HomeMy WebLinkAbout03-09-20 City Commission Packet Materials - A1. Deviation to Site Plan 19-128 App 19445Commission Memorandum
REPORT TO: Mayor and City Commission
FROM: Sarah Rosenberg, AICP, Associate Planner
SUBJECT: Update to Conditions of Approval for East Mendenhall Mixed Use
Modification/Certificate of Appropriateness Deviation application to an approved Site Plan
application (19-128) to allow for encroachment of open space hardscaping and a 4-foot awning
into the 35-foot watercourse setback. Application 19445.
STRATEGIC PLAN: 4.2 High Quality Urban Approach. Continue to support high quality
planning, ranging from building design to neighborhood layouts, while pursuing urban approaches
to issues such as multimodal transportation, infill, density, connected trails and parks, and walkable
neighborhoods.
4.4 Vibrant Downtown, Districts & Centers. Promote a healthy, vibrant Downtown, Midtown, and
other commercial districts and neighborhood centers – including higher densities and
intensification of uses in these key areas.
MEETING DATE: February 24, 2020
CONTINUED DATE: March 9, 2020
AGENDA ITEM TYPE: Regular
RECOMMENDATION: Approve the Modification/Certificate of Appropriateness Deviation
application to an approved Site Plan application (19-128) to allow for encroachment of open space
hardscaping and a 4-foot awning into the 35-foot watercourse setback. Application 19445.
BACKGROUND: On October 9 2019, an application was received for a
Modification/Certificate of Appropriateness Deviation to modify an approved site plan to allow
for encroachment of open space hardscaping and a 4-foot awning into the 35-watercourse setback.
Per BMC Sec. 38.200.010.A.1.k, the City Commission has the right to review more than two
deviations or where a deviation is for more than 20% of the standard.
At the Monday, February 24, 2020 hearing, the City Commission continued the agenda item to
March 9, 2020 to reevaluate the conditions of approval.
146
Staff met with the applicant team to discuss the conditions of approval and came to an agreement.
The updated conditions of approval are below and outlined in the attached staff report.
1. Any additional trees that need to be removed during the construction process must be
approved by the City Forester prior to removal.
2. The applicant must consult with a qualified professional, approved by the Community
Development Director, to perform archeological monitoring during excavation work. The
applicant will then produce a findings report to the City of Bozeman’s Historic
Preservation Specialist.
3. The applicant must work with the Community Development Department to create
interpretative signage along the creek as outlined in the 2019 Downtown Bozeman
Improvement Plan. The applicant must install and maintain the interpretative signage.
4. The applicant must work with the City of Bozeman Engineering Division on any
restoration work beyond the approved landscaping plan.
Code Provisions
1. Any work along the creek bank must conform to the approved landscaping plans.
2. BMC Chapter 40, Article 4. Any work on the site must conform to the approved
stormwater permit.
UNRESOLVED ISSUES: None identified.
ALTERNATIVES: None suggested or proposed.
FISCAL EFFECTS: Fiscal impacts are undetermined at this time, but will include increased
property tax revenues from new development, along with increased costs to deliver municipal
services to the property.
Report compiled on: February 6, 2020
Attachments: Staff Memo
147
19445 Staff Report for the East Mendenhall Mixed Use
Modification/Certificate of Appropriateness Deviation Request Application
Date: City Commission Public Hearing, February 24, 2020, 6:00pm
CONTINUED: March 9, 2020
Project Description: Modification/Certificate of Appropriateness Deviation application to an
approved Site Plan application (19-128) to allow for encroachment of open space hardscaping
and a 4-foot awning into the 35-foot watercourse setback
Project Location: 240 E. Mendenhall St., Bozeman Original Plat, S07, T02 S, R06 E, Block D,
Parcel A Plat C-1-H, City of Bozeman, Gallatin County, Montana
Recommendation: The application conforms to standards and is sufficient for approval with
conditions.
Recommended Motion: Having reviewed and considered the application materials, public
comment, and all the information presented, I hereby adopt the staff findings as presented in
the staff report for application 19445 that the application does meet the criteria required for
approval and move to approve with conditions the East Mendenhall Mixed Use application for
the deviations requested to allow for encroachment of open space hardscaping and
encroachment into the watercourse setback.
