HomeMy WebLinkAbout19- City Grant #2019-10 - 2020 DNRC Program Development (Forestry) BOZEMAN MT
City of Bozeman Grant Routing Cover Sheet
This form is used in conjunction with Administrative Order 2014-01, adopting the Grant Application and Reception
Policy. When a Department Director signs grant documents under this provision, they are certifying that they
understand and will carry out the provisions of the grant and its impact on city operations and finances. All the
required boxes must be initialed by the appropriate departments. Use a separate routing sheet for each phase of the
grant process. Utilize assigned grant number for each phase for tracking purposes.
Grant Document Title: .ZU2L) bN�C f P4)6#-AA DU. Grant#(issued by City Clerk):
CFDA#(applies to Federal grants) Grant Total: Grant Match: `I 32 ).5
Department: PF�P t� REC � I�y7 Grant Project Manager: M-- N -WLkST
Phase of Process: Notice of Intent Application Award/Contract
Date Document Signed:
For all grants under$20,000 in Department Finance Office City Manager Original Signed
value. Director Grant Documents
to City Clerk
Does not require approval on
Commission meeting agenda
PLETED-
For all grants over$20,000 in Department Finance Office City Manager Original Signed
value. Director Grant Documents
*Department Director initials to City Clerk
verify notification to City
Commission and City Manager
within 30 days of grant
application.
REQUIRES City Commission
Approval
DATE of COMMISSION
MEETING:
Presented by:
Consent Action
Revised 10/27/2014
Montana Department of Natural Resources and Conservation (DNRC)
2020 Urban Forestry Grant Application Cover Sheet
Use this page as the cover sheet and include separate pages for the Project Proposal. Please use the Budget Calculation sheets provided. This
document must be signed and dated by an individual who is legally authorized to act on the applicant's behalf. Please answer clearly and concisely
and include all required attachments.
APPLICANT NAME(i.e. City of Lumberton) DUNS NUMBER FEDERAL TAX ID NUMBER
City of Bozeman 083705293 81-6001238
APPLICANT ADDRESS CITY/TOWN STATE ZIP
PO Box 1230 Bozeman MT 59771
PRINCIPAL REPRESENTATIVE(person DNRC will use as primary contact) TITLE
Alex Nordquest City Forester
PRINCIPAL REP ADDRESS(if same as above, leave blank) CITY/TOWN STATE ZIP
PHONE(DAYTIME) FAX EMAIL
(406)582-3225 anordquest@bozeman.net
OTHER IMPORTANT CONTACTS:Provide name, title, and contact information(phone, email)
Jennifer Jolliff, Program Arborist (406)582-3226 jjolliff@bozeman.net
TOTAL REQUEST AMOUNT(maximum request$10,000) ARE YOU A CURRENT TREE CITY USA?(YIN) Y
$4,500.00 INDICATE IF INDIRECT COSTS ARE INCLUDED OR WAIVED:
Waived
PROJECT TITLE: Lott O'Trees
One-two sentences that best describes your proposal:
Lott O' Trees would continue our trials on experimental species for boulevard planting. We are looking
to expand the diversity of available species in preparation for Emerald Ash Borer.
PROJECT PROPOSAL
All the following elements must be addressed in application,in the order given. Limit responses to 400 words per section.
1. FEDERAL&STATE PROGRAM GOALS(4 pts):Specify how the project meets the federal and state program goals.
2. PROJECT SUMMARY(4 pts): Describe the type of project and clearly outline its purpose and goals.
3. 2020 RESILIENCE THEME(4 pts):How are you focusing on resilience? Does the project draw from existing resources(i.e.
inventory or management plan)? If so,directly tie these resources to the project.Supporting documentation (pictures and
maps) is encouraged.
4. PROJECT PERSONNEL(3 pts): Personnel should possess the necessary qualifications or expertise to carry out the project and
meet program goals. Please include each person's name,title/qualification, project role, and level of involvement.
5. LEVERAGING LOCAL SUPPORT&OUTREACH(3 pts): Please include any planned activities with partners or volunteers, as
well as any public education related to this project. Identify any other agencies or groups that will be involved.
6. PROJECT WORK PLAN AND SCHEDULE(4 pts): Provide a work plan/schedule for completing each activity and timetable for
completion with start and finish dates.Assume that tree planting and maintenance projects have a deadline of June 15,
2020;other projects must be completed by September 30, 2020.
