HomeMy WebLinkAbout2007-12-17 Minutes, City Commission
LINKED MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE CITY COMMISSION
BOZEMAN, MONT ANA
December 17, 2007
*****************************
The Commission of the City of Bozeman met in the Community Room, Gallatin County
Courthouse, 311 West Main Street, on Monday, December 17, 2007 at 6:00 pm. Present were
Mayor Jeff Krauss, Cr. Kaaren Jacobson, Cr. Jeff Rupp, Cr. Steve Kirchhoff, Cr. Sean Becker,
City Manager Chris Kuku1ski, Planning Director Andy Epple, Finance Director Anna
Rosenberry, City Attorney Paul Luwe, and Deputy City Clerk Cynthia Jordan Delaney.
0: 15:44 A. Call to Order - 6:00 pm - Community Room, Gallatin County Courthouse,
311 West Main Street
Mayor Krauss called the meeting to order at 6:07 pm.
0:15:46 B.
Pledge of Allegiance and a Moment of Silence
0: 16:57 Changes to the Agenda - Chris Kukulski, City Manager
Mr. Kukulski stated that there has been some discussion about opening and continuing item G2,
the Pcrtzborn Residence Certificate of Appropriateness, but he hasn't yet been able to verify that
with Mr. Pertzborn.
0: 17:34 Mayor Krauss
Mayor Krauss explained Cr. Rupp's absence and said Cr. Rupp is trying to make it back for this
meeting.
0:17:51 C.
(Baker)
Public Service Announcement - Climate Protection Task Force Update
0: 18:06 Hattie Baker, Sustainability Coordinator
Ms. Baker gave an update on the progress ofthe Climate Protection Task Force.
0:22:08 D. Minutes - September 4, 2007, September 10, 2007, September 17, 2007,
November 16, 2007 Joint City-County Meeting, November 19, 2007, and November 26,
2007
0:22:12 Motion and Vote to approve the Minutes of September 4, 10, 17, November 16, 19,
and 26 (2007).
It was moved bv Cr. Becker. seconded bv Cr. Kirchhoff. to approve the Minutes of
September 4. 10. 17. November 16.19. and 26 (2007).
Those votin2 Ave bein2 Crs. Becker. Kirchhoff. Jacobson. and Mavor Krauss.
Those votin2 No bein2 none.
4
Linked Minutes a/the Bozeman City Commission Meeting, Decemher 17, 2007
Those absent beine Cr. Rupp.
The motion carried 4-0.
0:22:32 E.
Consent
1. Authorize Payment of Claims (LaMeres)
2. Authorize City Manager to sign Amendment No.1, Professional Serviees Agreement
for Great West Engineering regarding the Mandeville Farm Industrial Subdivision
(Murray)
3. Authorize City Manager to sign the Lyman Creek Reservoir Improvements Project
Professional Serviees Agreement with Morrison~ Maierle, Inc. (Murray)
4. Authorize City Manager to sign the Public Street and Utility Easements for Stucky
Road, South 27th A venue, and Graf Street for the Meadow Creek III and IV Anncxation
(Krueger)
5. Authorize City Manager to execute Appropriate Settlement Documents relatcd to
Harbour vs. City (Luwe)
6. Authorize Payment of Costs incurred by MDEQ during the Period of October 2007
regarding Buttrey's Solvent Site (Luwe)
7. Acknowledge Receipt of and set Public Hearing for the Capital Improvement Plan
(Rosenberry)
8. Acknowledge Receipt of the Update on Ordinance No. 1554, Living Wage Ordinance
(Berg)
9. Approve Final Plat of Cottage Partners Minor Subdivision (Cooper)
10. Approve Monthly Building Report for November 2007 (Doerksen)
11. Approve Ratification of the Inter~Neighborhood Council ONC) Bylaws (Fontenot)
12. Approve Resolution No. 4085, Establishing a Fee Schedule for Reservation of Public
Parks for Group Activities (Dingman)
13. Approve Resolution No. 4087, Adopting by Reference the Parks, Recreation, Open
Space and Trails (PROST) Plan (Sanford)
14. Approve Resolution No. 4088, Authorizing the City Manager to sign Change Order
No. I with Dick Anderson Construction, Inc. for the Water Reclamation Facility Phase I
Early Out (Murray)
15. Approve Resolution No. 4089, Meadow Creek Phase lIT and IV Annexation #A~
06015 (Krueger)
16. Approve Ratification of City Manager's Signature on Planning Fee Schedule
Engagement Letter with AZ & Company (Rosenberry)
17. Approve Beer and Wine or Liquor License Renewals for Calendar Year 2008
(Neibauer)
18. Award Bid for Side~Load Refuse Packer (Johnson)
19. Provisionally adopt Ordinance No. 1735, Meadow Creek Phase III and IV Zone Map
Amendment #Z~06274 (Krueger)
0:22:36 Public Comment
Mayor Krauss opened and closed public comment. No person commented.
0:23:01 Motion and Vote we approve those items E 1-19 on the Consent agenda.