Report Date: Tuesday, February 11, 2020
Staff Contacts: Sarah Rosenberg, AICP, Associate Planner
Agenda Item Type: Action (Quasi-judicial)
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Unresolved Issues
None identified at this time.
Project Summary
Two zoning deviation requests have been submitted by the applicant to allow for
encroachment of structures into the 35-foot watercourse setback along Bozeman Creek. The
applicant is proposing to alter a site plan application for a six-story mixed-use development.
The site plan was approved on September 25, 2019. The approved site plan did not include any
sort of encroachment into the watercourse setback and only consisted of natural vegetation
and a shortened awning. The applicant is seeking one deviation to enhance the open space,
which would include hardscaping, a deck and other structural amenities that would encroach
148
19445 Staff Report for the East Mendenhall Mixed Use MOD/Deviation Page 2 of 16
into the watercourse setback. The second deviation is to allow for a 4-foot building cantilever
from the proposed building that would protrude over the watercourse setback. One motion is
stated for this multiple deviation request as Staff is recommending approval for both. The
findings below are split to address the two separate deviations.
The property is located in the B-3, Downtown Business Zoning District and is within the
Neighborhood Conservation Overlay District (NCOD). The property currently serves as a parking
lot.
Pursuant to Section 38.200.010.1.k of the Bozeman Municipal Code (BMC), “the City
Commission retains to itself under all circumstances” the review of any deviation request
where the deviation is for more than 20% of the standard. The proposed encroachment into
the watercourse setback requires a deviation great than 20% of the standard and therefore
requires review and decision by the City Commission.
Section 38.340.050.D. BMC, Standards for certificates of appropriateness, states that when
reviewing a contemporary, non-period, or innovative design for new structures or additions to
existing structures, the review authority must be guided by the design guidelines for the
neighborhood conservation overlay district to determine whether the proposal is compatible
with any existing or surrounding structures. A description of the NCOD Guidelines review
criteria and staff evaluation is in Section 5 of this report.
The application must also meet the standards for granting deviations in Section 38.340.070,
BMC. A description and staff evaluation of these standards is in Section 5 of this report.
Public comment has been received in support of the deviation.
Conditions of Approval
1. Any additional trees that need to be removed during the construction process must be
approved by the City Forester prior to removal.
2. The applicant must consult with a qualified professional, approved by the Community
Development Director, to perform archeological monitoring during excavation work.
The applicant will then produce a findings report to the City of Bozeman’s Historic
Preservation Specialist.
3. The applicant must work with the Community Development Department to create
interpretative signage along the creek as outlined in the 2019 Downtown Bozeman
Improvement Plan. The applicant must install and maintain the interpretative signage.
4. The applicant must work with the City of Bozeman Engineering Division on any
restoration work beyond the approved landscaping plan.
Code Provisions
1. Any work along the creek bank must conform to the approved landscaping plans.
149
19445 Staff Report for the East Mendenhall Mixed Use MOD/Deviation Page 3 of 16
2. BMC Chapter 40, Article 4. Any work on the site must conform to the approved
stormwater permit.
Alternatives
1. Deny the application with the following motion: “Having reviewed and considered the
application materials, public comment, and all the information presented, I hereby find
that application 19445 does not meet the criteria required for approval and move to deny
the East Mendenhall Mixed Use application for a deviation request to allow for
encroachment into the watercourse setback.
2. Open and continue the public hearing on the application, with specific direction to Staff or
the applicant to supply additional information or to address specific items.
