HomeMy WebLinkAboutTab 14 1 1-23 [21:21.371 Public Comment - Dennis Kidder
Dennis Kidder resides in Bozeman and supports Bridger View Trailer Park_
4.14.02 [21:22 00] Public Comment: - did not state name and address
Supports Bridger View 'Trailer Park.
4.15:42 [21 22:331 Public Comment - hick Klein
Rick Klein resides in Bozeman and is against any ordinance restricting the landowner of
Bridger View Trailer Park.
4-10-27 [21-24-2Q] Public Comment - Chris Kober
Chris Kober resides at Bridger View trailer- Park #54 and supports efforts to save Bridger
View Trailer Park.
4 17.25 [21-26:31 1 Cormnissioncr Rupp
4 19.29 [21.30:1 31 Commissioner Jacohson
4 21:25 1 21.33:36] Commissioner Rupp
4 22 01 121.36:48] Commissioner Becker
4 24 39 [ 21:39.561 Mayor Krauss
4:28.1 1 [21 40-21] Commvsroner Rupp
4 29.32 [21 41:45] Commissioner Jacobson
4 30 03 [21..43:13] Motion and Vole
It was moved by Cr. Rupp,seconded by Cr. Jacobson to direct staff to pursue option 2 jof
the Commission Memo interim Zonin , Ordinance and brin this back for the C onunission's
consideration.
Those voting Aye bein Crs. Rupp and .lacobson,
Those votinjZ No being, Cr. Becker and Mayor Krauss.
The vote tied 2-2. The motion should be voted upon at the next possible Commission meet
1)), the absent Commissioner Steve Kirchhoff, thus breakin the tie.
4. 31:55 [21 49 34] 5. Define the Purpose and .Intent of the Affirrdable Housing Task Force
( Fontenot)
4 32:33 121.50:15] Commissioner Jacobson
4 32.44 121:52:42] Mayor Krauss
4 33-36 [ I Commissioner Jacobson
4.35-20 [ ] Public Comment
Mayor Krauss called for public comment.
4 35 41 [21:54:39] Public Comment - Chris Budeski
Chris Budeski resides at 315 Sheridan Avenue and does not support new language defining
the purpose and intent of the Affordable Housing Taskforc.e.
No Text
• 4:36:35 [ ] Commissioner- Rupp
4:36:39 [ ] Mayor Krauss
4:37:27 [ ] C'olllrlllssloiler .l�lcohsoll
4:38:26 121:55:31 ] Public. Comment - Mike Jarrett
Mike Jarrett resides at 845 'Vest Arnold and does not support new language defining the
purpose and intent of the Affordable housing Taskforce.
4:39:03 [21:56: 19] Mayor Krauss
4:40:36 [21-.56:59] Commissioner Rupp
4:41:18 [21:57:28] Coillrrllssloner .I,,lcobsoll
4:42:01 22:02:01 ] Mayor Krauss
4:42:45 ( J Commissioner Becker
4:4.5:37 [22:03:07] Commissioner.lacobson
4:46:34 [ I Commissioner Rupp
4:47:14 [22:03:121 .Motion - Commissioner Jacobson
it was moved by Cr. Jacobson seconded by Cr. Becker, to accept the clarified purpose and
intent of the Affordable Housin Taskforce as outlined in the Commission memorandum Jof
Au ust 21 20061 to be included with the introductory letter to the Affordable Housin Task
Force.
4:48:04 [22:03:57] Mayor Krauss
4:49:32 122:05:47] Vote
It Nvas moved by Cr. Jacobson, seconded by Cr. Becker, to accent the clarified nu -nose and
intent of the Affordable 11ousin = Taskforce as outlined in the Commission memorandum jof
Aup,ust 21, 20061 to be included with the introductory letter to the Affordable HousinLy Task
Force.
Those voting Aye being, Crs. Jacobson Becker and Rupp.
Those votinp, No bein r Mayor Krauss.
The motion carried.
4:49:44 122-108:32] J. Noll -Action Items
4:49:46122:12:47] 1. FYI
4:50:00 122:15:56] FYI - Rick .Ilixson
Lombardi poplars (Durston Road) can not be saved.
