of charge by the City as a condition of service as a member of a board. Print form email form CITY OF BOZEMAN, MONTANA APPLICATION FOR THE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COUNCIL Date: November 28,2011 Name: Bryan Klein Physical Address: 1612 West Main Street Mailing Address (if different): Email: bklein @americanbankmontana.com Phone(s): 406.522.3538 Length of time in the Bozeman area: 10+years Occupation: Bank President Employer: American Bank Have you ever served on a City or County board? No (If so, where, what board, and how long?) Please explain your relevant qualifications, interests, and experiences. As the president of a locally owned community bank I am dedicated to the economic success of Bozeman and the surrounding area. Experience includes 20+ years banking in Montana, graduate degree, and multiple years of service on boards of service organizations and non profits. Currently member of Young Presidents Organization and a board member of Montana Bankers Assoc. References (Individual or Organization)Name: Phone: Don Cape Jr.-President/Owner of Old Chicago,Hilton Garden Inn(Bozeman and Billings) 406.624.0382 Rick Ungersma-President/Owner of Murdochs 406.587.5846 Kim Wild-President/Owner of TowHaul 406.388.3424 This application is considered public record. Application contact information may be displayed on the City of Bozeman website. PLEASE NOTE: Per Ordinance No. 1759, revising Chapter 2.01 of the Bozeman Municipal Code, all board members are required to attend a yearly ethics workshop provided free of charge by the City as a condition of service as a member of a board. Print form email form CITY OF BOZEMAN, MONTANA APPLICATION FOR THE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COUNCIL Date:January 5,2012 Name: Teresa W.McKnight Physical Address: 910 Technology Blvd.,Suite A Mailing Address (if different): Email: tmcknight @montana.edu Phone(s): (406)580-7002/cellular and(405)994-4821/office Length of time in the Bozeman area: 1 1/2 months Occupation: Executive Director of Montana State University Innovation Campus Employer: Montana State University/Montana State University Foundation Have you ever served on a City or County board? Yes (If so, where, what board, and how long?) City of Brookings Transportation Board -4 years City of Brookings Health System (Hospital Board of Trustees) - 2 years Please explain your relevant qualifications, interests, and experiences. 25-years in developing university-related research parks; economic development; incubation and entrepreneurial activities; business development; business recruitment and retention; master-planning; consulting, References (Individual or Organization) Name: Phone: Tom McCoy,Vice-President for Research,Montana State University (406)994-2891 Michael Stevenson,President&CEO,Montana State University Foundation (406)994-2053 Chris Kulkulski,City Manager,City of Bozeman (406)582-2306 This application is considered public record. Application contact information may be displayed on the City of Bozeman website. PLEASE NOTE: Per Ordinance No. 1759, revising Chapter 2.01 of the Bozeman Municipal Code, all board members are required to attend a yearly ethics workshop provided free of charge by the City as a condition of service as a member of a board, email form CITY OF BOZEMAN, MONTANA APPLICATION FOR THE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COUNCIL Date: 1/17/2012 Name: John Hoagland Physical Address: 150 Village way Mailing Address (if different): 101 Evergreen Drive Email: Joagland@simmsfishing.com Phone(s): office-406-585-3557 cell-406-599-8393 Length of time in the Bozeman area: 2 Years Occupation: Vice-President Employer: Simms Fishing Products Have you ever served on a City or County board? yes (If so, where, what board, and how long?) Chairman Board of Selectman, Marion Massachusetts 3 Years Selectman, Marion Board of Selectmen 6 Years Please explain your relevant qualifications, interests, and experiences. Moved to Bozeman 2 Years Ago. Interested in getting involved in community. Served as Chief Executive of Marion for 3 Years. Responsible for 5,000 person government. Bring local private business experience as well as 30 years global private and public company business experience References (Individual or Organization)Name: Phone: K.C.Walsh President, Simms Fishing Products 406-585-3557 Will Brooke Attorney 406-581-0200 Dr. Blair Erb Doctor Bozeman/Deaconess 406-522-3959 This application is considered public record. Application contact information may be displayed on the City of Bozeman website. PLEASE NOTE: Per Ordinance No. 1759, revising Chapter 2.01 of the Bozeman Municipal Code, all board members are required to attend a yearly ethics workshop provided free of charge by the City as a condition of service as a member of a board. Print form ill form CITY OF BOZEMAN,MONTANA P CATION FOR THE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COUNCIL Date: l( Name: d Physical Addre: Mailing Address(if different), Email:_ Phone(s)- Length of time in the Bozeman area: Occupation; Employer: Xc Have you ever served on a City or County board? _ (If so,where,what board,and how long?) Please explain your relevant qualifications, interests,and experiences. &6t&S e!'C� OQIAA4.