Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1997-06-09 Minutes, City Commission ----- --.- ----------- -- -..,....- MINUTES OF THE WORK SESSION/AGENDA MEETING OF THE CITY COMMISSION BOZEMAN, MONTANA June 9, 1997 ***************************** . The Commission of the City of Bozeman met in work session and agenda meeting in the Commission Room, Municipal Building, June 9, 1997, at 3:00 p.m. Present were Mayor Stueck, Commissioner Rudberg, Commissioner Stiff, Commissioner Frost, Commissioner Youngman, Acting City Manager Brey, City Attorney Luwe and Clerk of the Commission Sullivan. The meeting was opened with the Pledge of Allegiance and a moment of silence. Agenda Meeting - for reaular meeting and Dublic hearings to be held on June 16, 1997 Since this is an agenda meeting, only those issues requiring staff action are contained in the minutes. . Acting City Manager Brey briefly reviewed the background information which was included in the Commissioners' packets. (4) Assistant Planner Chris Saunders gave a brief overview of the project, stating that, at the Planning Board meeting, the applicant requested a second variance, to allow the streets to be offset from those north of West Babcock by 105 feet instead of the 125 feet required. He noted that issues pertaining to bottlenecks in the sewer system and traffic levels on West Babcock Street were identified during staff review of this application. He then indicated that a parkland dedication is proposed in the center of the development, to meet the recreational needs of the residents. Since it does not meet the size required by statutes, therefore, a cash-in-lieu payment may be required. Responding to Commissioner Frost, the Assistant Planner stated that the level of . service on a street is determined not only on automobile counts, but on the drivers' confidence level, width of driving lanes and the separation between driving lanes and pedestrian walkways. After asking the Assistant Planner several questions about the new variance request, City Attorney Luwe informed the Commissioners that they will be unable to consider the variance at Monday's meeting because it has not been noticed and the hearing held. 06-09-97 - 2 - (5) Assistant Planning Director Arkell gave a brief overview of this project, which involves the aggregation of two townhouse lots in the Parkway Plaza PUD, for a lot totalling 11,947 square feet. She noted that this is 53 square feet less than is required under the zone code for a four-plex, and the applicant is proposing the construction of a triplex on the site. She noted the other issue involved pertains to the size of the water mains and . whether a 3/4-inch water line can adequately serve a triplex. (6) Assistant Planner Jody Olsen provided a brief overview of the project. She noted that no public comment has been received on this application, and it was approved on the Planning Board's consent agenda at the June 3 meeting. (7) Mayor Stueck stated that he contacted the City staff this morning to get background information on this item. He said many half baths for senior citizens are proposed in the Beehive Homes. He noted that the 3/4-inch water line that has been extended to the site is not adequate for the number of half baths in the unit, and a 11.4-inch or 1 Y2-inch line must be installed. (8) The Acting City Manager stated that the information for this agenda item . is not yet ready, but will be in time for the packets on Thursday. He also assured the Commission that Ms. Beiser will receive a copy of the staff responses at the same time as they are distributed in the Commissioners' packets. (9) Mayor Stueck noted that the Montana Department of Transportation has turned down this request, and they have also expressed concerns about the number of times Main Street is closed during the year. He recognized that an agreement was negotiated between the local office of the Montana Department of Transportation and former City Manager Jim Wysocki, and it is a tenuous agreement at best. He cautioned that the Montana Department of Transportation has suggested that requests for additional closures could result in the loss of some of the closures that had previously been approved. Acting City Manager Brey noted that, with any change in personnel, the City must . once again re-establish its relationship with the Department. (10) City Attorney Luwe stated this ordinance is currently in draft form and needs some revisions prior to its adoption. He stated that, if the Commission wants this ordinance to be in effect before the Sweet Pea parade, a special meeting must be held on June 30 for its 06-09-97 -.-.. -- ..--- .--- ----- .- .---.- -..-...-.