HomeMy WebLinkAbout26 - Evaluations - Stucky Road RFQ (3)Stucky Road Reconstruction
Name of Reviewer:
Date of Review:
Prime Consultant
Sanbell
Allied Engineering (w/ RPA & Morrison Maierle)
HDR Engineering
Selection Criteria
Experience with Projects of Similar Size & Design
Max 40 pts
34
28
32
28 is base
Firm's Qualifications and Project Approach
Max 30 pts
26
21
27
21 is base
Ability to Meet Schedule and Budget
Max 10 pts
5
7
8
7 is base
Present and Projected Workload
Max 10 pts
6
7
8
7 is base
Past Projects/Experience working with the City of Bozeman
Max 5 pts
5
4
4
Office Location
Max 5 pts
5
5
5
Total Points Awarded
0
81
72
84
0
0
0
0
0
/100
/100
/100
/100
/100
/100
/100
/100
/100
Notes
concern with workload and ability to deliver project on timeline, by far the most direct transportation project experience, recent designs showed weakness in QA/QC and thoroughness,
less experience on water, wastewater, storm aspects,
experience with city projects lies mostly as a sub rather than prime role,
HDR appears to have put a good deal of thought into the project challenges and potential solutions, while HDR has no direct transportation project experience with the city, they have
a long and proven history in water and wastewater, project approach was detailed, tying in experience on other projects for context, broad range of transportation projects of similar
size and context with other cities in MT and with MDT, range of staff to meet project needs, clearly identified role and reason for subcontractors,