150
19445 Staff Report for the East Mendenhall Mixed Use MOD/Deviation Page 4 of 16
TABLE OF CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ...................................................................................................... 1
Unresolved Issues ............................................................................................................... 1
Project Summary ................................................................................................................. 1
Public comment has been received in support of the deviation. ......................................... 2
Conditions of Approval....................................................................................................... 2
Alternatives ......................................................................................................................... 3
TABLE OF CONTENTS .......................................................................................................... 4
SECTION 1 - MAP AND PLAN SERIES ............................................................................... 5
SECTION 2 – PROPOSED DESIGN....................................................................................... 6
SECTION 3 - REQUESTED DEVIATION(S) ...................................................................... 10
SECTION 4 - RECOMMENDATION AND FUTURE ACTIONS ...................................... 10
SECTION 5 - STAFF ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS ........................................................... 11
Applicable Plan Review Criteria ...................................................................................... 11
APPENDIX A – PROJECT SITE ZONING AND GROWTH POLICY............................... 15
APPENDIX B – DETAILED PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND BACKGROUND.............. 15
APPENDIX C – NOTICING AND PUBLIC COMMENT ................................................... 16
APPENDIX D – OWNER INFORMATION AND REVIEWING STAFF ........................... 16
FISCAL EFFECTS ................................................................................................................. 16
ATTACHMENTS ................................................................................................................... 16
151
19445 Staff Report for the East Mendenhall Mixed Use MOD/Deviation Page 5 of 16
SECTION 1 - MAP AND PLAN SERIES
CURRENT ZONING MAP
152
Page 6 of 16
SECTION 2 – PROPOSED DESIGN
PROPOSED SITE PLAN
153
19445 Staff Report for the East Mendenhall Mixed Use MOD/Deviation Page 7 of 16
PROPOSED LANDSCAPE PLAN
154
19445 Staff Report for the East Mendenhall Mixed Use MOD/Deviation Page 8 of 16
APPROVED SITE PLAN WITH APPLICATION 19128
155
19445 Staff Report for the East Mendenhall Mixed Use MOD/Deviation Page 9 of 16
EAST ELEVATION ALONG BOZEMAN CREEK
VIEW FROM EAST MENDENHALL
156
19445 Staff Report for the East Mendenhall Mixed Use MOD/Deviation Page 10 of 16
SECTION 3 - REQUESTED DEVIATION(S)
The applicant has submitted two zoning deviation requests from Section 38.410.100 BMC to
allow for encroachment of open space hardscaping and a 4-foot awning into the 35-foot
watercourse setback.
Section 38.410.100.A.1.a.(2) states that “no fence, residential or commercial structure, fill
material, parking or other similar improvements shall be located within required watercourse
setback.” There is a 35-foot watercourse setback along Bozeman Creek, which prohibits any
structure from being located in the setback. The open space hardscaping, structures within it,
and the awning all encroach into the watercourse setback.
The applicant argues that the term setback defined by the BMC should not apply to the
building’s awning that encroaches into the watercourse setback. However, the Bozeman
Municipal Code defines “setback,” in relevant part, as the space on the same lot with a principal
building, which is open and unoccupied from the ground upward or from the ground
downward. See section 38.700.170 BMC. Therefore, the proposed awning encroaches into the
watercourse setback and is not allowed under 38.410.100 absent an approved deviation.
SECTION 4 - RECOMMENDATION AND FUTURE ACTIONS
The proposed application and associated deviation request requires the review and decision of
the City Commission. The City Commission retains to itself under all circumstances the review
of any deviation request where the deviation is for more than 20% of the standard.
Staff’s position is that the application conforms to standards and is sufficient for approval with
conditions. The Unified Development Code prohibits structures within the watercourse setback.
However, the application meets all deviation criteria and findings supporting the approval of
the deviation request are below.
Additionally, following conditions are required to approve the application and findings
supporting these conditions is below.
5. Any additional trees that need to be removed during the construction process must be
approved by the City Forester prior to removal.
6. The applicant must consult with a qualified professional, approved by the Community
Development Director, to perform archeological monitoring during excavation work.
The applicant will then produce a findings report to the City of Bozeman’s Historic
Preservation Specialist.
7. The applicant must work with the Community Development Department to create
interpretative signage along the creek as outlined in the 2019 Downtown Bozeman
Improvement Plan. The applicant must install and maintain the interpretative signage.
157
19445 Staff Report for the East Mendenhall Mixed Use MOD/Deviation Page 11 of 16
8. The applicant must work with the City of Bozeman Engineering Division on any
restoration work beyond the approved landscaping plan.
Code Provisions
3. Any work along the creek bank must conform to the approved landscaping plans.
4. BMC Chapter 40, Article 4. Any work on the site must conform to the approved
stormwater permit.
The City Commission considered the proposal on February 24, 2020 and continued the meeting
to March 9, 2020. The City Commission public hearing will occur at 121 North Rouse Avenue,
Bozeman MT, in the City Commission room at 6 p.m.