- ~ 3 - final adoption. He noted that if immediate adoption is not essential, staff will take more time to revise this proposed ordinance. The Commission determined that it is not essential to have this ordinance in effect prior to the Sweet Pea parade, and City Attorney Luwe withdrew it from the agenda. ( 17) Historic Preservation Planner Strahn provided a brief overview, stating this . is one of the first applications to go through the ADR instead of the DRB review process. Responding to Questions from Mayor Stueck, the City Attorney stated he will review the advertisement published in the newspaper prior to next week's meeting. (18) Historic Preservation Planner Strahn provided an overview of the many requested deviations on the subject property. He stated that staff can support the deviations to allow the porch to encroach into the front yard setback. Staff also supports the request to allow the fence in the front yard to exceed four feet, although a fence lower than six feet is preferred. He indicated that staff cannot support the proposed 24-foot by 24-foot carport at the rear of the lot, stating that it would not contribute to the historic character of the area. . Work Session - (A) Pro Dosed revisions to animal control section of Bozeman MuniciDal Code (B) Signs in City Darks (C) Setting of schedule for review of City Manager's budget recommendations (D) Discussion re outdoor lightina issues (E) Discussion with various arOUDS re imDact fees (A) Proposed revisions to animal control section of Bozeman Municipal Code Included in the Commissioners' packets was a copy of the draft ordinance, reflecting the proposed changes to the animal control ordinance. Also distributed to the Commissioners were copies of letters from the Humane Society, dated June 5 and June 9, forwarding comments on the proposed ordinance. Staff Attorney Tim Cooper provided some background on the revisions to this section of the Bozeman Municipal Code, stating that he became involved in the rewrite only recently. He noted that this ordinance includes provisions for impounding dogs and for holding dogs that . are suspected of or have been deemed to be dangerous. He noted that when the revisions to this section of the code were initially prepared, they were designed to address the leash law, create an animal control board, add provisions pertaining to exotic and wild animals, and identify areas where animals are not allowed. He then indicated that the animal control board has now been eliminated from the ordinance. 06-09-97 - 4 - The Staff Attorney noted that under the revisions to the kennel licensing requirements, any combination of three or more animals of any type will trigger a kennel license. he also noted that kennel licenses are to be divided into two categories, one for pets and one for breeding animals. Staff Attorney Cooper identified some areas of the ordinance where additional . revisions are needed. He indicated that those areas will be revised prior to the ordinance being submitted to the Commission for possible action. Responding to questions from Mayor Stueck, Staff Attorney Cooper stated that he will carefully review the provisions of the ordinance as drafted to determine whether animals may be ordered held pending a City Court hearing. He cautioned that the Humane Society will not want to hold those animals for an extended period of time without reimbursement. City Attorney Luwe cautioned that, depending on the incident, different procedures may be undertaken by different agencies. He then indicated that the Court could require the owner to pay associated costs. He stated that the language contained in the ordinance can be strengthened if the Commission desires. . Commissioner Frost noted that if someone goes to Court over an incident involving a dog, it could be quite a long time before the whole procedure is complete. He then asked if language can be added to the ordinance that might address that type of situation. Commissioner Rudberg stated that the Commission adopted an ordinance which prohibits dogs in the cemetery, and noted that the Commission also talked about the possibility of not allowing dogs on City streets when there are community events, such as parades. She asked if that provision should be incorporated into this ordinance or addressed in a separate ordinance. City Attorney Luwe noted that the Commission has also discussed the possibility of providing a leash free zone in which dogs are allowed to run. He asked if they wish to incorporate this type of provision into the ordinance as well. . Commissioner Youngman stated she feels it is important to include all possible changes in the draft ordinance. She noted that a work session or a public hearing can then be held on the ordinance, with comments about any aspects of the ordinance being open for discussion. 06-09-97 ------- __.__ _._____._n __ ___ ------.-.".. - 5 - Mayor Stueck stated he is concerned about dogs on Main Street, not only during community events like parades, but illegally tied along the sidewalk. He also noted that not all dogs are maintained on leashes six feet or shorter, and that can increase the risk of conflicts. Staff Attorney Cooper suggested that the prohibition of dogs in certain areas of the community could be included in a different section of the code, rather than in the animal control . ordinance. Commissioner Youngman stated that she recognizes the importance of tightening the language to protect the public from dangerous dogs and dangerous owners, but she is concerned that those provisions may be unnecessarily restrictive for good dogs and good owners. She noted that the leash free zone in a specified area, such as Burke Park, could be of benefit to the well behaved animals in the community. Commissioner Youngman noted that when an animal is in training, the training is not limited to just the classroom; it often extends into the community. She noted that training may include a longer leash or no leash, and she feels those training times should be accommodated. She recognized that this ordinance is also designed to ensure that a park is a safe place for . people. She