HomeMy WebLinkAbout02-27-24 Public Comment - C. Mcqueary - Public comment for CC mtg Grand Ceilo 22090From:Christopher Mcqueary
To:Agenda
Cc:Daniel Carty; Kaveney Marcia; dangie@me.com; Craighead April; Lara Schulz
Subject:[EXTERNAL]Public comment for CC mtg Grand Ceilo 22090
Date:Tuesday, February 27, 2024 12:15:58 PM
Attachments:GC ll CC mtg statement for 02.27.24.pdf
CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you
recognize the sender and know the content is safe.
Sent from Outlook
Dear City Commissioners
Public Comment re. Gran Cielo II Agenda for Feb 27 2024
My name is Chris McQueary I live at 3306 S 29th and I am an adjoiner to the proposed Grand Cielo
development and more importantly to the Kurk St Forest on its southern boundary.
I’d like to bring your attentfon once again to a piece of land proposed for the Grand Cielo ll development.
I hope you can visit this area soon in person to see why it is so valuable to all of us and why the mature
trees and forest found there are the developer’s greatest asset and can now be preserved through
thoughtiul and efficient site planning guided by you.
A lot of tfme has been spent in our lives composing the many 3 minute blocks of spoken and written
commentary which we have then presented to our city commission and to the developers about this
property and proposed development. We used our tfme to describe the values of this property centered
squarely on the conservatfon of its trees (the asset to us all) and known as the Kurk street forest.
To summarize what has been spoken and written previously about this asset:
Natfve and mature trees are deeply rooted in the 80 acre historic ag land that is being proposed for
development and was recently annexed by the commission. The trees as the asset, have created the
Kurk St forest. When I say a forest, I mean a fully ecologically functfoning, thriving type of ecosystem
which supports many plants, and animals. For example, the relatfvely large populatfon of birds nestfng in
this forest have been doing so generatfon after generatfon, season after season for nearly 100 years.
There are two stands of trees bisected by a seasonal irrigatfon waterway which looks like any other
stream in Montana. The two narrow ribbons of tree stands that are about the width of a 2 lane street
makes them an easy natural feature to design around for preservatfon.
Scarcity alone could be the greatest factor in knowing that these trees are an asset to all of us. An
interestfng fact is that less than 4% of the 80 acres being proposed for development are forested. From a
higher-level view, the new owners of the 80 acres are quite fortunate as they have acquired 50% of all
the trees in a 640 acre area. Check this out on google earth, it’s striking. Scarcity alone is not the only
factor though. While the ecological value is the most important asset to myself and others who are
centered on such things, I realized that there is another important value factor as well…. one which is
monetary. This factor is known and currently used by the developers themselves in their promotfonal
video (https://grancielobzn.com/ ) . As any perspectfve buyer can see in the video, the trees and forest
are showcased in the foreground in their brilliant fall colors. It is stated that these are the “million-dollar
views” being made available to current and future residents of Grand Cielo. I am sure that current and
future potentfal residents were drawn in by the belief that the aesthetfcs provided by the trees and the
forest would be lastfng in perpetuity as was my family in our decision to invest in our property nearby.
We see these trees every day as they fill the windows of our home and as we enjoy them while outside.
Each tfme we return home, the trees are there. Because of this invaluable part of our life, there has been
many sleepless nights and fear within our household since the announcement of Grand Cielo ll and how
it might be designed without tree conservatfon as the priority. I felt some relief to see that the
developers had recognized their asset. I am now hopeful that the preliminary plat and site design is
created with city requirements and ordinance to recognize the conservatfon of the most important
asset………the trees of Kurk St Forest.
On Sunday evening my young son told me that he heard the owl. Once I heard it as well , everything we
were doing stopped and we ventured into the Kurk St forest. While being guided by the sound (which we
know well as a great horned owl) we were able to catch up with wise old owl and had a few minutes to
watch this creature which resides here in the winter. This outfng reminds us of the trees which stand
dormant now waitfng for spring and for the birds to return when they will bloom again for possibly the
100th tfme. This forest is stfll alive and well.
Dormant trees in Kurk St Forest winter 2022/23
Thank you
Chris