HomeMy WebLinkAbout25 - Notice of Awards - 2026 Urban Forest Management Plan (11)RFP – 2026 Urban Forest Management Plan
Scoring Tool
Candidate Name: __Flaming Tree_____________________ Date: ______12/1/25_____________________
Panelist Name: ______Alex Nordquest__________________ POINTS: ____70____/100 IX. SELECTION CRITERIA
Proposals will be evaluated based on the following criteria:
1. Respondent’s approach to the Project
Possible Points: 30
• Spelling errors; plain text with very little visuals/graphics/colors
• EAB – focused, little mention of fully comprehensive approach
• 16 pages total – the least detailed proposal submitted
POINTS_10/30
2. Qualifications of Firm and Key Personnel to be assigned to this Project
Possible Points: 20
• No UFMP experience
• More wildland, fire, and true forestry experience
POINTS___10/20
3. Capabilities to meet time schedule
Possible Points: 20
• They mention capacity and dedication
• Relatively close by (Wyoming) to facilitate in-person meetings
POINTS_20/20
4. Experience creating innovative public engagement methods
Possible Points: 20
• Not the most visually compelling examples or ideas mentioned
• Referencing other entities (DNRC, Arbor Day Foundation, Branch Out Bozeman) implies lack of
experience
POINTS__10/20
5. Familiarity and/or previous experience with City of Bozeman
Possible Points: 5
• Wyoming-based and familiarity with Bozeman area, but no previous work here
POINTS___5/5
6. Urban Forestry planning experience in Northern Rocky Mountain Region
Possible Points: 5
• Wyoming-based, similar climate/region
POINTS___5_/5