�6' References(Individual or Organization)Name: Phone. 3 try''\- e..., %. -� - - ©� t [x-'S 5 This application is considered public record. Application contact information may be displayed on the City of Bozeman website. PLEASE NOTE: Per Ordinance No. 1754,revising Chapter 2.01 of the Bozeman Municipal Code,all board members are required to attend a yearly ethics workshop provided free of charge by the City as a condition of service as a member of a board. 3 30 September 2008 1 the tributary www.bozeman�,lbutory.com that Pape approaches client education ui "In technology, we don't deploy //WBenefit? // real estate,particularly with respect to the solutions that we don't test to death. If at is Benefit. Who �s Benefit?"' of "value." He teaches his agents that means beating on it with a hammer, An interview with Jerry Pape, Jr. on right and clients his version of the value concept then we're beating on it with a hammer,In buying, selling and troubleshooting in under an hour.By teaching the constructs this way we know what to expect from a of value and the status of the current market given product.This knowledge allows us By Holly Zadra first, Pape creates a proactive relationship to create reliable solutions." BUDDHISM AND REAL ESTATE with his clients that sets the tone for the rest With nine years of national Total I've known Jerry Pape,Jr. for nearly As a Buddhist practitioner and a realtor of of a transaction. eight years.He is a Buddhist practitioner nearly 20 years experience, Pape should Cost of Ownership studies for over According to Pape, education empowers companies ranging from two employees and founder of two businesses, know something about both. the client. "When you look at people's ego to 75,Pape means what he says."We have Triple Creek Realty of Bozeman and According to Pape,real estate has been mechanics,they generally don't wantto admit this down to a science.Most businesses Excalibur,a national IT management and made more complicated than it has to be;it what they don't know.When they do,they feel with managed IT spend between 2 to 5 troubleshooting company. At a recent is not supposed to be a mystery.For Pape, like they're in a disadvantageous position.If percent of their annual sales on IT.Most lunch meeting, I asked Pape, in what the theory behind his work whether in you give them the tools to make informed of my clients are operating flawlessly at became a rather stream-of-consciousness technology or real estate practice is this: decisions, they are in a better position to 0.8 to 1.25 percent," interview, to share with me how these "If you want to be the best at what you do, understand value and be comfortable with As for real estate in Bozeman recently three very different pursuits fit together you have to be the best educator.Being the what they are buying or selling. At that it's been what Pape unfortunately calls, in his life. best educator allows you to empower your point,they are no longer making reactionary "Who-you-know real estate" nut "what- I was particularly interested in Pape's clients with knowledge and confidence decisions, they're making logical decisions you-know real estate." Pape noted that thoughts on the Buddhist concept of in the transactions they undertake. Real that temper their emotions, learning how 'Today, because so many of the who- "Right Livelihood"and real estate practice estate should never be taken lightly. to buy what they really need,not what they you-know agents had no real training, especially inlight of the fact that Tributary It is a serious business working with merely want." they are struggling because they didn't writer Helen Tzitley recently went so far large amounts of money and a degree of He added, "Similar concepts apply to do the heavy lifting by acquiring the as to give real estate brokers the moniker emotional involvement that is often sellers, especially in this market. Many training needed to survive in what has "dirty pirate hookers"in a story she wrote the most profound combination of sellers have completely unfounded become a what-you-know real estate about buying her first home, the two in most people's lives." concepts of value and have further era." It has been suggested that by next Right livelihood is concerned with compounded the problem by having spring,perhaps as many as half the full ensuring that one earns one's living in EDUCATION AND REAL ESTATE intense emotional involvements time agents in the Gallatin Association an honorable way,that is, that wealth be Pape feels many sellers with their existing properties." of Realtors will be lost