SECTION 5 - STAFF ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
Staff’s analysis and resulting recommendations are based on the entirety of the application
materials, municipal codes, standards, and plans, public comment, and all other materials
available during the review period. Collectively this information is the record of the review. The
analysis in this report is a summary of the completed review. Unless specifically modified in this
application all conditions and code requirements from the original site plan approval (19128)
remain in effect.
Applicable Plan Review Criteria
The applicant is advised that unmet code provisions, or code provisions that are not specifically
listed as conditions of approval, does not, in any way, create a waiver or other relaxation of the
lawful requirements of the Bozeman Municipal Code or State law.
In considering applications for plan approval, the review authority and advisory bodies evaluate
the following criteria. This application must comply with all applicable requirements of BMC
chapter 38 including overlay district requirements. The staff provides findings analyzed under
the following relevant sections of code and applicable plans:
• BMC 38.340.050 Standards for Certificate of Appropriateness
• BMC 38.340.070 Criteria for Granting Deviations
• Downtown Bozeman Improvement Plan
• Bozeman Creek Enhancement Plan
Standards for Certificate of Appropriateness
Pursuant to Section 38.340.050 BMC, all work performed within the Neighborhood
Conservation Overlay District (NCOD) must be in conformance with the most recent edition of
the Secretary of the Interior’s (SOI) Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties. The
approved site plan application (19128) associated with these deviations was reviewed under
the Site Plan and Certificate of Appropriateness criteria and found to have met standards.
Nothing in this deviation application affects the initial determination of the approved site plan
158
19445 Staff Report for the East Mendenhall Mixed Use MOD/Deviation Page 12 of 16
as all Certificate of Appropriateness criteria have been met. The staff report for that site plan
application is included at the end of this packet.
Criteria for Granting Deviations
Pursuant to Section 38.340.070 BMC, there are three criteria for granting deviations from the
underlying zoning requirement.
1. Modifications must be more historically appropriate for the building and site in question
and the adjacent properties, as determined by the standards in Section 38.340.050, than
would be achieved under a literal enforcement of this chapter.
Bozeman Creek was channelized through the center of town back in the early days of the area’s
settlement, as evidenced by Sanborn maps dating from 1891. It was narrowed, straightened,
and banks armored with rock, concrete, and other materials. Since the realignment, Bozeman
Creek was diverted to be utilized for the built environment. Structures were built up to and
over the creek. Included in this packet are photographs and maps showing the history of the
built environment colliding with the natural environment. On this very parcel, the pattern of
development shows that structures were built over the creek and next to it (see historic
documents and information at the end of this report).
Although the proposed enhanced open space and cantilever do not replicate what was
traditional to the construction or style of the early settlement of Bozeman, staff finds that the
traditional placement of structures very close to the creek is more historically appropriate to
the history of the site. Bozeman Creek was forced to meander through downtown to be utilized
for industry and recreation. Similarly, applicant has proposed deviations will enhance the
recreational use and enjoyment of the creek by providing enhanced outdoor open space
adjacent to the creek. Staff finds that the enhanced open space on the site is more historically
appropriate and traditional to the utilization of Bozeman Creek.
Similar to the findings of the enhanced open space, staff finds that the cantilever encroaching
over the watercourse setback is historically appropriate as structures were historically built
right up to the creek.
2. Modifications will have minimal adverse effects on abutting properties or the permitted
uses thereof.
Granting deviations to allow for hardscaping in the open space and a protruding awning to
encroach into the watercourse setback will have minimal adverse effects on abutting
properties. All along Bozeman Creek, there are structures and buildings that abut up against it.
To the south of the subject property, 311 E. Main (Bar IX) cantilevers over the creek and has an
outdoor patio that is adjacent to Bozeman Creek. Across the creek to the east is a parking lot
that fronts directly up to the creek. To the north, 317 E. Mendenhall (Fresco restaurant) and
159
19445 Staff Report for the East Mendenhall Mixed Use MOD/Deviation Page 13 of 16
121 N. Rouse (City Hall) both have buildings that front very closely to the creek and within the
watercourse setback. It is consistent with the pattern and character of the neighborhood and
neighboring properties will experience no adverse effects.