5
Linked Minll1es oj"rhe Bozeman City Commissiul1 MeetinK. December 17. 2007
It was moved bv Cr. Kirchhoff. seconded bv Cr. Jacobson. we approve those items E 1-19
on thc Conscnt aecnda.
Those votine Ave beine Crs. Kirchhoff. Jacobson. Becker. and Mavor Krauss.
Those votine No beine none.
Those absent beinl! Cr. RUDD.
The motion carried 4-0.
0:23: 17 F. Public Comment
Mayor Krauss opened public comment.
0:24:20 Jim Rivenes - Public Comment
Mr. Rivenes, of 5B Gallatin Drive, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, stated that he doesn't think
it is the City COl1unission's business to be involved, and the Commission doesn't represent him at
a federal level.
0:28:01 Ted Camobell- Public Comment
Mr. Campbell, of 712 Doney Way, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, stated that the US is
engaged in a global struggle against literalist Islam, and he asked the Commission not to stain
themselves with this abominable resolution.
0:32:03 Sherrv Coffin - Public Comme11f
Ms. Coffin, of 45 Peaks View Drive, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, recited her family's
military history, and she believed this resolution is completely out of the purview of the City
COl1unission, and that it is arrogant to think that this will come to any fruition.
0:33:26 Keith McCormick - Public Comment
Mr. McCormick, of 3300 Graf Street, who supported the Iraq Resolution, gave his military
background and stated that he doesn't think there is anything more significant that the City
Commission can do than to pass this resolution and send this message.
0:34:59 Bob ROuldlton - Public Comment
Mr. Roughton, of 180 Tower Road in Belgrade, who supported the Iraq Resolution, is a proud
veteran and member of Peaceseekers, and he stated that one way for Americans to best express
their will is when the cities represent the views of the majority.
0:37:26 Aimee Kissel- Public Comment
Ms. Kissel, of 1002 South 15th Avenue, who supported the Iraq Resolution, stated that she wants
to support servicemen and women by saying this is enough and no to this war on false pretenses,
and urged the Commission to support democracy at the local level.
0:38:40 Crail! Schnurbusch - Public Comment
Mr. Schnurbusch, of North 15th Avenue, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, stated that this
resolution should never be entertained by this body, and the Commission is not addressing
numerous things because they are acting in this game of foolishness.
6
Linked Minutes oj'the Bozeman Ci~v Commission Meeting. Decemher /7. 2007
0:40:45 Alanna Brown - Public Comment
Ms. Brown, of60l South 9th Avenue, who supported the Iraq Resolution, stated that the greatest
challenge of Christianity is to love thy neighbor as thyself, but leaders who flaunt a personal
relationship with Christ have led us to harm, kill, and disrupt a Muslim nation.
0:42:42 Don Kreitz - Public Comment
Mr. Kreitz, of Fairway Drive, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, stated that the Commission has
got to do something about the brutal winter weather in Bozeman because they are spending
valuable time and dollars on a silly resolution that gets us nowhere.
0:45:29 Maire O'Neill- Public Comment
Ms. O'Neill, of 6877 Fowler Lane, commented on the PROST PLAN as a founding member of
the Gallatin Equestrian Partnership. She reiterated that no rural or equestrian uses have been
considered or added into the Plan since the October meeting.
0:48:15 Marvanne Amsden - Public Comment
Ms. Amsden, of 5588 Patterson Road, commented on the PROST Plan. They have been very
busy since the October meeting getting additional supporters, including 21 non-profit equestrian
organizations in the Gallatin Valley.
0:50: 19 Public Comment closed.
Mayor Krauss closed public comment.
0:50:3] G.
Action Items
0:50:33 1. Resolution No. 4073, Relating to Tax Increment Renewal Bonds, Series 2007
(Downtown Bozeman Improvement District); Ratifying the Sale and Prescribing the Form
and Terms Thereof and the Security Therefore (Rosenberry)
0:50:42 Anna Rosenberry, Finance Director
Ms. Rosenberry presented the staffreport.
0:50:52 Cr. Jacobson became Mayor Pro Tem.
Mayor Krauss turned the gavel over to Mayor Pro Tern Jacobson and left the room.
0:57:00 Mayor Krauss returned.
Mayor Krauss returned to his seat and role as Mayor.
0:57:0R Public Comment
Mayor Krauss opened and closed public comment. No person commented.
0:57:20 Motion and Vote that we approve Resolution No. 4073, Relating to Tax Increment
Renewal Bonds, Series 2007, ratifying the sale and prescribing the form and terms thereof
and the security therefore.
7
Linked Minutes oOlle Bo::cnwn C'ill' Call/mission Meeling, Dcccmhcr /7, 2007
It was moved bv Cr. Jacobson. seconded bv Cr. Becker. that we approve Resolution No.
4073. Relatinl! to Tax Increment Renewal Bonds. Series 2007. ratifvin!! the sale and
prescribinl! the form and terms thereof and the securitv therefore.
Those votin!! Ave bein!! Crs. Jacobson. Becker. Kirchhoff. and Mavor Krauss.
Those votin!! No beinl! none.
Those absent bein!! Cr. Rupp.