4:52:41 [22:18:251 FYI - Brit Fontenot
Reminder that the first meeting in September will 1"all on a Tuesday.
• 4:53:24 [22:20:07] F YI - Roll Brc
Y
No Text
•
.7
Commission Memorandum
REPORT YO: Honorable Mayor and City Commission
FROM: Brit Fontenot, City Clerk
Chris Kukulski, City Manager
SUBJECT: Define the Purpose arad Intent of the Affordable Housing 'Task l'orcc.
MEETING: DATE: August 21, 2006
BACKGROUND:
The purpose of the task force is to review, analyze, and suggest improvements and
alternatives to the Inclusionary Housing draft ordinance as modified by the Bozeman City
Commission on July 31, 2006
The draft Inclusionary Housing ordinance has one over -arching goal, which has been
r'citer'ated numerous times by a majority of the commission: the steady production of affordable,
for -sale housing in proportion to annual market -rate Dousing production. The draft language
calls for 10% of all new housing constructed to be set aside for purchase by first-time buyers
earning between 80% - 120% of the area median income -
This goal is clearly stated in the Inclusionary I lousing draft and establishes the
benchmark by which the Bozeman (.;ity Commission will evaluate alternatives to the draft
ordinance that might be recommended by the task force. In short, any alternative
recommendation must rnec't or exceed the affordable housing production goals, estimated to be
85 units annually, while adhering to the targeted first-time home -buying population and all other
statements of applicability contained in the draft language.
LZJt;COMMENDATION: Motion and Vote to approve, deny or conditionally approve the above
stated purpose and intent of the Affordable Housing Task Force -
FISCAL EFFECTS: None
A.i..TERNA14NI ;S: As suggested by the City Commission.
•
•
�J
0 Respectfully submitted,
Brit Fontenot, City Clerk Chris A. Kukulski, City Manager
Attachments: done
•
•
No Text
•
•
I-]
•
E
� 1
5
0 There was no public comment on this item.
0:32:18 [18:26:02] Motion and Vote
It was moved by Cr. Ruin. seconded by Cr. Kirchhoff to adopt
Resolution No. 3930 which includes a 10% increase in wastewater rates
to be reserved for capital improvements related to the facility plan as
well as implementation of the lift station charges and written shut-off
notice charge.
Those voting Ave being Crs. Rupp, Kirchhoff, Jacobson, Becker and
Major Krauss.
Those voting No being none.
The motion carried.
0:32:50 118:26:46] 3. Workforce Housing, #7-06152
0:33:20 [ 18:27:02] Staff Report
Assistant Planning Director Chris Saunders presented the staff report.
0:40:14 [18:33:531 Public Comment - Les Scheidt
Les Scheidt resides at 706 Hunters Way and opposes the "Affordable
Ordinance".
0:43:16 [ 18:37:17] Public Comment - Roger Koopman
Roger Koopman resides at. 911 South Tracy Avenue and opposes the
Workforce Housing Ordinance.
0:48:43 [18:42:451 Public Comment - Denise Rogers
Denise Rogers resides at 6 West Babcock, Apt. 101 and supports the
Workforce Housing Ordinance.
0:54:21 f 18:48:351 .Public Comment - Linda Pierce
Linda Pierce resides at 48 Hitching Post Road (non-resident) and supports
affordable housing in Bozeman.
0:56:56 [18:51:07] Public Comment - Wallis Bryan
Wallis Bryan resides at 2226 Powder Park Court and opposes the Workforce
Housing Ordinance as written.
0:59:56 [ 18:54:181 Public Comment - Jeanie Etgen
Jeanie Etgen resides at 410 North 4th Street and supports the Workforce
Housing Ordinance.
1:01:36 [18:56:081 Public Comment - Roxanne Klingensmith
•
11
•
6
Roxanne Klingensmith resides at 1717 S. Black No. 53 and supports the
Workforce Housing Ordinance.
1:03:16 [18:57:43] Public Comment - Linda Harper
Linda Harper resides at 733 North Aster and support~ tile Workforce
Housing Ordinance.