noted, however, that people typically do not use the parks early in the morning and suggested that dog owners could be allowed to exercise their dogs in the parks until a specified time, such as 9:00 a.m. or 10:00 a.m. She acknowledged that this proposal could lead to enforcement problems. Animal Control Officer Connie Lien stated that, while she likes the concept forwarded by Commissioner Youngman, not everyone is on the same schedule. She recognized that areas need to be provided where dogs can run under reasonable supervision, and feels the issue should be addressed from that angle. Commissioner Rudberg expressed concern that 1,000 animals were adopted out last year, but a review of the number of licenses issued revealed that 800 dog licenses and 300 cat licenses were issued. She stressed the importance of ensuring that a higher percentage of . animals are licensed. She also expressed concern that it is not uncommon for those owners walking their dogs to let them "do their duty" on someone's lawn and make no effort to clean it up. Acting City Manager Brey noted that the outstanding issues he has identified include a leash free zone, training time and cost recovery for animals being held. He noted that the 06-09-97 - 6 - issue of exotic animals has not yet been discussed. He cautioned, however, that this section must be coordinated with the provisions of the zone code. He also noted that in an effort to coordinate this section with others in the code, the parks section must be taken into consideration. He recognized the concerns about licensing which were raised and suggested that allowing the Humane Society to sell licenses might help to address that problem. He then . stressed the importance of obtaining input from others who might be impacted by this ordinance, including the Humane Society. Responding to Commissioner Frost, City Attorney Luwe stated the maximum penalty for violations of the animal control ordinance is $500, but no minimum fine is included in this ordinance as drafted. Animal Control Officer Lien noted that Neighborhood Coordinator/GrantspersonJames Goehrung has prepared a brochure that includes many of the provisions of the animal control ordinance. She suggested that distribution of this information could be beneficial. Mayor Stueck stated it would be beneficial for Staff Attorney Cooper to meet with representatives from the Humane Society and any other entity that should be involved and . incorporate their ideas and suggestions into a revised draft for Commission consideration. Commissioner Frost asked that a minimum fine for cleaning up after dogs be added to this ordinance. Commissioner Youngman expressed concern that the requirements for providing enclosures for exotic animals are not consistent with the definition. Staff Attorney Cooper stated that the section on exotic animals was lifted from an ordinance in another community. He then indicated that he will review and revise this section as necessary to reflect local issues. Responding to questions from the Commission, Animal Control Officer Lien stated that it is easy to identify a breeding operation for which a kennel license might be requested. She then requested that the Commissioners provide for discretion in enforcement of the provisions . of this ordinance. Commissioner Rudberg stated that she had requested statistics from Animal Control Officer Lien. She noted that, since January, citations include 148 dogs at large, 88 nuisance animals and 11 bites. She stated that these statistics reflect the magnitude of the problem and the importance of addressing the issues as quickly as possible. 06-09-97 - 7 - Ms. Ganay Johnson, Executive Director of the Humane Society, recognized that irresponsible owners are part of the problem. She then asked that her organization be allowed to provide input into revisions to the ordinance. She expressed concern about housing vicious animals at the Humane Society, stating they do not have the proper facilities to do so and she does not feel it is proper to ask her staff to deal with those animals. . Ms. Clara Gallagher, Public Relations Officer for the Gallatin Dog Club, characterized the club as a non-profit organization which promotes responsible pet ownership. She then asked for an opportunity to provide as much input as possible to ensure that the result is equitable and enforceable legislation. Responding to questions from Commissioner Frost, Animal Control Officer Lien stated that most of the dog bite incidents have occurred close to or at home, and generally revolve around the protection of their property or owner. City Attorney Luwe stated that a revised draft should be ready for Commission review at the June 30 work session and then Commission action at the July 7 meeting. (E) Discussion with various groups re impact fees . Acting City Manager Brey stated that a few weeks ago, Mr. David Smith indicated that he was prepared to discuss the issue of impact fees. Mr. David Smith, Executive Director of the Bozeman Area Chamber of Commerce, reminded the Commission that just over a year ago, a group began meeting to consider the affects of impact fees and to identify possible alternatives to forward to the Legislature that would assist local governments in financing infrastructure improvements. He stated that on May 2, the group met to discuss the results of their meetings and the legislative attempts. Mr. Smith noted that the results of a survey recently conducted regarding the demands that various land uses place on the county government revealed that agricultural land and open space demand 25 cents in services for every dollar paid in property taxes, industrial development demands 7 cents in services, commercial development demands 18 cents in . services, and residential development demands $1.45 in services. In light of those statistics, the group feels that impact fees for commercial development must be carefully evaluated. Mr. Smith stated that the group supports the development of a building permit process in the County. The group also supports the development of very clearly defined goals for the impact fees. 06-09-97 .