The motion carried 4-0.
0:58: 17 2. Pertzborn Residence Certificate of Appropriateness with Deviations #Z-
07248 (Bristor)
0:58:59 Mayor Krauss
Mayor Krauss asked the applicant about deferring this item.
0:59:37 Rob Pertzborn, Applicant
Mr. Pertzborn stated that he wants to do this item tonight.
1 :00: 12 Allyson Bristor, Associate Planner and Historic Preservation Officer
Ms. Bristor presented the fInal draft ofthe staff report.
1:02:36 Cr. Rupp entered.
Cr. Rupp entered the meeting.
1: 13:27 Rob Pertzborn, Applicant
Mr. Pertzborn, of I II North Tracy representing himself from 518 North Tracy, handed out to the
Commission the "Applicant's Requested Edits to Staff Conditions." He said there is nothing in
"the shack" worth saving, and the shed could fall at any minute. He described the new house and
garage design and disagreed with many parts of the staffrcport.
1:27: I 5 Public Comment opened.
Mayor Krauss opened public comment.
1:27:23 Jeffl'Ieronimo - Public Comment
Mr. leronimo, of 429 North Black, immediately south of the property in question, stated that he
wasn't impressed with the "subjective assessment" of the staff report. He said this building is a
dump with no historical significance. Mr. Pertzborn plans on building two great structures.
I :3 I: I 3 Brian Caldwell- Public Comment
Mr. Caldwell, of 733 South Tracy, discussed how this project can be reviewed considered an
appropriate proposal. He feels this is an excellent example of today's architecture, and doesn't
want to have photocopied home designs that can't evolve. He supported this project.
I :34:22 Public Comment closed.
Mayor Krauss closed public comment.
1:34:41 Mr. Pertzborn
8
Linked Minutes of the Bozeman City Commission Meeting. Decemher 17. 2t107
Mr. Pcrtzbom referenced the handout that had his desired updates to the conditions, and he wants
them to approve this project as well as both deviations.
1 :36: 13 Public hearing closed.
Mayor Krauss closed the public hearing.
1 :45: 14 Mayor Krauss
Mayor Krauss stated that he is inclined to grant the deviation requests and conditional approval
with conditions as revised by applicant. He stated that this is good architecture, and he knows it
when he sees it.
1 :51:44 Motion to approve COA/DEV Z-07248 with requested deviations, modifying staff
conditions to include amendments as presented by applicant in the 12-17-07 memo
provided this evening.
It was moved bv Cr. Becker. seconded bv Cr. Ruoo. to aDo rove COA/DEV Z-07248 with
reQuested deviations. modifyinl! staff conditions to include amendments as presented bv
applicant in the 12-17-07 memo provided this eveninl!.
1 :52:02 Mayor Krauss
Mayor Krauss noted for the record that the applicant's 12-17 ~07 handout strikes portions of a
number of conditions, and the handout will be needed to see those changes. The "no comments"
on the handout means that conditions stand as staff has written them.
1:52:34 Vote to approve COA/DEV Z-07248 with requested deviations, modifying staff
conditions to include amendments as presented by applicant in the 12-17-07 memo
provided this evening.
[It was moved bv Cr. Becker. seconded by Cr. Rupp. to approve COA/DEV Z-07248 with
reQuested deviations. modifvinl! staff conditions to include amendments as oresented bv
aoplicant in the 12-17-07 memo provided this eveninl!.1
Those votinl! Aye beinl! Crs. Becker. Ruoo. Kirchhoff. Jacobson. and Mayor Krauss.
Those votinl! No beinl! none.
The motion carried 5-0.
Revised Conditions of Approval including the approved "Applicant's Requested Edits to
Staff Conditions" memo from 12-17-07:
1. Prior to issuance of a demolition/buildinl! oermit. the applicant shall oerform the
followinl! documentation of the existinl! structures:
a. Exterior and interior BW ohotOl!raohs (minimum size of 4"x6") of all cxistinl!
structures. presented in both print and dil!ital formats (on a CD-R).
b. Scaled elevations of all existinl! structures.
c. Final update to the Historical & Architectural Inventorv file for 433 North Black
Avenue.
9
Linked Minules (lllhe Bozeman Ci(v Commission Mee/illg. December 17. l007
The architecture description and condition will be updated. as well as the additional
historic research. The Historic Preservation Officer will direct the applicant to the
appropriate paperwork for the update. Prior to release of the Certificate of
Appropriateness. the applicant shall submit the documentation materials to the
Department of Plannim! for final review and approval bv Administrative Deshm Review
Staff.
2. Prior to issuance of a demolition/buildin!! permit. the applicant shall salva!!e suitable
buildin!! materials of the existin!! house and detached shed. The applicant mav choose to
salva!!e materials at his personal expense (personal storaee. etc.). or he mav offer them for
trade and/or sale to the public (newspaper ad. etc.). Prior to release of the Certificate of
Appropriateness. the applicant shall submit documented proof to the Department of
Plannin!! of the selected salva!!e method. for final review and approval bv Administrative
Desien Review Staff.