1:06:21 [19:01:00] Public Comment - pal. Dabney
Dab Dabney resides at. 522 South 6th Street and opposes the Workforce
Housing Ordinance as written.
1:09:34 [19:04,131 Public Comment - Georgette Cassen
Georgette C'assen resides at 213 West Story Street and supports the
Workforce Housing Ordinance.
1:10:22 1.19:05:031 Public Comment - Alanna Brown
Alanna Brown resides at 601 South 9th Street and supports the Workforce
Housing Ordinance.
1:13:31 [19:08--16] Public Comment - Diana Anthony
Diana Anthony resides at 816 N. 17th Street and her dream is sustainable
development for her mobile home park and supports affordable housing.
1:16:02 [ 19:10:48] Public Comment - Beth Hansen
Beth Hansen resides at 1813 South Rouse Apt. i3, and opposes the
Workforce Housing Ordinance as written.
1:17:11 [ 19:11:5.5] Public Comment - Kate Reid (for habitat for Humanity)
Kate Reid is a non-resident and opposes the Workforce IIousing Ordinance
as written.
1:19:37 [ 19:14:241 Public Comment - Jim Evans
Jim Evans resides at 2862 North 27th, Apt. No. 2 believes hard work and
saving are important paths on the route to home ownership.
1:22:11 [19:17:00] Public Comment - Sandy Leal
Sandy Leal resides at 1]27 South Cedar View and opposes the Workforce,
Housing Ordinance as written.
1:24:05 [ 19:18:51 ] Public Comment - Chris Hanson
Chris Hansen resides at 617 N. 5th, Unit K, opposes the Workforce Housing
Ordinance as written.
1:27:20 [1.9:22:021 Public Comment - Bob Chase
Bob Chase resides at 433 South Black acknowledges problem of affordable
0
housing but opposes the Workforce Housing Ordinance as written.
0
.7
•
7
1:31:12 [19:26:16] Public: Comment - Verne Klinginsrnith
Verne Khriginsmith resides at 1717 South Black Street and supports the
Workforce I lousing Ordinance.
1:35:04 [19:29:26'1 Public Comment - Tina Rodriguez (for (-;VHK'I"11')
Tina Rodriguez resides at 118 South 15th No. 4 and supports the Workforce
Housing Ordinance.
1:36:09 [ 19:31:16] Public Comment - Adell Westrick
Adell Westrick resides at 2727 West Mendenhall and opposes the
Workforce Housing Ordinance.
1:39:31 [ 0:11:33] Comment - Mayor Krauss
1:40:32 [19:35:361 Public Comment - Dennis Hardin
Dennis Hardin resides at 6125 S. 1.9th Avenue (non-resident) and opposes
the Workforce Housing Ordinance as written.
1:44:22 [19:39:43] Public Comment - Debbie Jamieson
Debbie Jarnieson resides at 2605 Bear Canyon Road (non --resident) and
opposes the Workforce Housing Ordinance.
1:47:27 [19:42:55] Public Comment - Rob French
Rob :French resides at 217 West Koch and opposes the Workforce Housing
Ordinance as written.
1:5.1:17 [.19:46:36] .Public Comment - Jim Walseth
Jitn Walseth resides at 603 West Babcock and supports the Workforce
Housing Ordinance.
1:53:55 [ 19:49.29] Public Comment - Mary Pat Harris
Mary Pat Harris resides at 1311Wild1-lower Way (non-resident) and opposes
the Workforce Housing Ordinance as written.
1:57:34 [ 19, 53:081 Public Comment - Dane Gamble
Dane Gamble resides at 1313 Hitching Post Road (non-resident) and opposes
the Workforce Housing Ordinance as written.
2:00:27 [ 19:.56:121 Public Comment - Don Lint
Don lint resides at 406 Princeton Street and opposes the Workforce Housing
Ordinance as written.
2:03:04 [ 19:58:531 Public Comment - Frank Schledorn
Frank Schledorn resides at 1208 North 8th Ave. and opposes the Workforce
40 Housing Ordinance as written.
•
L
•
Ed
• 2:05:24 [20:01:14] Public Comment - Jeremy Shea
Jeremy Shea, President of SWMBIA, encourages the Commission to vote
NO on inclusionary zoning.