to the changing acquired only by legal means;peacefully in our current market These involvements often market and economic pressure and will without coercion or violence;honestly,not are caught up in the cause them to so overvalue have to seek other employment. by trickery or deceit;and in ways which do mentality of"they found the property they are Certainly,he said,the economy plays the not entail harm and suffering for others. the property they WANT trying to sell that they can't greater role in this attrition,but surviving Pape responded that he was taught this so they've got to somehow accomplish their larger real estate cycles is also a result of proper goals in a timely fashion. concept very simply by the Ven. Gyatru[ sell the property that they _ training and supervision,This is why Pape Rinpoche, who said we must always be have at the price that they Pape said, "Bob Hendricks, himself went through(and why everyone asking"What is benefit?Who is benefit?" NEED to get what they a noted mortgage banker at that works with him goesthrough)rigorous "What I learned from this teaching is WANT."But,said Pape,"the First Interstate Bank, taught training. His agents must undergo 250 that with each action you must consider market doesn't wake up in me years ago that people often hours of directly supervised training in what the benefit is and who is benefited.I the morning and go,'Bob Smith, what do can't seethe forest for the trees.While striving buyer transactions and 250 hours in seller find in my life that if the answer to who you need today?'Further,when you allow to get an extra $10,000 for their existing transactions. Pape said, "Insufficiently is benefited by a particular action is'just inexperienced people to buy what they property,people often lose sight of the fact trained agents cause harm to their clients me',then I'm not working hard enough." want,nine out of ten times,two years down that if the mortgage rate on the property and are an E&O liability." In keeping with the Buddhist idea the road,they're very unhappy with what they're trying to buy ticks up even one tenth they bought because they didn't understand of a point,this will cost them over$10,000 in of benefiting others, Pape is straight- interest in the life of the new loan." ON TROUBLESHOOTING faced and calm as he addresses what he what they really needed." calls "fiduciary obligation in real estate" Pape's concern is that most people don't Pape is emphatic,"lime is of the essence Michelle Fiore,a renowned California wherein the agent must consider the really think cognitively about the whole in real estate where a variety of dynamic physician and friend of Pape's for 30 years client's benefit in advance of his or her transaction process. From a professional internal and external factors are at play says,"If there is a crisis and Jerry walks own benefit,something that was not often standpoint, the following steps remain in every transaction."For these and other in the room•-no more crisis.People either attended to in Bozeman's past climate of constant in every deal: examine current reasons,Pape believes it is very important love him for the'Pape Effect'or hate him irrational property values and skyrocketing market status, seek the targ e t property, to educate sellers about how their property for it." When asked to comment on this appreciation.Pape noted that new agents write offers,negotiate a price,pursue due stacks up in the current market and what effect Pape said,"I'm a paid confronter, must have enough initial income to not diligence, request inspections, manage the market is likely to offer them.Said Pape, Trouble is trouble and I meet it head-on. need the deal. If an agent needs the deal contingencies and close the deal.However, "To not take this education process very Nobody wants someone to come in and pat and the client's money,he or she is at risk anytime you put people through a process seriously results in a tremendous number the trouble on its head and say,'Oh,it'll go of violating this fiduciary obligation. they don't understand,they are goingto feel of stagnant, overpriced properties that awayon its own.'Ifyou areatroubleshooter insecure and possibly hoodwinked.Hence, slow both market recovery and a return to clients want you to confront the trouble and Pape sees Bozeman as very young positive appreciation," make it go away.It doesn't matter if it's a and unsophisticated when it comes to his stresson the role of agent as advisor and P pP difficult real estate problem,misbehaving educating inex inexperienced educator.A local bank executive once told In the end, the real measure of any P Pape,"Anybody can put a sign in the yard— transaction according to Pape is what his technology or an unethical vendor, the about market values and the transaction clients think two ears later, not the day client points at the trouble;I shoot it." process. This is particularly true in a