Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout05-19-25 Public Comment - J. Davis - Re_ I.1 Review and Consider the Boutique HotelFrom:Jack Davis To:Bozeman Public Comment Subject:[EXTERNAL]Re: I.1 Review and Consider the Boutique Hotel Date:Sunday, May 18, 2025 8:30:19 PM Attachments:Review and Consider the Boutique Hotel.docx CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. The City Commission of Bozeman, Montana May 18, 2025 Re: I.1 Review and Consider the Boutique Hotel My wife and I are writing in concern about Matt Paine’s application to build the Boutique Hotel in downtown Bozeman. She was born and raised in Bozeman and I have lived here for 50 years. The reason Bozeman has been such a charming and well received town over the years is not because of its high rise buildings. The high rise condos and hotels were constructed so out-of-town developers could “make a buck off of Bozeman.” They were planned and constructed to make money for the developers and not to enhance and improve the ambience and charm of the town. One example of this disrespect for Bozeman’s notable neighborhoods is the Guthrie Building. What an absolute shame! There are many more examples. The proposed building site for the Boutique Hotel is too small for a project this large. The Bozeman Creek flows adjacent to the building site. What are the consequences not if, but when, this creek floods? Where are all the vehicles that will be associated with this project going to park? The city needs to step back and re-evaluate the consequences of this project. There are too many possible problems related to this ill-conceived project. You need to take into consideration Matt Paine’s 6-Range Project located at the intersection of West Babcock and North Ferguson. A permit for this project was approved by the Bozeman City Commission more than 3 years ago. This development that was approved has been abandoned and now sits in limbo on 8-plus acres. It is a visual eyesore and a safety liability. Like the Boutique Hotel, the 6-Range Project should have never been approved by the city commission from its inception. The high-rise buildings proposed for that location are totally out of character with the one- and two-story surrounding neighborhoods. The City Commission of Bozeman should start over with their permitting processes and demand that all projects conform, comply and blend in with the characteristics of the surrounding neighborhoods. Neighborhoods have character because the buildings complement and enhance each other. Your in-fill and scatter- gun approach to buildings are just willy nilly and give Bozeman a hodge podge appearance of no “planning” at all. How many high rise hotels can Bozeman support? How many high rise buildings can be built in Bozeman before the town loses its appeal and charm? This is not the same quaint and charming town that it once was before all the high rise buildings were constructed. How many members of the City Commission of Bozeman were born and raised in Bozeman like Susan, my wife? She, and the people she grew up with, are all disgusted and sickened with all the high rise buildings this commission has approved over the past few years. The City Commission of Bozeman should require that any and all building projects they approve should be required to have a performance bond. That would insure that no developer, including the Paine Group, could walk away and abandon a project. Proposed developments that are authorized by the commission would have to be completed within the time frame of the original agreement. We oppose the Boutique Hotel development. We also oppose the 6-Range Project that has been abandoned inside the city limits by the Paine Group. The “Gold Rush” of “Building Bozeman” is totally out of hand! By giving the builders special concessions, you have essentially eliminated Bozeman’s parking availability. Now, our access to water is in jeopardy for the future with this total unrestrained viewpoint of “Build Bozeman for Big Profits.” If any of you commissioners lived next to one of these abomination high rise buildings, you would change your tune, especially when you can’t find a place to park in front of your own house. Please do not approve the Boutique Hotel. Whatever you decide to do regarding the Boutique Hotel at least require the Paine Group to clean up their mess at the 6-Range Project they abandoned within the city limits. Thank you for your time and consideration, Jack and Susan Davis 247 Mill Creek Drive Bozeman, MT 59718 wonderland@montana.com Cell – 406-581-1901 The City Commission of Bozeman, Montana May 18, 2025 Re: I.1 Review and Consider the Boutique Hotel My wife and I are writing in concern about Matt Paine’s application to build the Boutique Hotel in downtown Bozeman. She was born and raised in Bozeman and I have lived here for 50 years. The reason Bozeman has been such a charming and well received town over the years is not because of its high rise buildings. The high rise condos and hotels were constructed so out-of- town developers could “make a buck off of Bozeman.” They were planned and constructed to make money for the developers and not to enhance and improve the ambience and charm of the town. One example of this disrespect for Bozeman’s notable neighborhoods is the Guthrie Building. What an absolute shame! There are many more examples. The proposed building site for the Boutique Hotel is too small for a project this large. The Bozeman Creek flows adjacent to the building site. What are the consequences not if, but when, this creek floods? Where are all the vehicles that will be associated with this project going to park? The city needs to step back and re-evaluate the consequences of this project. There are too many possible problems related to this ill-conceived project. You need to take into consideration Matt Paine’s 6-Range Project located at the intersection of West Babcock and North Ferguson. A permit for this project was approved by the Bozeman City Commission more than 3 years ago. This development that was approved has been abandoned and now sits in limbo on 8-plus acres. It is a visual eyesore and a safety liability. Like the Boutique Hotel, the 6-Range Project should have never been approved by the city commission from its inception. The high-rise buildings proposed for that location are totally out of character with the one- and two-story surrounding neighborhoods. The City Commission of Bozeman should start over with their permitting processes and demand that all projects conform, comply and blend in with the characteristics of the surrounding neighborhoods. Neighborhoods have character because the buildings complement and enhance each other. Your in-fill and scatter-gun approach to buildings are just willy nilly and give Bozeman a hodge podge appearance of no “planning” at all. How many high rise hotels can Bozeman support? How many high rise buildings can be built in Bozeman before the town loses its appeal and charm? This is not the same quaint and charming town that it once was before all the high rise buildings were constructed. How many members of the City Commission of Bozeman were born and raised in Bozeman like Susan, my wife? She, and the people she grew up with, are all disgusted and sickened with all the high rise buildings this commission has approved over the past few years. The City Commission of Bozeman should require that any and all building projects they approve should be required to have a performance bond. That would insure that no developer, including the Paine Group, could walk away and abandon a project. Proposed developments that are authorized by the commission would have to be completed within the time frame of the original agreement. We oppose the Boutique Hotel development. We also oppose the 6-Range Project that has been abandoned inside the city limits by the Paine Group. The “Gold Rush” of “Building Bozeman” is totally out of hand! By giving the builders special concessions, you have essentially eliminated Bozeman’s parking availability. Now, our access to water is in jeopardy for the future with this total unrestrained viewpoint of “Build Bozeman for Big Profits.” If any of you commissioners lived next to one of these abomination high rise buildings, you would change your tune, especially when you can’t find a place to park in front of your own house. Please do not approve the Boutique Hotel. Whatever you decide to do regarding the Boutique Hotel at least require the Paine Group to clean up their mess at the 6-Range Project they abandoned within the city limits. Thank you for your time and consideration, Jack and Susan Davis 247 Mill Creek Drive Bozeman, MT 59718 wonderland@montana.com Cell – 406-581-1901