3. Modifications must assure the protection of the public health, safety and general welfare.
Approvals may be conditioned to assure such protection, and such conditions may include a
time period within which alterations will be completed; landscaping and maintenance
thereof; architectural, site plan and landscape design modifications, or any other conditions
in conformity with the intent and purpose set forth in this part 1.
Staff has identified no significant barriers to public health, safety and general welfare from the
proposed construction. The enhancement of the open space will allow for residents, tenants
and the public to utilize the area adjacent to Bozeman Creek. A proposed railing and retaining
wall will alleviate public safety concerns regarding public access to the creek. The permeable
pavers will help reduce storm water runoff and restore a functioning creek to enhance public
health. The protruding awnings does not have any sort of impact on the public health, safety,
and general welfare.
In addition to the deviation criteria above, the Uniform Development Code (chapter 38 BMC)
requires conformance with specific plans adopted by the City of Bozeman. The Downtown
Bozeman Improvement Plan and Downtown Creek Enhancement Plan are applicable to this
project. The designed conditions identified by staff as necessary for approval of the deviations
to bring the project into compliance with these two plans.
Downtown Bozeman Improvement Plan
Adopted in 2019 by the City Commission, the Downtown Bozeman Improvement Plan (DBIP)
serves as a neighborhood plan to provide recommendations in shaping Bozeman’s downtown.
One of the themes of the DBIP is to connect to nature and culture by enhancing the natural
systems and increasing public spaces. Bozeman Creek flows right through downtown, but it is
piped, hidden under roads and parking lots, largely overgrown, or fenced. The goal of
enhancing Bozeman Creek is to reveal the creek, which would help create places to linger and
points to interact with the creek. Revealing the creek can also help produce strategies that help
find healthier ways for the natural waterways to filter storm water.
The requested deviation to allow for encroachment into the watercourse setback will help
achieve these goals. The enhanced open space creates points of access to Bozeman Creek’s
edge and allows the public to experience the waterways. Staff has made three conditions of
approval to help achieve the goals of enhancing and engaging Bozeman Creek. Restoration
efforts and rehabilitation activity will assist in opening and revitalizing that portion of the creek
as noted in condition number one.
160
19445 Staff Report for the East Mendenhall Mixed Use MOD/Deviation Page 14 of 16
The DBIP also emphasizes creating signage along the creek to capture the history and ecological
storytelling. Condition number three notes that the applicant must work with the appropriate
parties to create interpretive signage along the creek on the subject property.
Downtown Creek Enhancement Plan
In 2012, the City of Bozeman developed the Downtown Creek Enhancement Plan (DCEP), which
created goals, objectives, and strategies to assist in enhancing Bozeman Creek through
downtown. Staff finds that the requested deviations along with the recommended conditions
of approval advance the following goals and objectives.
Objective 1.1: Inform residents about the natural resource values of the creek corridor, the
ecological services it provides, its past and present importance to the Bozeman community,
and current enhancement efforts.
As stated in condition number three, interpretive signage along the creek will provide
educational opportunities on the history and ecological services it provides. Condition number
two requires the applicant to work with the City of Bozeman Historic Preservation Specialist
during excavation to determine if there are any artifacts that could be used to inform residents
about relevant historic information that could be placed on interpretive signage.
Goal 2: Restore the natural processes necessary for a functioning stream ecosystem.
The restoration efforts affiliated with this deviation request and conditions of approval will
assist in restoring the structure of Bozeman Creek. Proposed permeable pavers and landscaping
will help retain storm water runoff. Plantings proposed along the creek bed and adjacent to the
creek will assist in restoring the natural process. It is the intent of the applicant to protect all
existing vegetation within the 5’ non-disturbance zone. To achieve the goals of the DCEP,
condition number one requires proper tree inspection and evaluation. The City Engineering
Division reviewed and approved the proposed landscape plan. Condition number four requires
the applicant to work with the City Engineering Division on any additional restoration work
along the creek’s bank.
Objective 3.1: Minimize pollution of surface and ground water for sediment, biological
pathogens, excess nutrients, urban pollutants and hazardous wastes.