3. The applicant shall submit additional information to the Department of PlanniDl! that
addresses the followin!! issues. for final review and approval bv Administrative Desi!!n
Review Staff:
a. Scaled street elevations that show the hei!!ht and massin!! of the houses in the immediate
nei!!hborhood.
b. A scaled elevation (either north or south) that shows both the principal sin!!le-household
and accessorv structure.
c. Scaled section(s) of the house's loft/stora!!e area. Please c1arifv how that space will be
accessed from the second floor. d. Scaled section(s) showine the proposed sidewall hei!!hts
of the l!ara!!e's second floor.
4. The applicant shall submit to the Department of Plannine revised materials that reflect
the followine chanees. for final review and approval bv Administrative Desi!!n Review
Staff:
a. On the Sheets AI.! - A1.3. an identified "Tree Protection Zone" around the existine
trees proposed to remain on the propertv and in the street boulevard shall be added. with a
notation that states: "Trees will not be damaeed bv eQuipment durin!! construction. "
b. On the Sheets A3.1 and A3.2. a notation shall be added that states: "Foundation of the
new construction will follow existin!! site contours. "
c. The proposed retainine walls shall not exceed 36 inches in heieht.
d. On sheets A3.1 and A3.2. a notation shall be added that states: "All proposed l!Jazin!!
should be non-reflective and translucent."
5. The !!ara!!e mav be located closer to the allev as shown on the proposed site plan. but
shall have a maximum footprint of 884 SQuare feet.
6. Prior to issuance of anv tvpe of a demolition/buildinl! permit. the applicant shall submit
a color palette for the buildine to the Department of PI ann in!!. which includes actual
material samples and color chips. The materials/color palette shall be presented on a board
no lareer than 24" x 36" and contain all the primarv materials to be utilized on the
buildine includinf! window/storefront frames and doors (entrv. earaee. and service). All
final buildin!! elevations shall be keved to the color palette to delineate where each
10
Linked Minutes oj'the Rozemun Citl' Commission Meeting. Decemher /7, 2007
individual buildin!! material and color is specified. The materials/color palette shall be
subiect to final desil!n review and approval bv Administrative Desi!!n Review Staff.
7. Anv existin!! city sidewalk panels alon!! N. Black that are damal!ed shall be replaced.
1 :52:45 Mayor Krauss
Mayor Krauss declared a five minute break.
I :52:52 Break
2:07:443. Bus Shelter Presentation (Scott Hedglin, AlA, Dowling Sandholm Architects;
and Lisa Ballard, P.E., Streamline Coordinator)
2:08:26 Andy Epple, Planning Director
Mr. Epple introduced Lisa Ballard and Scott Hedglin who will give a presentation about the
status of bus shelters that are needed for the growing bus system.
2: I 0:39 Lisa Ballard, Streamline Coordinator
Ms. Ballard talked about the success of Streamline's ridership numbers. She asked the
Commission for decisions on funding, sponsorship, and shelter design.
2: 12:35 Scott Hedglin, Dowling Sandhom Architects
Mr. Hedglin described the well-attended bus shelter design workshop in November and the
issues that were addressed.
2: 15:34 Cole Robertson, MSU School of Architecture
Mr. Robertson talked about the components of the project: sponsorship, the community context
element, and the interchangeable parts and components.
2:26:58 Mr. Hedglin
Mr. Hedglin said that the important question is whether or not advertising is going to be a
funding source for the bus shelters: yes or no for advertising. If so, a market analysis will show
how much these bus shelters will cost, which will drive the design.
2:28: 17 Mr. Epple
Mr. Epple said that advertising is currently not allowed under the sign code. If they want to
change that, the Commission needs to direct staff to amend the sign code.
2:32:22 Gary Walrack, Chandler Communications
Mr. Walrack, of 4123 4th Avenue South, Great Falls, stated that Chandler Communications will
pay for it all over the long haul (liability, insurance, construction, maintenance, service) in return
for advertising. Chandler would have posters on the bus shclters that are taken from vintage
designs, with no phone number or address.
2:39:20 Public Comment opened.
Mayor Krauss opened public comment.
11
Linked Minutes olthe Bozeman City Commission Meeting. December 17. 2()()7
2:39:28 Betsv Babblev - Public Comment
Ms. Babbley, of 11 West College Street, stated that she uses the bus quite often and feels quite
exposed. She wants to see a clock in each bus shelter. She is willing to be a poster girl for bus
stop advertising.
2:41 :00 Crail! Sclmurbusch - Public Comment
Mr. Schnurbusch, of North 15th, stated that Streamline hasn't proven it's viable. As a taxpayer he
doesn't want to pay tor free rides. Don't spend over $100,000 on shelters until you start charging
riders and see community participation.
2:42:37 Marv Vanthull- Public Comment
Ms. Vanthull, of 416 East Story, stated that everybody is going to pay tor increased traffic in
town one way or the other. If you don't pay for bus stops and buses with taxcs, you will pay in
larger traffic jams.