7. PROJECT MONITORING&EFFECTIVENESS(4 pts):Describe how you will measure your project's success and
accomplishments. Describe whether you will make updates to your inventory, if applicable. Note that tree planting and
maintenance projects require a 3-year establishment plan. (See the example at UCF webpage).
I certify that the community/organization listed above has the approval of the local government to conduct this project.
APPLICANT PRINCIPAL REPRESENTATIVE: Name, Signature — Nd ( �
AUTHORIZED APPLICANT OFFICIAL: Name, Title, Signature ► -I�iDv�r �j l
I
PROJECT PROPOSAL
TreesLott 0?
1. Federal&State Program Goals:
• Advancing inventory and assessment information:
The City of Bozeman's current tree inventory reflects a lack of species diversity.Approximately 33%of our
boulevard trees are ash (Froxinus spp.)species, creating many management concerns. With the looming threat of
Emerald Ash Borer,some neighborhoods may suffer the loss of all of their boulevard trees. Maples(Acerspp.) are
also heavily-represented at 17%, similar to other Montana communities. According to this assessment, it would
be in our best interest to maximize alternative species for future plantings by expanding our selection.
• Encouraging healthy and resilient urban landscapes that are adaptive to climate change:
Many of the trees approved for boulevard planting in Bozeman are over-used, and are poorly adapted to drought
conditions and degraded urban soils. In order to achieve a healthier and more resilient urban forest, species
selection must be increased to ensure diversity and successful establishment despite our harsh climatic
conditions and the effects of urbanization.
• Increasing public education of urban forest benefits,and forest health and pest challenges:
Bozeman city residents have been excited to participate in past year's Lott 0'Tree drawings.They support efforts
to maintain and expand our forest and appreciate beautiful parks and tree-lined boulevards.The proposed Lott
0'Trees project would continue exploration of tree species that have not been previously tried in the Bozeman
area, expanding the current selection to provide more diversity, and therefore, a more healthy and resilient
resource.
• Strengthening partnerships with underserved groups:
Introducing new tree species to the existing selection would encourage local nurseries and tree farms to stock a
supply for the public to plant in private landscapes, boosting retail sales by offering something out of the
ordinary.
The proposed project would apply to underserved and underrepresented groups by making the new trees
available to anyone with an interest and suitable planting site.There would be no cost or physical requirement,
with the exception of supplemental watering.The project would be described on the City of Bozeman's Forestry
web page, and interpretive signage would accompany each planting to educate curious pedestrians about our
urban forest and the need to diversify for health, resiliency, and continued benefits.
2. Project Summary:
In 2019, we continued our Lott 0'Trees program through Program Development funds.The program was again
well-received with Forestry staff, residents and City Commissioners. Demand was slightly less this time,with just
over 100 applicants for the lottery drawing. With a 2nd year of planting,we've doubled our sample size and aim to
continue the Lott' 0 Tree program for a third year.The grant award would be used to purchase more
experimental tree species and to evaluate their suitability.Trees would again be offered to residents through a
lottery,with Forestry Division staff evaluating planting sites.There would be no cost to residents except for
watering.Those not selected in the lottery would be directed to our annual Costshare program. Continued
maintenance and monitoring would be conducted by Forestry Division staff.
The following five species have been selected for the Lott 0'Trees project and are currently available for
purchase:
• Kentucky coffeetree (Gymnocladus dioicus)—Zones 3-8
Large shade tree, Ash replacement
• Turkish filbert(Corylus colurna)—Zones 4-7
Excurrent growth form, similar to Linden or Alder
Food source for wildlife ARL
���KvoY
• Heritage oak (Quercus robur x macrocarpa)—Zones 4-7
Oak hybrid, tolerates urban conditions Q Q
Food source for wildlife
• Kentucky Yellowwood (Cladrastis kentukea)—Zones 4-8 O
Small to medium sized tree, ideal for under utility ♦+
lines .NN O O _O
White flowers in spring ��
• Hop hornbeam (Ostrya virginiana)—Zones 3-9
Small to medium sized tree, ideal for under utility lines
Figure 1. Lottery contestant winning tree
Flowers resembling hops
3. 2020 Resilience Theme:
Lott 0'Trees is based on our urgent need to renew boulevards with diversity. Using our City-Wide Tree Inventory,
we know that Ash (Fraxinus spp.) compose roughly one-third of our overall tree population. With such heavy
reliance on Ash, Bozeman would be quite vulnerable to the arrival or Emerald Ash Borer.Trialing new species
gives us greater diversity in the urban forest, increasing our resiliency against pests and diseases.
