HomeMy WebLinkAbout24 - Notice of Awards - Professional Geographic Information Systems (GIS) Services (4)Criteria
#1
#2
#3
#4
#5
#6
[5 points] Executive Summary
[10 points] Proposal Requirements
[20 points] Experience with similar projects
[35 points] Approach to the Project
[20 points] Qualifications of the Firm for Scope of Services
[10 points] Cost
NOTES
Executive Summary
Proposal Requirements
Experience with similar projects
Approach to the Project
Qualifications of the Firm for Scope of Services
Cost
Phase 1 $$$$
Phase 2 $$$$
Weight
0.05
0.1
0.2
0.35
0.2
0.1
3
10
10
15
5
1
44
Cultivate Geospatial
0.15
1
2
5.25
1
0.1
9.5
Seattle Project look cool, why so cheap on our proposal?
15000
34000
3.5
10
14
22
15
8
72.5
GTG
0.175
1
2.8
7.7
3
0.8
15.475
Bringing in GHD (Kathleen Zynd)for CW Expiereince
58000
TBD
5
10
19
20
15
8
77
HDR
0.25
1
3.8
7
3
0.8
15.85
HDR will begin to draft a roadmap based on findings from the interviews, job shadowing, architecture, and system reviews
Small Team
Field Visits
Task2.1 Interviews and Job Shadowing
79400
198390
HDR will help the City set up a GIS Technical Committee and Governance Charter
2
10
10
12
10
4
48
InterDev
0.1
1
2
4.2
2
0.4
9.7
Small Team D2:E21
34000
69200
3
9
10
11
5
5
43
Mag River
0.15
0.9
2
3.85
1
0.5
8.4
140000
TBD
5
10
18
28
18
8
87
NV5
0.25
1
3.6
9.8
3.6
0.8
19.05
Deliverables: 2 day onsite workshop
Verti GIS As Sub
57800
TBD
NV5 Geospatial is the only firm to achieve a Platinum Partnership with both Esri and Cityworks.
2
10
10
12
10
2
46
Resource Data
0.1
1
2
4.2
2
0.2
9.5
Light on CW
Cover letter addressed to Alex
Experience with reliable and repeatable VertiGIS upgrades
Not all that confidan that one person "Letty" can do both Verti and CW, Not a overall great understandign of CW Upgrade
76125
294690
3
10
10
20
12
4
59
Sanborn
0.15
1
2
7
2.4
0.4
12.95
Overall just don’t like to looka dn feel fo the proposal light on CW
KCI as Sub for CW
AppGeo will develop an online survey to distribute to GIS and Asset Management stakeholders.
112044
110635
4
10
18
25
15
7
79
Timmons
0.2
1
3.6
8.75
3
0.7
17.25
VertiGIS Implementation Partner
just a few maps?
Only 30 CR reports to update * • Timmons Group will use Cityworks provided tools for the report migration
36580
TBD
Pedro Oliveira (VertiGIS Esri Gold Partner, Cityworks Platinum Implementation Partner, VertiGIS Implementation Partner
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Executive Summary
Firm/Individual Profile
Scope of Project•
Related Experience with Projects Similar to the Scope of Services
Description of Proposed Approach to the Project
Proposed Schedule
Present and Projected Workloads
Recent and Current Work for the City of Bozeman
References
Price Proposal for both Phase 1 & Phase 2
General and Technical Requirements
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Executive Summary
Firm/Individual Profile
Scope of Project•
General and Technical Requirements
Related Experience with Projects Similar to the Scope of Services
Description of Proposed Approach to the Project
Proposed Schedule
Present and Projected Workloads
Recent and Current Work for the City of Bozeman
References
Price Proposal for both Phase 1 & Phase 2