-- ..- --.-.--- - 8 - Mr. Smith stated that developers expect that they will be required to pay fees to mitigate the impacts of their developments. He stressed the importance of a predictable process, rather than having "requirements change along the way". He further noted that the City and the County should be accountable for how the monies are expended, stressing the importance of spending the monies in a wise and prudent manner. He suggested that the City . and the County could establish advisory committees to assist them in developing the five-year capital improvements program, and then review and update that plan on an annual basis. He noted that this would give the community an opportunity to provide input while allowing the governing bodies to maintain the final authority over the program. Mr. Russ Squire, Southwest Montana Building Industry Association, forwarded his preference that the impact fees not be increased. He noted that $40 million in needed improvements to the community's infrastructure have been identified, and suggested that the costs of those improvements should be borne by the entire community. He then suggested that more clustered development could be beneficial, however, he noted public policy does not force developers into that type of discussion. . Mr. Squire stated he feels the issues are greater than just the impact fees and at what level they should be assessed. He stressed that those fees will not solve current problems. He also noted that impact fees will not address the demands which residential properties place on City services. He encouraged the Commissioners to not increase the impact fees, particularly because of the burden that could place on commercial and industrial development, both of which place low demands on City services when viewed in light of the amount of property taxes paid. He concluded by encouraging the Commissioners to find a better alternative for funding of infrastructure improvements than the impact fees can provide. Acting City Manager Brey noted that the City Manager's recommendations for the Fiscal Year 1997-1998 budget include one water project to be funded from impact fees; and one wastewater project is anticipated in the next fiscal year. He then reminded the . Commission that when the level of impact fees was established, it was with the understanding that after the legislative session had ended, the issue would be revisited in light of new funding opportunities that had been provided. Mayor Stueck noted that he had asked the Impact Fee Coordinator to provide three 06-09-97 ._. - ____._n.__._________ __n._....._.. .___. -...- .-- ----. .-. .----- - 9 - different alternatives for changing the rates on impact fees, and that information has been forwarded in the memo dated June 4. Responding to questions from the Mayor, Impact Fee Coordinator Saunders stated that the impact fees for water and wastewater are based on the size of the water line, therefore, in many instances the fees paid by commercial and residential developments are the . same. He then stated that the differences between the fire and street impact fees for commercial and residential development are based on the characteristics of those developments. Mayor Stueck noted that the street impact fees have a greater effect on commercial development than any of the other three impact fees, and he feels it is important to retain them at 10 percent to minimize negative impacts on that type of development. He then stated that he is not concerned about the big developers because he feels they can absorb the additional costs generated by the impact fees. He stated, however, that he is concerned about the builder who constructs only one or two houses a year, particularly if those houses do not sell quickly. . Acting City Manager Brey reminded the Commission that the capital improvements programs for the four impact fee programs were drafted in April, and those programs were based on existing rates. He asked if the Commissioners wish to have any additional information provided before they consider the impact fee rates on an upcoming agenda. Responding to Mayor Stueck, the Acting City Manager stated the capital improvements programs are re-evaluated annually, and projects on those lists can be added, deleted or rearranged. Impact Fee Coordinator Saunders stated that the capital improvements list is a public document and requests from outside entities are accepted as input for consideration in the re- evaluation process. He noted that with the flexibility in these programs, the City can be responsive to the realistic needs of the community. . Commissioner Frost noted that the City currently assesses impact fees on only four of its many services. He noted that, even if the impact fees were assessed at the actual costs identified, development would be bearing only a portion of the costs to the City because the remainder of the services are being provided through the standard funding mechanisms rather than through impact fees. 06-09-97 ..