A Design Report provided with the application explains how water, sanitary sewer, and storm
drainage improvements designed on the site help minimize pollution of surface and
groundwater. The application includes a below-grade StormTech detention system that will
allow for infiltration of storm water runoff from the roof, hardscape and landscape. The
Engineering Division reviewed and approved this plan. As stated above, the permeable pavers
in the enhanced open space help limit storm water runoff, which will minimize pollution of
surface and ground water.
161
19445 Staff Report for the East Mendenhall Mixed Use MOD/Deviation Page 15 of 16
APPENDIX A – PROJECT SITE ZONING AND GROWTH POLICY
Zoning Designation and Land Uses: The subject property is zoned B-3 (Downtown Business
District). The intent of the downtown B-3 business district is to provide a central area for the
community's business, government service and cultural activities with urban residential
development as an essential supporting use. The downtown B-3 district should be the area of
greatest density of development, intensity of use, and appropriate infill. Design standards
reinforcing the area's historical pedestrian-oriented context are very important.
This district encourages high volume, pedestrian-oriented uses in ground floor space in the
"core area" of the city's central business district, i.e., along Main Street from Grand to Rouse
and to the alleys one-half block north and south from Main Street. Lower volume pedestrian
uses such as professional offices may locate on ground floor space in the downtown B-3 area
outside the above-defined core.
Adopted Growth Policy Designation: The property is designated as “Community Core” in the
Bozeman Community Plan. The Plan indicates that, “The traditional core of Bozeman is the
historic downtown. This area has an extensive mutually supportive diversity of uses, a strong
pedestrian and multi-modal transportation network, and a rich architectural character.
Essential government services, places of public assembly, and open spaces provide the civic and
social core of town. Residential development on upper floors is well established. New
residential uses should be high density. The area along Main Street should be preserved as a
place for high pedestrian activity uses, with strong pedestrian connectivity to other uses on
nearby streets. Users are drawn from the entire planning area and beyond. The intensity of
development is high with a Floor Area Ratio well over 1. Future development should continue
to be intense while providing areas of transition to adjacent areas and preserving the historic
character of Main Street.”
APPENDIX B – DETAILED PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND BACKGROUND
The Planning Division received an application for Modification/CCOA with a deviation
application to an approved Site Plan on October 9, 2019. A corrections letter was sent on
November 4, 2019. Revisions were received on December 10, 2019. The application was
deemed adequate for continued review on January 2, 2020 and the City Commission hearing
and noticing was scheduled. The subject application is a request for the City Commission to
review and approve a deviation for watercourse encroachment. The application is proposing to
allow for encroachment into the watercourse setback along Bozeman Creek. The property is
located at 240 E. Mendenhall and is zoned B-3. It is outside of a Historic District but located
within the NCOD.
162
19445 Staff Report for the East Mendenhall Mixed Use MOD/Deviation Page 16 of 16
Pursuant to Section 38.200.010 of the Bozeman Municipal Code, the City Commission retains
itself under all circumstances the review of any deviation request where the deviation is for
more than 20% of the standard.
APPENDIX C – NOTICING AND PUBLIC COMMENT
Notice was provided pursuant to Section 38.40.030, BMC. Notice was sent to property owners
within 200 feet of the exterior boundaries of the property via USPS first class mail on February
6, 2020 which was at least 15 and not more than 45 days prior to the expected decision by the
City Commission. Notice was published in the Bozeman Daily Chronicle on February 16 and
February 23. A 24” x 36” notice sign was posted on site on February 6, 2020.
Public comment was received in support of the deviation.
APPENDIX D – OWNER INFORMATION AND REVIEWING STAFF
Owner/Applicant: Hooks Ranch, LLC, 43 Sheffield Place, Southfield, CT 06489
Representative: Intrinsik Architecture, Inc., 111 N. Tracy Avenue, Bozeman, MT 59715
Report By: Sarah Rosenberg, AICP, Associate Planner
FISCAL EFFECTS
No unusual fiscal effects have been identified. No presently budgeted funds will be changed by
this application.
ATTACHMENTS
The full application and file of record (#19445) can be viewed at the Bozeman Community
Development Department at 20 E. Olive Street, Bozeman, MT 59715.
Application Documents
Application Plans
Approved Site Plan Staff Report
163