2:43:29 Alanna Brown - Public Comment
Ms. Brown, of 601 South 9th Avcnue, statcd that she is aware that larger cities with public
transportation advertise community services and the arts. She wants the Commission to dccide
what they want to say about the community in an advertising plan.
2:45: 10 Sherrv Coffin - Public Comment
Ms. Coffin, of 43 Peaks View Drive, stated that if something sounds too good to be true, it
probably is. The City might bc turning over control of what that advertising actually is. Shc is
concerned about who would control it and how to deny inappropriate advertising.
2:46:39 Chris Bude,r;ki - Public Comment
Mr. Budeski, of 315 Sheridan Avenue, read a letter representing the Urban Transportation
Stakeholder's Advisory Board showing support in thc placement of the bus shelters and using
advertising to financially support them. The City could control the advertising.
2:47:42 Public Comment closed.
Mayor Krauss closed public comment.
2:48: I 0 Mr. Walrack
Mr. Walrack clarified that all design copy that goes into the shelters would be approved in
advance by Vicki Hassler at the Planning Dcpt. Hc statcd that they gladly give space to non-
profits.
2:51:28 Mayor Krauss
Mayor Krauss noted for the record that Cr. Rupp is sitting in the baek tor this discussion; he is
sitting this one out because of his involvement with Streamline.
2:51 :44 Cr. Becker
Tonight Cr. Becker wants to provide direction to staft: thc ad-hoc advisory board, Chandler, and
any other interested parties to pursue a business plan that includes build-out, timing, design
12
Linked Minutes ulthe Buzenwn City Cummissiun Meeting. December /7, 2007
specifications (that were brought up tonight), advertising, maintenancc, ctc., assuming an
eventual amendment to the sign code. Direct staff to bring forth an agenda item so we can make
a decision on the sign code.
2:54: 15 Ms. Ballard
Ms. Ballard said she doesn't know where money would come from if they don't get sponsorships.
2:55:25 Mayor Krauss
Mayor Krauss stated that he thinks we proceed with entering into a contract with Mr. Walrack.
He is ready to move forward with the original advertising ordinance that we had drafted and
enable Mr. Walrack, the City, and Streamline to go into business together to get these bus
shelters built and move our bus system forward.
2:57:05 Cr. Jacobson
Cr. Jacobson expressed concerns about the length ofthc tcrm of the contract.
2:57: 16 Mayor Krauss
Mayor Krauss reassured Cr. Jacobson that we will let them enter into thosc negotiations and
come back to us with a business plan.
2:57:53 Mayor Krauss
Mayor Krauss said he thinks they need to address Cr. Jacobson's concern in the contract, the
performance issues in the contract.
2:58:04 Three thumbs up given to proceed.
Mayor Krauss, Cr. Becker, and Cr. Jacobson gave three thumbs up to support their direction to
proceed.
2:58:364.
Resolution No. 4086, Out of Iraq (Peace Seekers)
2:59: 19 Mayor Krauss
For public comment, Mayor Krauss asked the pros to come up first (pro~lraq Resolution), and
the cons to come up second (against Traq Resolution).
2:59:46 Mayor Krauss
Mayor Krauss declared a five minute break.
2:59:58 Break
3:07:10 Call to Order
Mayor Krauss called the meeting back to order.
3:07:50 Mayor Krauss
Mayor Krauss said he wanted to expedite the meeting: there will be 45 minutes to hear from
people in favor of this resolution and 45 minutes to hear from those opposed. He asked the public
to observe appropriate decorum and respect.
13
Unked Minllles of Ihe Ho;emiln City Commission Meeting f)ecemher 17, 2007
3:09:34 Franke Wilmer - Public Comment
Ms. Wilmer, of Lorelei Drive, who supported the Iraq Resolution, stated that it is always diffieult
for democracy to go to war, and it always should be. She stated that debates like this do not
undermine the morale of the troops; this grassroots democracy is appropriate.
3:14:00 Bradv Wiseman - Public Comment
Mr. Wiseman, representing the 65th District in the MT House of Representatives, supported the
Iraq Resolution. He thanked Cr. Steve Kirchhoff for his service. Hundreds of our constituents are
looking for someone in gov't. to say this war is immoral and illegal.
3:16:32 Marv Vanthull- Public Comment
Ms. Vanthull, of 416 East Story, who supported the Iraq Resolution, stated that the Commission
always considers the health, safety, and welfare of the local people. She said this resolution also
concerns local welfare, and this war will impact our children and grandchildren.
3:18:35 Graham Cummins - Public Comment
Mr. Cummins, of 1703 West Olive Street Unit 15, who supported the Iraq Resolution, stated that
it is neither arrogant nor inappropriate to take a position on international relations. If these
deeisions are left to authorities in Washington, DC, we will be reduced to an oligarchy.
3:20:20 Drusha Mav/we - Public Comment
Ms. Mayhue, of 226 East Koch, who supported the Iraq Resolution, stated that when anything
concerns how our tax dollars are spent, then it is the business of the City. We are spending $12
billion each month on this war in Iraq, and this could be spent here.