2:07:48 [20:03:41 ] Public Comment - Rene Goggler
Rene Goggler resides at 1418 North River Rock in Belgrade (non-resi(tent)
and would like to see the Task Force open to other suggestions and options
and opposes the Workforce Housing Ordinance as written.
2:10.46 120:00:361 Public Comment - Julie Linecker
Julie Linecker resides at 5969 Baxter Lane and opposes the Workforce
Housing Ordinance as written.
2:13:53 [20:09:56] Public Comment - Joyce Miller
Joyce Miller resides at 1002 Zacharia Lane (non-resident) and opposes the
Workforce Housing Ordinance as written.
2:16:58 [20:10.-001 Public Comment - Keri Lister
Ken Lister resides at 382 Peace Pipe Drive .and opposes the Workforce
Housing Ordinance.
2:21:59 [20:12:53] Public Comment - Karen Lindell
Karen Lindell resides at 416 East Aspen and opposes the Workforce
Housing Ordinance as written.
2.23:14 [20:18:03] Public Comment - Scott Jagger (Bozeman Chamber of Commerce)
Scott Jagger stated the Chamber supports workforce housing and affordable
housing but not inclusionary zoning.
2:26:08 [20:19:26) Public Comment - Voss Owen
Voss Owen resides at 4108 West Dickerson opposes the Workforce Housing
Ordinance as written.
2:28:11 [20:22:231 Public Comment - Scott Teal
Scott Teal (non-resident) supports the Workforce Mousing Ordinance.
2:34:13 [20:24:24] Public Comment - Jason Mann
Jason Mann resides at 6000 Walker Road (non-resident) and opposes the
Workforce Housing Ordinance as written.
2:37:38 [20:30:32] Public Comment - Chris Budeski
Chris Budeski resides at 315 Sheridan Ave. and opposes the Workforce
Housing Ordinance as written.
2:41:02 [20:33:40] Public Comment - Jennifer Wilson
No Text
9
Jennifer Wilson resides at 4630 Clear View Road (non-resident) and apposes
the Workforce Housing Ordinance as written.
2:44:08 [20:37:34] Public Comment - Karen Thames
Karen Thomcs resides at 1010 East Gallatin (none -resident) and opposes the
Workforce Housing Ordinance as written.
2:46:45 [20:40:39] Public Comment - Tracy Poole
Tracy Poole resides at 250 Hyalite View Drive (non-resident) and opposes
the Workforce Housing Ordinance as written.
2:50,54 [20:43:281 Public Comment - Tom Eaglehoff
Tom Eaglehoff resides at 305 South 16th and opposes the Workforce.
Housing Ordinance as written.
2:54:06 [20:47:32] Public Comment - Andrew Huriburt
Andrew llurlburt resides at 909 West Olive and opposes the Workforce
llousing Ordinance as written.
2:55:05 [20:50:56] Public Comment - Anders Lewendal
Anders Lewendal resides at 4020 Gran Street and opposes the Workforce
Housing Ordinance as written.
2:58:50 [20:51:54] Public Comment Mary Boustead
Mary Boustead resides at 4239 East Baseline Road (non-resident.) and
opposes the Workforce Housing Ordinance as written.
3:01:45 (20:55:40] Public Comment - Tim Turner
J'im Turner resides at 814 South Willson and opposes the Workforce
Housing Ordinance as written.
3:03:14 [20-58:39] Public Comment - Kelly Wood
Kelly Wood resides at 918 Woodland Drive and opposes the Workforce
Housing Ordinance as written.
3:07:12 [21:00:291 Break
Mayor Krauss called for a 15 minute break.
3:29:30 [ ] Call to Order
Mayor Krauss called the meeting to order.
3:29:58 (21:04:10] Public Comment - Lucille Pope
Lucille Pope (non- resident) requested a broad representation of workforce
wage earners on the Task Force.
3:30:20 [21:25:59] Public Comment - Joan Rudberg
No Text
10
.loan Rudberg resides at 2517 Valhalla Court and opposes the Workforce
Housing Ordinance as written.