- -. .-. ..------.-- .------.--- -.-- - 10 - Responding to questions from Commissioner Frost, Impact Fee Coordinator Chris Saunders stated he has not had an opportunity to review the study completed for the County, although he noted that similar studies have generated similar kinds of results, Commissioner Frost noted that, while Costco may not place as significant an impact on some of the City services as a residential development, it will have a definite impact on . roads. Acting City Manager Brey reminded the Commission that the impact fees were set at a low level in anticipation of some possible legislative changes, He noted that those changes did not occur, and review of the impact fees will be placed on an upcoming agenda. (B) Signs in City parks Included in the Commissioners' packets was a memo from Project Planner Christopher Williams, dated June 4, regarding the installation of 44 signs at West Babcock Park, Planning Director Andy Epple stated that each of the 44 signs is painted on a 4-foot by 8-foot sheet of plywood, so each sign contains 32 square feet, and the combined total of the signs is 1,408 square feet. He noted that no permit was sought or received by the . Bozeman Baseball Association to allow the installation of these signs. He noted that both the Planning Office and City Hall have received calls from residents in the neighborhood and others regarding the signs, which are located in a residential area, The Planning Director noted that earlier this year, the Gallatin Valley Softball Association approached the Planning Office about the possibility of installing signs at the Recreation Complex, and that request was denied by staff based on the provisions of the Bozeman Municipal Code, He then stated that, because of the concerns that have been raised, staff feels it is appropriate for the Commission to consider this issue and develop a policy that can be applied in an equitable manner, He characterized the issue as allowing commercial advertising in public parks, and indicated that Sections 12,26,030, 18,08.020 and 18,65.050,C, provide varying and sometimes contradictory statements on this issue. . The Planning Director forwarded questions to which staff feels responses could provide direction on how to proceed with this issue, as follows: 1. Should commercial advertising be permitted in public parks, and under what circumstances? 2, If commercial advertising is permitted, how much should be permitted? 06-09-97 - 11 - 3. What kind of application should be required? 4. How much should be charged for review? 5. Should the signs be subject to durationallimitations? 6. What department or individual will review the application? Planning Director Epple suggested that if the Commission provides general direction . on these issues, staff can bring back a conceptual policy for Commission consideration. Commissioner Frost stated he feels it is important for the Recreation and Parks Advisory Board to provide its input on this issue prior to the Commission making a decision. Ms. Linda Ellison, 3301 West Babcock Street, stated that this area of the community is used by walkers and joggers. She noted that the park, while it is not an open space, has provided an open area, and that area has been an asset to this segment of the community. She expressed concern about the visual appearance of the signs, plus she is concerned about casinos being advertised in a recreation facility oriented to youth. She forwarded her interest in seeing another venue used for letting the public know who has been involved in the development and maintenance of this facility. . Ms. Ellison encouraged the Commissioners to drive along Fowler Avenue, from West Babcock Street to West Main Street, so they can see the signs from her perspective. She also asked the Commissioners to consider the existing residential neighborhood and the area immediately around this facility which will probably develop with residences over the next few years as they discuss this issue. Responding to Commissioner Rudberg, Planning Director Epple stated it is his understanding that the signs at West Babcock Park are to be removed after the baseball season is done and stored so they can be used again next year. Mayor Stueck noted that, while he has been actively involved in the development of the park, he knew nothing about the signs until they were installed. He stated that the businessmen involved in development of the park donated $50,000 in improvements, and this . is their effort to generate monies to maintain the facility. He then indicated that, because of the temporary nature of the baseball program and since the signs are installed on the inside of the outfield fence, he feels that allowing the signs may be appropriate. Planning Director Epple noted that staff has discussed the possibility of a special 06-09-97 .