3 :22: 16 Ron Pulcini - Public Comment
Mr. Puleini, of 411 West Garfield, who supported the Iraq Resolution, introduced himself in
Vietnamese. He described a young Vietnam soldier who later committed suicide. When these
men and women eome baek from Iraq, you're going to see terrible things happen.
3:25:24 Jeannie Gracie - Public Comment
Ms. Gracie, 410 North 4th, who supported the Iraq Resolution, urged the Commission to be in
support of the peaee resolution. She said people have to stand up loudly and be a voice in
Washington, DC.
3:25:53 Brie Cummins - Public Comment
Ms. Cummins, of 1703 West Olive Street #15, who supported the Iraq Resolution, stated that
continuing the war harms all communities through an enormous national debt, the loss of
soldiers' lives and health, and loss of other nations' goodwill. Represent community damage.
3:26:28 Sheralvn Devries - Public Comment
Ms. Devries, of 1330 Mountain Splendor Drive, who supported the Iraq Resolution, stated that
what's great about this resolution is that it's non-binding: no new taxes, no PTSD, no separating
families, and no locals closing business to serve overseas. It says local people are being harmed.
14
Linked Minutes of'the Bozeman (j~l' Commission Meeting, Decemher /7, 2007
3:28:39 Kirsten Valentine - Public Comment
Ms. Valcntinc, of 418 South 3rd A venue, who supported the Traq Resolution, stat cd the
Commission's voices arc louder than our voices to the gove1l1ment, and our Bozcman voices are
heard louder by you.
3:30:47 Richard Gillette - Public Comment
Mr. Gillcttc, of 1122 South 5th, who supported the Traq Resolution, stat cd that it is most
appropriate that the Commission consider this resolution. Local action is grassroots, dcmocratic,
and vcry American. Leadership is increasingly originating at the local level.
3:32:33 Don Bachman - Public Comment
Mr. Bachman, of 3910 Sourdough Road, who supported the Iraq Resolution, described his
military cxperience in Vietnam, and his experience on September 11,2001. We have a say in
how the federal gov't. docs its work. It is appropriate to pass this.
3:35:55 Mike Year - Public Comment
Mr. Year, of 29 Kane Drive, who supported the Traq Resolution, stated that in 1970 just back
from Vietnam he made a commitment to stand up and say something the next time this country
did this. He supports the troops and wants to see them come home.
3:38:43 Donald Mal.zola - Public Comment
Mr. Mazzola, of 612 North Bozeman, who supported the Iraq Resolution, stated he is fulfilling
his responsibility as a citizen. He has decided he wants to change the minds of any who want to
vote against this resolution.
3:40:14 Phvllis Bock - Public Comment
Ms. Bock, of1615 South Black, who supported the Traq Resolution, stated that she stood in front
of this courthouse every Saturday before the war started, and urged the Commission to vote in
support of this rcsolution.
3 :40:41 Kezia Vernon - Public Comment
Ms. Vernon, of 544 North Rouse, who support cd the Traq Resolution, asked the Commissioners
to speak in a spirit of compassion, progression, and integrity, and fulfill the City's core values
and votc tor this resolution.
3:41 :07 Bob Nichol- Public Comment
Mr. Nichol, of 1615 South Black, who supported the Iraq Resolution, described the impact:
shredded Bill of Rights, weakened economy, crippled armed forces, privatized military activities,
extended tours of duty, also suicides, desertions, divorce, bankruptcies, tamily problems.
3:46:04 Charlotte Trollim!er - Public Comment
Ms. Trollinger, one of the original Peace Seekers who lived in Bozeman for 25 years and now
lives in Boulder, supported the Iraq Rcsolution. She said cities arc part of the foundation of
democracy, and the Commission has a voice and a responsibility.
3:47:38 Mayor Krauss
15
Linked Minules (?/"the Bo;;;eman Cily Commission Meeting, Decemher 17, 2007
Mayor Krauss stated there are eight minutes left of public comment.
3:47:42 Paul Luwe, City Attorney
Mr. Luwe stated that in his opinion the Mayor can't limit a group of people to 45 minutes. He
recommended that the Mayor extends for both sides an opportunity for each person to speak to
thc three minute limit. The proceedings can continue, but people can't be denied participation.
3:48: 18 Mayor Krauss
Mayor Krauss said he will continue the proceedings.
3:48:36 Ashlev Kirchhofl- Public Comment
Ms. Kirchhoff, of 509 South 5th, who supported the Iraq Resolution, believes in freedom and
American values. She doesn't think this war supports our values in any way. It is a very
complicated ethnic contlict which we don't have the expertise to mediate.
3:50:29 Max Kirchhoff-Public Comment
Mr. Kirchhoff, of 516 South 6th, who supported the Iraq Resolution, said he is struggling to find
a reason why we're in Iraq because every reason is a lie. This war affects every person. Passing
this resolution is a step in the right direction.
3:51 :59 LuinKuv - Public Comment
Ms. Kay, of 17630 Big Elk Mcadow Road, Gallatin Gateway, who supported the Iraq
Resolution, said she has been standing against this war tor five years. To force the Iraqi gov't.
into action, we need to remove our troops.