today people need real estate consulting." Y correcting market that the majority of Solving problems or`troubleshooting" that he gets a check.From this point of view, "Three out of five times,someone will Bozeman agents have never seen."When is what Pape does best. Whether in his method is based on building long-term call with a serious problem,I will arrive on people ask someone to perform real estate technology or real estate,troubleshooting relationships and is only possible if the idea the scene with my trouble dispelling force agency far them,they should know what often requires thinking outside the box. of truly benefiting others is kept in mind for field,and they will.jump up and down in front of they're asking for...Most people don't "Many people are so used to thinking inside the long haul. saying' me, pointing behind themselves °It's on fiell'I will try to move to know what a real estate agent is really their little box that sometimes they need a the trouble spot,and the distressed client supposed to do.Around here,people think nudge to see that many of the best solutions REAL ESTATE AND TECHNOLOGY will stand between me and the trouble. they mostly sit around and make a bunch emerge by looking at things from differing For Pape,real estate and technology have They don't want to be the ones who can't of money for doing nothing,which is not angles,"said Pape. something in common—all the"heavy lifting" fix it."Perhaps this is because,according accurate,"or right in the Buddhist sense. One of those differing angles is the way should be done up front. to Pape,when he arrives it means they're the tributary I September 2008 31 in real trouble. It means he knows more an expert,many people,think What don't effect my friend Ken McLeod called like health insurance companies and big than they do about the subject and it's I know and why do I need his help? not 'strange gravity."' technology vendors. I have always felt going to cost a lot of money to fix it,both of What does he know and how can he help? that it was not enough to fight for just which produce profound ego trauma and "Coming to the point where they can see IN A NUTSHELL what I needed in these situations. I try eventually financial anemia. expertise as a benefit and the relationship very diligently to ensure that the fight Pape tries to set expectations I am fighting Pape relates the tactical aspect of his as an alliance requires acknowledgement accordingly. on the door of his office g ting won not just for t but personality type to something he learned of most people's biggest problem: Ego. for every other little guy who might have is a picture of a yellow peanut M&M the same roblem, but lacks the skill in rescue dive training. "If your dive And believe me;'Pape added"My ego is character with blue hair, a cell phone p buddy is in a tough spot,you check your no exception." and black shoes.This way,when people set to solve it.In doing so I'm trying to air,you check his eyes and you make a hard Pape addressed the source of his come looking for a nut with blue hair and constantly assess my actions so that I can decision.If his eyes don't look right,you expertise this way:"Since I was a child, a cell phone, they know where to find avoid making choices based on benefit to clock him. Barn! And then you drag him '1 don't know' has been an immediate him. He's not your average anything- self at the expense of others." in.Otherwise,he'll drown you both,You're action item. It began with'I don't know take it or leave it.When I ask him what's Or,more simply put,Pape returns to there to save the day and keep your own how it works,'to the vacuum cleaner got up with the blue hair,he said it's a long his root mantra, "What is benefit?Who ass afloat,not to negotiate other people's taken apart.Throughout my life,I saw a storythathas todowith Gothnightclubs, is benefit?" ego mechanics.Period." great deal of suffering in the world when beautiful women and an unbreakable One reason people have difficulty with people had things that didn't work the habit.Pape called it a"state indicator" Pape is that to get people or vendors in way they were supposed to work.I had an knowing it makes him look like Sonic a giant corporation thousands of miles inherent knack for three things: I knew the Hedgehog. The pricklier it is, the away to actually comply and perform how to break it,how to fix it and I knew pricklier he is. On really prickly days, requires an unusual confrontational why it wasn't working."Eventually these if you don't treat him appropriately, skill and a lot of leverage. "When I three talents lead to a degree in Science things might not go very well.If the soft get a trouble call and they tell me the and Technology focusing on Usability touch is the better approach,he brings accounting system's down, 18 people's Engineering from Stanford. in his friend and partner of many years, paychecks are at stake,and it's