Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout26 - Notice to Proceed - HVAC MaintenanceExecutive Summary Qualifications of Firm for Scope of Services Price Proposal Description of Proposed Solution Present and Projected Workloads Related Experience / Work for City Total LONG Reviewer 1 3 11 28 13 4 2 61 S. Conley Tri-County M&E Core Control Johnson Controls Central P&H Apollo Independent HVAC Allied C&M Comfort Systems USA LONG Reviewer 2 4 0 5 0 0 1 10 AVG Score 88.2 82.2 78.6 67.8 66.8 59.2 58.8 50.8 50.4 38.4 Reviewer 3 4 4 10 5 7 3 33 Reviewer 4 5 10 15 15 6 2 53 Avg: Reviewer 5 5 10 3 10 5 2 35 38.4 Core Control Reviewer 1 4 18 28 24 4 4 82 Reviewer 2 3 10 25 25 3 5 71 Reviewer 3 3 15 25 20 2 5 70 Reviewer 4 5 18 28 23 7 5 86 Avg: Reviewer 5 4 16 30 25 5 4 84 78.6 Tri-County M&E Reviewer 1 4 17 26 24 7 3 81 Reviewer 2 3 20 20 10 10 5 68 Reviewer 3 1 20 30 25 9 4 89 Reviewer 4 5 18 26 24 5 4 82 Avg: Reviewer 5 4 19 27 28 9 4 91 82.2 Allied C&M Reviewer 1 0 5 23 10 4 3 45 Reviewer 2 1 5 10 1 1 1 19 Reviewer 3 4 15 25 10 3 3 60 Reviewer 4 1 10 25 15 5 1 57 Avg: Reviewer 5 3 20 24 15 7 4 73 50.8 Independent HVAC Reviewer 1 4 14 22 22 2 3 67 Reviewer 2 3 5 17 25 5 1 56 Reviewer 3 4 8 20 15 1 1 49 Reviewer 4 5 12 25 13 5 2 62 Avg: Reviewer 5 5 14 21 15 3 2 60 58.8 Johnson Controls Reviewer 1 4 18 20 24 3 4 73 Reviewer 2 3 10 20 25 5 5 68 Reviewer 3 2 12 20 15 1 1 51 Reviewer 4 5 18 24 22 1 4 74 Avg: Reviewer 5 3 15 18 27 5 5 73 67.8 S. Conley Reviewer 1 4 19 21 27 10 5 86 Reviewer 2 5 15 30 25 8 5 88 Reviewer 3 5 18 25 30 10 5 93 Reviewer 4 5 18 24 30 8 5 90 Avg: Reviewer 5 5 19 15 30 10 5 84 88.2 Apollo Reviewer 1 4 18 19 24 7 3 75 Reviewer 2 1 5 5 5 10 5 31 Reviewer 3 1 15 20 10 7 4 57 Reviewer 4 5 16 21 17 2 3 64 Avg: Reviewer 5 5 18 12 20 9 5 69 59.2 Comfort Systems USA Reviewer 1 4 18 16 20 0 0 58 Reviewer 2 5 5 20 30 1 0 61 Reviewer 3 5 0 20 10 0 0 35 Reviewer 4 5 18 23 21 2 1 70 Avg: Reviewer 5 4 5 9 10 0 0 28 50.4 Central P&H Reviewer 1 4 16 15 23 8 5 71 Reviewer 2 5 10 20 30 7 5 77 Reviewer 3 5 2 20 15 3 2 47 Reviewer 4 4 18 23 20 3 5 73 Avg: Reviewer 5 5 16 6 29 5 5 66 66.8