-- - 12 - temporary use permit. He then stressed the importance of addressing the issue of signage on a consistent basis. Mayor Stueck requested that this item be placed on a future agenda for discussion, after the Recreation and Parks Advisory Board has submitted its input. (C) Setting of schedule for review of City Manager's budget recommendations . The Commissioners set the first work session for 6:00 p.m. to 9:00 p.m. on Thursday, June 12, in the Conference Room. They decided that, due to the late hour of this meeting, the remainder of the schedule will be set at that work session. (D) Discussion re outdoor lighting issues Mayor Stueck requested that, due to the late hour of this meeting, this item be placed on the agenda in two weeks. Commissioner Rudberg asked that a representative from Montana Power Company and possibly someone from the lighting industry be invited to attend the Commission meeting at which this item will be discussed, noting that their input could be valuable. . Executive session re litigation At 5:22 p.m., Mayor Stueck declared that, pursuant to Section 2-3-203(4), M.C.A., he, as presiding officer, is closing the meeting for the purpose of discussing litigation issues pertaining to the Bozeman Solvent Site. He then called an executive session for the purpose of discussing litigation issues and requested that all persons except the Commissioners, Acting City Manager, Director of Public Service, City Attorney, consulting attorney O'Connell and the Clerk leave the room. At 6: 15 p.m., Mayor Stueck closed the executive session and reconvened the open meeting. Discussion - FYI Items . Acting City Manager Brey presented to the Commission the following "For Your Information" items. (1 ) Undated letter from Marla Loessberg, Manhattan, in opposition to the Pride! parade. 06-09-97 . ~ _n .-....--- ".-- - -.--- --- ___..".._. __._. _... u. - 13 - (2) Letter from Sandra Knapp, 1924 Baxter Drive, dated June 1, urging the Commission to not approve installation of the fence around the cemetery. Mayor Stueck reminded the Commission that, last fall, the Commission approved a plan for installation of a fence around a portion of the cemetery in accordance with an agreement reached by members of the Recreation and Parks Advisory Board and the Cemetery . Board. (3) Status report on the transportation projects as of June 1997, as prepared by City Engineer Brawner. (4) Memo from Impact Fee Coordinator Chris Saunders, dated June 4, forwarding information on how increases in the percentages of fees assessed will change the fees for single family residences. (5) Memo from Alec Hansen, Executive Director of the Montana League of Cities and Towns, dated June 3, notifying the City of the District 10 meeting scheduled for 3:00 p.m. on Wednesday, June 11, in the Commission Room. (6) Agenda for the joint meeting of the Gallatin County Commission and the . Madison County Commission, which was held at 10:00 a.m. today at Buck's T-4. (7) Agenda for the County Commission meeting to be held at 1 :30 p.m. on Tuesday, June 9, at the Courthouse. (8) Agenda for the Development Review Committee meeting, to be held at 10:00 a.m. on Tuesday, June 10, in the Commission Room. (9) Notice of the Headwaters Cooperative Recycling Project meeting to be held at 1 :00 p.m. on Thursday, June 12, in the Commission Room, along with minutes from the meeting held on May 14 and the RFP work session held on May 21 . (10) The Acting City Manager submitted the following. (1) Stated that the Pride! parade was essentially uneventful, with only a couple of minor incidents and no arrests. (2) Announced that the City received a $412,000 grant from the COPS More program for the new . 9-1-1 equipment. A second grant is being sought by the County, and the decision on that grant should be made in September. (11 ) Mayor Stueck stated that he welcomed 250 women for the Rainbow State Convention this morning. 06-09-97 ----- - 14 - (12) Commissioner Stiff stated that he talked to staff about the proposed amendments to the Bozeman Area Subdivision Regulations, which were considered during a public hearing held a few months ago. He noted that, as a result of that conversation, he has decided it is not necessary to get a copy with all of the strike-outs and underlines for review prior to adoption of the amendments. He indicated that this should speed up the process. The . Commissioners concurred that it is acceptable to receive a clean copy instead of one reflecting all of the changes. Executive Session - City Manaaer selection crocess At 6:22 p.m., Mayor Stueck announced that, pursuantto Section 2-3-203(3), M.C.A., the Montana Constitution and the Montana Supreme Court rulings, he, as presiding officer, has determined that the right to privacy clearly exceeds the merits of public disclosure. He noted that a level of confidentiality has been identified in the process of selecting a new City Manager, except for those chosen to be in the finalist round. He then called an executive session for the purpose of discussing the applications which remain in the pool. . At 6:32 p.m., Mayor Stueck closed the executive session and reconvened the open meeting. Adjournment - 6:32 c.m. There being no further business to come before the Commission at this time, it was moved by Commissioner Frost, seconded by Commissioner Youngman, that the meeting be adjourned. The motion carried by the following Aye and No vote: those voting Aye being Commissioner Frost, Commissioner Youngman, Commissioner Rudberg, Commissioner Stiff and Mayor Stueck; those voting No, none. ( C1 ~ fi~ . ATTEST: DON E. STUECK, Mayor ()J: J ~ ROBIN L. SULLIVAN Clerk of the Commission 06-09-97