Existing Products:
• Urban Forest Management Plan
• Emerald Ash Borer Course of Action Plan
• City-Wide Tree Inventory
According to the Urban Forest Management Plan, "The major weakness in Bozeman's urban forest is its lack of
species diversity."With low species diversification, the tree population is vulnerable to insect and disease
problems, which is a valid concern with Bozeman's high percentage of ash trees and the possibility of Emerald Ash
Borer infestation in the near future. The Urban Forest Management Plan, together with the Emerald Ash Borer
Course of Action Plan, recommend a "10-20-30" guideline for species diversification, where there would be no
more than 30%of any family, 20%of any genus, and 10%of any species represented in the total tree population.
The Urban Forest Management Plan also states that "The city's cost-share and voucher programs have been
popular, and these are an easy avenue for educating people. These programs can be expanded to plant more trees
and should focus on trying a wider variety of species."
�
ASH TREE DISTRIBUTION
�
"
'
FigumeI Bozeman has over 8,000 Ash trees, with mature trees in the historic core and younger trees throughout the city.
The Emerald Ash Borer Course of Action Plan emphasizes the immediate necessity of incorporating a more
extensive selection of trees into the existing population. "..jocushngmn creating o healthy, sustainable urbonfonest l
ahead ofE48/n Bozeman should beoprinr/tK" By replacing ash trees with a more diverse selection and byplanting
new trees selected from a broader spectrum will begin to transform and improve our urban forest to a more
healthy and resilient condition. "Progress can be made to achieve the goal of having no more than 20%of any one
genus."
4. Project Personnel:
Last year's project ran smoothly with just our full-time staff before the arrival of seasonal workers. Following the
drawing, our crews were able to quickly assign workers to planting sites and finish installations in a matter of days.
We would continue the same strategy with our 5 full-time Certified Arborists.
* Alex Nordquest, City Forester: Project leader, project implementation and design, supervisor, public
correspondence and education, web site design, monitoring
w Jennifer]o||iff, Program Arborist: Assists in project implementation and design, public correspondence and
education, site inspections, application processing, ordering trees and supplies, maintenance, monitoring
~ Vince Ga||i, Foreman, Program Arborist: Supervision of planting crews, equipment operator, public
correspondence and education, maintenance, monitoring
• Amy Hansen, Program Arboriot: Public correspondence and education, maintenance, monitoring
• Wynn Krauss, Program Arborist: Assists in supervision nf planting crews, equipment operator, public
correspondence and education, maintenance, monitoring
5. Leveraginq Local Support& Outreach:
Continuing the Lott O'Trees program gives us a direct link to Bozeman residents.The chance of winning a free
boulevard tree generated heavy interest, with many residents unaware of the Forestry Division's existence.A third
year of lottery drawing creates another chance to engage new residents, explaining their role in Bozeman's urban
forest and detailing other Forestry Division services.
The interpretive signage on each tree was a great tool for the general public. In addition, our web page provided an
interactive map showing the location for each Lott 0'Tree. We would continue these powerful visual aids with the
2020 grant.
6. Project Work Plan and Schedule:
March April May June
5 - Order trees 2 - Post lottery on web 7—Pick up trees (Billings) 4— Begin monthly
page monitoring
2—30 Site inspections 8-31 Planting
2—30 Selection of
"winners" according to
site/species
7. Project Monitoring and Effectiveness:
In order to gauge the effectiveness of this project, we would monitor each tree planted. In the past two years, each
Lott 0'Tree has been added to our tree inventory. Data points are updated by measuring new growth, trunk
diameter, and overall tree vigor. We would continue this with a 3rd year of Lott 0' Trees, monitoring successful
specimens for consideration in our approved boulevard species list.
Monitoring Tree and Site Conditions: Below is an example of a tracking sheet that could be utilized to monitor
tree establishment and any changes to the site.