3:33:45 121:28:07] Public Comment - Mary ,Jacobs
Mary Jacobs (non-resident) suggest broadening the vision of the Task Force,
hiring an arbitrator and considering all perspectives.
3:39: 19 121:31:19] Public Comment - Paul Rugheimer
Paul Rugheimer resides at 506 Oxford Drive opposes the Workforce
Housing Ordinance as written.
3:43:33 [21:37:05] Public Comment. - Frank Eekes
Frank Eckes resides at 2201 Maplewood Street and opposes the Workforce
Housing Ordinance as written.
3:45:01 [21:41:181 Public Comment - Mike Jarrett
Mike Jarrett resides at 845 West Arnold and opposes the. Workforce housing
Ordinance as written and considers housing costs are high due to fees, taxes
and regulations imposed by the City government.
.3:47:32 [21:42:521 Public Comment - Jennifer Owens
Jennifer Owens, no address given, has volunteered for the Task Force but
. does not think inclusionary zoning will work.
3:48:30 (21:45.30) Public Comment - Gary .Perry
Gary ferry, Manhattan, Montana State Legislator, opposes the Workforce
Housing Ordinance as written.
3:52:27 [21:46:22] Discussion - Commissioner Kirchhoff
Commissioner Kirchhoff commented on the Workforce Housing Ordinance
and public testimony.
4:00:36 [21:51:02] Discussion - Commissioner Jacobson
Kaaren Jacobson commented on the Workforce Housing Ordinance and
public testimony.
4:11:53 [21:58:45] Discussion - Commissioner Becker
Commissioner Becker commented on the Workforce Housing Ordinance and
public testimony.
4:23:00 [22-09:56] Discussion - Commissioner Rupp
Commissioner Rupp commented on the Workforce Housing Ordinance and
public testimony.
4:30:51 [22:17:29] Discussion - Mayor Krauss
r
LJ
No Text
• Mayor Krauss commented on the Workforce Housing Ordinance and public
testimony.
4:41:35 [22:21:35] Discussion - Commissioner Rupp
Commissioner Rupp responded to Mayor Krauss' comments.
4:42:32 [22:29:38] Discussion - Mayor Krauss
Mayor Krauss responded to Commissioner Rupp's Comments.
4:44:11 [22:40:42] Discussion - Co.mmissioner Kirchhoff
Commissioner Kirchhoff responded to questions by Commissioner Rupp.
4:46:28 [22:42:01 ] Discussion - Commissioner Jacobson
Commissioner Jacobson responded to Commissioner Rupp.
4:46:54 1 0:14:551 Discussion - Mayor Krauss
4:49:09 [22:43:06] Discussion - Commissioner Kirchhoff
Responds to the Commission concerning the Task Force.
4:49:51 [22:45:37] Discussion - Commissioner Jacobson
Commissioner Jacobson suggests altering the Task Force guidelines.
4:50:04 [22:46:04] Discussion - Conunissioner Rupp
Commissioner Rupp agreed with Cr. Jacobson with addition of review of the
ordinance, and recommended the Task Force bring forth other options but
insisted on a firm titmeline.
4:50:24 [23:59:57] Discussion - Commissioner Kirchhoff
Suggested whiting on giving direction to staff on unresolved issues.
4:51:02 [22.47:10] Discussion - Commissioner Becker
Commissioner Becker suggested the Task Force include other options in its
report.
4:51:52 [22:48:231 Discussion - Mayor Krauss
Mayor Krauss suggested language for a motion.
4:52:22 [22:49:05] Discussion - Commissioner Rupp
Commissioner Rupp suggests providing the Task Force with the ordinance
and remaining questions.
4:53:03 [22:49:20] Discussion - Mayor Krauss
4:53:17 [ 0:33:011 Discussion - Commissioner Kirchhoff
0
No Text
1.2
. 4:53:52 [ 0:06:251 Discussion - Commissioner Rupp
4:54:10 122:49:451 Discussion - Comrnissioner Becker
4:54:54 [22:50:15] Discussion - Commissioner Kirchhoff
4:55:44 122:51:10] Discussion - Commissioner Jacobson
4:55:51 1 ] Discussion - Commissioner Jacobson proposed language for a motion.