3:52:55 Murf!uritu McLurtv - Public Comment
Ms. McLarty, who recently moved from Bozeman to Pray, MT, who supported the Iraq
Resolution, stated that police are struggling for personnel, the MT National Guard doesn't have
over half of its equipment, and federal funds are drying up. She presented a 17 page petition.
3:54:31 Glenn Alli11f!er - Public Comment
Mr. Allinger, of 112 Westridge Drive, who supported the Iraq Resolution, read a quotation from
Dwight Eisenhower. He stated that our national direction affects local priorities and resources,
both financial and human. We must bring troops home and rebuild alliances.
3:55:39 Steven Gram - Public Comment
Mr. Grant, of 1103 Hunters Way, who supported the Traq Resolution, stated that he is proud that
we have a City Council that has the courage to bring up a resolution like this.
3:56:14 Curu Wilder- Public Comment
Ms. Wilder, of 1701 Driftwood Drive, who supported the Iraq Resolution, suggested that in lieu
of supporting an amendment calling for the impeachment of George Bush and Dick Cheney tor
war crimes, she is in support of this resolution to act at the local level.
3:57:06 Collette Kirchhoff-Public Comment
16
Linked Minutes olthe Buzeman Ci~v Commission Meeting, December 17, 2U07
Ms. Kirchhoff, of 516 South 6th, who supported the Iraq Resolution, stated that she is a local
doctor who takes care of people who go to war. She said the medical journals estimate it will
cost at least $260 billion to take care of returning Iraq soldiers who are sick and scared.
3:58:41 Jesse Vernon - Public Comment
Mr. Vernon, of 2893 Sourdough Road, who suppol1ed the Iraq Resolution, suggested that if this
doesn't pass we should consider a resolution for a draft. For most of us, this is an intellectual
debate, and we're not involved in a meaningful way.
3:59:32 Public Comment closed for supporters, and opened for opponents ofresolution.
After all had spoken in support, Mayor Krauss closed this portion of public comment and opened
public comment for opponents of the resolution.
4:00:06 Kellv Wood - Public Comment
Mr. Wood, of Woodland Drive, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, stated that it's to the credit of
US Marines and taxpayers that 50 million people have been liberated from bondage in Iraq. He
asked to give war a chance.
4:04:51 Jeff Martv - Public Comment
Mr. Marty, an MSU student and vice president of the MSU College Republicans, who opposed
the Iraq Resolution, quoted from an Iraq veteran from Helena, "A surrender resolution is not
supporting our troops. . . . This is a blatant slap in our faces."
4:07:29 Sandv Schnurbusch - Public Comment
Ms. Sehnurbuseh, of 675 North 15th, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, is the mom of a Navy
sailor. She said that this resolution grieves her son. Each soldier from Bozeman was expecting
his/her community to support them. She wanted to change the resolution's language.
4:09: 13 Dvlan Lar.'mn - Public Comment
Mr. Larson, an MSU student, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, stated that in Helena and
Missoula the people voted, not five people voicing their opinion for the entire City. He wanted
the Commission to look at snow removal and high school and college safety.
4: 11 :40 Dan Riftter - Public Comment
Mr. Ritter, of 72 Kimball A venue, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, is a retired Marine who said
this resolution will have an impact on the troops. Allow the troops to finish the job. Pass a
resolution saying you want the troops to win and be proud.
4: 13:46 Dan Bieeerstaff- Public Comment
Mr. Biggerstaff: of 1409 Ash Drive, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, stated that he was a Navy
pilot, but the Commission is voted to take care of concerns of the City. He spoke for six retired
professors who want the Conm1ission to do the City's business.
4: 15: 15 Gerrv Lanevre - Public Comment
17
Linked Minules of'lhe 80zemun Cily Comlnission Meeting. Decemher /7. 2007
Mr. Lapeyre, of ] 704 South Willson, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, stated that the emotions
expressed tonight do not alter many erroneous facts: this war isn't illegal or immoral, and the
president isn't impeachable over this war. The war has turned around.
4: 17:36 Eric Brv.<mn - Public Comment
Mr. Bryson, of 2738 Harris, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, stated that the Commission
representing his interests in US foreign policy is a significant misunderstanding, or ignorance or
arrogance. As an elected City Cr., he won't subject the community to politically divisive stunts.
4:20: 18 Doue Chamnan - Public Comment
Mr. Chapman, 5915 Estate Lane in Belgrade, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, said many
Gallatin County residents have volunteered for this worthy effort to free oppressed people and
suppress evil. He offered alternate language tor a new resolution.
4:22:35 Dustin Lucas - Public Comment
Mr. Lucas, of 2220 West Main, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, stated that he has done two
tours of Iraq. Until you've seen the people we've freed, and the lives we've helped, you have no
right to pass a resolution saying that what we're doing there wrong.
4:24:00 Karen Lindell- Public Comment
Ms. Lindell, of416 East Aspen, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, stated that instead of adopting
a resolution that encourages the enemy and will cause more harm for soldiers, adopt a resolution
that will tell our government to let our soldiers to fight to win.