DATE ADDRESS SPECIES SITE CONDITIONS TREE CONDITION DIA. GROWTH
9-7-2020 514 W. Koch KCT Irrigated boulevard, Good 2.5" 1.5"
exposure to s/w winds
LOTT O' TREE PROJECT— LONG TERM MAINTENANCE AND MONITORING PLAN
YEAR 1-2020
GOAL: PROVIDE PUBLIC EDUCATION, MONITORING,AND STRUCTURAL PRUNING
ACTIVITY SERVICE/FREQUENCY MATERIALS J F M A M J J A S O N D
Structural 20 hrs. @$ Pickup truck X X X X
pruning
Public Provide tree care X X X X X X X
Education information to interested
citizens
Monitor Assessment done while Pickup truck X X X X
pruning/watering
YEAR 2-2021
GOAL: PROVIDE PUBLIC EDUCATION,STRUCTURAL PRUNING,AND REMOVAL OF SUPPORT STAKES
ACTIVITY SERVICE/FREQUENCY MATERIALS J F M A M J J A S 0 N D
Structural 20 hrs. @$ Pickup truck X X X X
pruning
Remove 20 hrs. @ Pickup truck X X
stakes
Public Provide tree care X X X X X X X X X X X X
Education information to interested
citizens
Monitor Assessment done while Pickup truck FTI X X X X X
pruning
YEAR 3-2022
GOAL: PROVIDE PUBLIC EDUCATION,STRUCTURAL PRUNING,AND SELECTION OF SUITABLE SPECIES
ACTIVITY SERVICE/FREQUENCY MATERIALS 1 F M A M J 1 A S O N D'-
Structural 20 hrs. @$ X X X X
pruning
Public Provide tree care X X X X X X X X X X X X
Education information to interested
citizen
Re-mulch 20 hrs. @$ X X
Monitor Assessment done while X X X X X
pruning
BUDGET CALCULATION FORM(4 pts)
$VALUE OF
PROJECT EXPENSES QUANTITY/HOURLY RATE GRANT FUNDS CASH MATCH IN-KIND TOTAL
REQUESTED(A) (B) MATCH A+B+C
(C)
PERSONNEL EXPENSES(SALARIES/WAGES/BENEFITS)
Requested grant funds cannot be used for regular personnel costs of city/town employees. However, the cost of forestry student
interns or seasonal employees can be included as grant funds.
City Forester 40 hrs @$30.21 per hour $1,208.40 $1,208.40
Full-time arborist 1 30 hrs @$26.27 per hour $788.10 $788.10
Full-time arborist 2 48 hrs @$24.07 per hour $1,155.36 $1,155.36
Full-time arborist 3 24 hrs @$23.72 per hour $569.28 $569.28
Full-time arborist 4 44 hrs @$16.68 $733.92 $733.92
TOTAL PERSONNEL EXPENSES $0.00 $4,455.06 $0.00 $4,455.06
OPERATING EXPENDITURES(TRAVEL,SUPPLIES,RENTALS,ETC.)
Kentucky coffeetree 5 @$176.00 $880.00 $880.00
Heritage oak 5 @$144.00 $720.00 $720.00
Yellowwood 5 @$176.00 $880.00 $880.00
Hop hornbeam 5 @$144.00 $720.00 $720.00
Turkish filbert 5 @ 160.00 $800.00 $800.00
Travel to Billings-pick up trees
with 1 ton truck and trailer 4 hrs @$25.95 per hour $103.80 $103.80
Fuel to Billings and return 142 miles @ 13mpg $56.32
$2.56 per gallon $56.32
Tree Planting-1 ton truck and
trailer 36 hrs. @$25.95 per hour $934.20 $934.20
Interpretive signage-6"x 8" 25 @$20.00 each $500.00 $500.00
Pickup trucks 144 hrs. @$12.30 per hour $1,771.20 $1,771.20
TOTAL OPERATING EXPENSES $4,500.00 $2,865.52 $0.00 $7,365.52
CONTRACTED PROFESSIONAL SERVICES
TOTAL CONTRACTED SERVICES $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
w,
TOTAL PROJECT EXPENDITURES $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
INDIRECT COSTS* $0.00
TOTAL PROJECT FUNDING $4,500.00 $7,320.58 $0.00 $11,820.58
IMPORTANT NOTES:
ALL MATCH EXPENDITURES(BOTH CASH AND IN-KIND CONTRIBUTIONS)MUST BE
SUBSTANTIATED WITH DOCUMENTATION TO BE APPLIED TO THE 100%MATCH REQUIREMENT.
FEDERAL FUNDS MAY NOT BE USED AS MATCH(NO FEDERAL CASH, DONATED AND/OR IN-KIND CONTRIBUTIONS).
*The indirect cost rate can be a NICRA,a negotiated indirect cost rate agreement recognized by a federal agency;many local governments
and organizations have one.Applicants without a negotiated rate are eligible to use the de minimis indirect rate of up to 10%.Note that
you may choose to waive indirect costs.