payday, "When you study people using things, Bennett Drozic. Together the two have I'm not here to say, 'Hi. How are you? you gain many perspectives through the ability to do jobs they could not Are you having a nice day?How's your intense observation. Your value to otherwise accomplish alone. familyV and I'm certainly not here to call the tech industry is how many 'user In contrast to what makes his clients up the misbehaving vendor and say,`Can perspectives'are in your head.Because I crazy,I asked Pape what produces anger you pretty please replace this defective taught technology and applied physics at or irritation for him."It's pretty hard to product that your company made?'" Stanford,and technology at UC Santa Cruz make me angry.Probably the thing I get and San Jose State, I gained thousands most angry about is when others selfishly ABOUT THE MAN upon thousands of user perspectives, ignore interdependence, especially There's no doubt that Jerry Pape, Later at Mac Academy, as a national communities and large corporations, Jr. talks big and makes an immediate technology educator in the 90's, I had bringing harm to others.I frequently find To argue with Jerry Pape,Jr.,email him impression.When he enters a room,only groups as large as 500-1,500 students.In myself fighting with large corporations at trib@espt.com. the undead fail to take notice.Pape would all,I've had well over 20,000 students.I beg to differ,he thinks the undead actually know categorically what people do and pay don't like about technology." COMM" T' ���� V a more attention than we think. His „ jl� J„„I vocabulary astounds (he said `annoys'). Pape knows the founders of Cisco, LJ l�1 His memory is sharp (he corrected me, Intuit,Aldus and Symantec.He designed 'failing').He's definitive,effective,witty, exams that certify Adobe instructors,and and depending upon the circumstances, contributed to the design and execution of C I by turns serious and playful. When he products many of us use every day like the - really offers his energy to you,you can be Palm Pilot andtheDymoLabelwriter.When certain he is focused on your needs. he talks about these things in conversation 057E Legitimizing sucha reputation,however, itmakeshim soundlike aname dropperbut, presents two problems: naysayers and to him,it is simply a matter of past work ego barriers. Pape acknowledges that experience."Everyone has a resume,"he many people think he is completely full said. "A lot of mine just happened to be of shit,People that know Pape well know based in the progressive environment of 416 EAST PARK STREET he can substantiate anything he says. If Silicon Valley." And statements like that LIVINGSTON 1 406.222.6200 he doesn't know the answer,he can find it are what tend to put a question mark in the C 0 M M u N t TY C L 0 s E T,C 0 M thought bubble of listeners because Pape where fashion meets philanthropy in under 15 minutes.He'll pull it out of a book,off the net,ask a mentor or contact looks much younger than he is and started the people directly responsible for the much earlier than most. technology in question. In response to the quizzical looks he Pape said,"I won't hesitate to call the gets, Pape admits that context matters OUR STAND VP of hardware development at one of when delivering information. "When I'm my vendors because I've invested years in the classroom or amongst friends, m THERE'S NO SUBSTITUTE in these relationships.I visit my vendors delivering information is easy, but in FOR A NEW CAB OTHER THAN annually all across the country. I like certain external social circumstances, I A NEW GAR. Woody Allen's old line`80%of success is set off so many people's negative coping just showing up,' so I actually show up mechanisms - even when I'm standing Call me today to learn about New Car Replacement.If your new and demand accountability which really still and not saying anything-that things car is totaled,you'll get a new one-not just book value. surprises new vendors. Relationships can get polarized pretty quickly." (406)586-3330 are a primary differentiator in the IT In a more gentle and self-serving way, management business, You can't succeed Pape said this about his character,"People Mafle Gary CIC,LUTCF Serving the community ,jl without both'who you know'and'what you enjoy pearls very much,but to produce 1920 W Babcock ``�� know'and a whole lot of each." a pearl,you have to have start with what Bozeman for over 20 years The other side of legitimization has to is essentially an irritant. I am often the a012550 @allstate.com AllStM. do with overcoming ego barriers. Pape cognitive dissonance that creates new Fe&reis optional and subjedlolums and Conditions.Available in select states now and inmoststatesby1131106isubjedto remarked that when a person speaks as possibilities in any given situation, an regulatoryapprovelwMerequired).Allstate Firemd Casualty lruranceC cmpanyNoftrook,IL©2011 Mlstale Inurance Company