The goal of the 'Task Force is to make recommendations to develop an
adequate supply of affordable housing. The Task Force will review, analyze
and suggest improvements to the Inclusionary Housing Ordinance as
recommended by the City Commission following the public hearing=., on the
proposed ordinance on August 7, 2006 and examine any other alternatives
that will increase the supply of housing with special attention given to
Section C, individualized program.
4:56:52 [ ] Discussion - Commissioner Kirchhoff
4:57:05 [ J Discussion - Commissioners Rupp, Jacobson and Kirchhoff
4:58:41 [ ] Discussion - Commissioner Jacobson restated the proposed language for a motion
The goal of the 'Task Force is to make recommendations to develop an
adequate supply of affordable housing. The Task Force will review, analyze
and suggest improvements, as needed, to the Inclusionary housing
Ordinance as recommended by the City Commission following the public
hearing on the proposed ordinance on August 7, 2006 and examine any other
alternatives that will increase the supply of affordable housing with attention
should be given to Section 3, individualized program.
5:00:24 [ 0:33:121 Discussion - Commissioners Becker and Jacobson
5:01:53 [ ] Discussion - Commissioners Rupp, Jacobson, Becker and Kirchhoff
5:04:16 [ ] Motion -by Commissioner Jacobson and Second by Commissioner Becker
It was moved by Cr. Jacobson, seconded by Cr. Becker, to define the
goal of the Task Force is to make recommendations to develop an
adequate supply of affordable housing,and examine an other
alternatives that will increase the suoply of affordable housin .
Attention should he given to Section 3 individualized pro ram.
5:05:29 [ ] Diticussion - Commissioner Jacobson restated the proposed language for a motion:
The goal of the Task Force is to make recommendations to develop an
adequate supply of affordable housing. The Task Force will review, analyze
and suggest improvements, as needed, to the Inclusionary Housing
Ordinance as recommended by the City Commission following the public
El
C�
13
hearing on the proposed ordinance on A►.►gust 7, 2006. The Task Force will
also examine any other alternatives that will increase the supply of
affordable housing as decined necessary, Special attention should be given
to Section 3, individualized program_
c _p p seconded by Commissioner
5:07:5) Commissioner ire ho ro posed a motion 5
Rupp
Commissioner Kirchhoff stated that the -eight -week task of the Work
Force � ..._ _....
e Housing Task Force is to:
Review and analyze the Work Force Housing Ordinance; and
2) Suggest any alternatives that demonstrably meet_o_r exceed the Work
Force Housing supply objectives in the ordinance.
5:09:46 [ ] Comnussioner .Kirchhoff restated his proposed motion
Commissioner Kirchhoff stated that the eight -week task ol- the Work Force
llousing 'rask Force is:
1) Review and analyze the draft Work Force Housing Ordinance provided at
the August 7, 2006 City Commission meeting; and
• 2) Suggest any alternatives that demonstrably meet or exceed the Work
Force housing supply objectives in the ordinance.
5:09:15 [ ] Discussion - Mayor Krauss
5:09:39 [ ] Discussion - Commissioner Jacobson
10.05 [ 0:01:21] Discussion - Re -reading of Commissioner Jacobson's motion by the City Clerk
it was moved by Cr. Jacobson, seconded by Cr. Becker, to define the goal of
the Task. Force to make recommendations to develop an adequate supply of
affordable housing. The Task Force will examine any other alternatives that
will increase the supply of affordable housing. Special attention should be
given to Section 3, individualized program.
5:10:35 [ ] Discussion - Commissioner Becker rc-affirming his second on Commissioner
Jacobson's original motion
5:1.1:18 [ ] Discussion - Re -reading of Commissioner Jacobson's motion by the City Clerk.
It was moved by Cr. Jacobson, seconded by Cr. Becker, to define the goal of
the Task Force is to make recommendations to develop an adequate supply
of affordable housing. The Task Force will also examine any other
0
No Text