4:25: 18 Montv Bare - Public Comment
Mr. Bare, of 21 09 South Tracy, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, stated that he is proud to have
served in the Air Force. His friends who have served in Iraq say that what we see in the media is
not what most people in Iraq are treating our people like. Don't bring the war into our cities.
4:26:51 Kathi Bare - Public Comment
Ms. Bare, of 2109 South Tracy, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, stated that Monty lost his best
friend in Vietnam. She said this resolution is way out of line, and she is appalled. What's really
going on in Iraq is different from what the Communist News Network reports.
4:27:48 Robert Parker - Public Comment
Mr. Parker (didn't give realllame), who opposed the Iraq Resolution, stated that if the US leaves
Iraq now, thousands of men, women, and children could be slaughtered. It is irresponsible to.
invade the country, and now that it's broken, abandon it to slip back into genocide.
4:28:49 Heidi Douf!hertv - Public Comment
Ms. Dougherty, of2311 Milkhouse Avenue, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, is the mother and
aunt of soldiers. She said it has nothing to do with City Commission business. She said the
military had fewer members for Iraq because of 1992-2000 budget cuts.
4:30:28 Frank Sch/edorn - Public Comment
18
Linked Minutes (~rthe Bozenwn City Commissiun Meeting. December 17,2007
Mr. Schledorn, of 1208 North 8th A venue, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, supported a letter
to the editor from Don White. He described his and his family's military duty, and said this
resolution isn't the way to get out ofthis conflict. This wastes the Commission's time.
4:32:57 Charles Mainwarinl! - Public Comment
Mr. Mainwaring, of 3000 Trail Creek, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, stat cd that he is
absolutely disgusted. He is a Marine and said it seems this valley isn't supporting the war effort
at all. It sends a negative message and breaks his heart.
4:34: 13 Carol DelJler - Public Comment
Ms. Delger, of 28494 Norris Road, who opposed the Iraq Resolution, expressed her thoughts
about the Commission's extreme irresponsibility, not supporting our police and firc, wasting
money on the stupid Story Mansion, and called liberalism is a mental disorder.
4:34:59 Marietta Glaze - Public Comment
Ms. Glaze, who opposed the Traq Resolution, said thank you to each and every person who has
been in the military. She loves and thanks them. She asked the Commissioners to do the right
thing to vote against this.
4:35:37 Public Hearing closed.
Mayor Krauss closed the public hearing and thanked the public for their decorum.
4:36: 13 Motion the Commission approve Commission Resolution No. 4086 as drafted.
It was moved bv Cr. Kirchhoff. seconded bv Cr. Jacobson. the Commission approve
Commission Resolution No. 4086 as drafted.
4:36:43Cr. Kirchhoff
Cr. Kirchhoff' stated many people in this room can't agree on basic things, but the fact we can
discuss this is important. I-Ie takes seriously those who serve in the military. He doesn't wish any
harm on another American. In his mind, this resolution is 100% supporting the troops, bringing
them back.
4:40:42 Cr. Jacobson
Cr. Jacobson supports the resolution, and she thinks we should get involved because this war
affects us locally. She said that losing men and women is a tragedy. Things change from the
grassroots; nothing will change until we're willing to stand up and oppose this war. She
described how the US got into the Iraq War and the politics of fear used.
4:52: 1 0 Mayor Krauss
Mayor Krauss doesn't support the resolution, and said that unfortunately we have chosen to go
into an issue that's inappropriate for the City. He gave examples for the worthiness of American
sacrifice, talking about the Cold War, the perseverance of the American spirit, North Korea, and
the blessings of capitalism and freedom.
5 :00: 19 Cr. Becker
19
Lil/ked Mil/Illes o/'the Bozeman Ci~1' Commission Meeting, December 17, 2VIJ 7
Cr. Becker thanked the public for coming. He said this resolution starts with supporting the brave
men and women and honors those who have lost their lives or been disabled. He read the
resolution and said we all unequivocally support and honor our troops. This is a policy decision,
and it is our responsibility. This is an opportunity to improve the dialogue and hold our public
officials accountable.
5:04:44 Cr. Rupp
Cr. Rupp said both sides tonight ean be proud we can come together and express beliefs. He
struggles beeause he doesn't know the answer about where we are in this war. He described
difficult points about this war. He said he swore to support the Constitution and the separation of
powers. Citing Article 2, Section 2 of the Constitution, he said foreign policy is in the hands of
the executive, and that is how he will vote.
5:09:41 Vote the Commission approve Commission Resolution No. 4086 as drafted.
nt was moved bv Cr. Kirchhoff. seconded by Cr. Jacobson. the Commission aDDrove
Commission Resolution No. 4086 as drafted.]
Those votinl! Aye beinl! Crs. Kirchhoff. Jacobson. and Becker.
Those votinl! No beinl! Cr. RUDD and Mayor Krauss.
The motion carried 3-2.
5:10:07 J. Adjournment
Mayor Krauss adjourned the meeting at 11 :08 pm.
ATTEST:
St~~
PREPARED BY:
Cy laney, Deputy City Cler
Approved on ~hh.ul~ :1.51 ~()()i
20