HomeMy WebLinkAbout11-01-19 Public Comment - K. and J. King - HRDC Warming Center SiteFrom:Jennifer King
To:Sarah Rosenberg; Agenda
Cc:Klett King
Subject:HRDC Proposed Warming Center Site
Date:Friday, November 01, 2019 10:51:32 AM
Attachments:Homeless_Stats_Fact_Sheet-1.pdf
Dear Bozeman Leaders,
We would like to voice our concerns with the request with HRCD and the special permit request for
our neighboring home at 3025 Westridge Drive. The special permit would allow this home to serve
as a warming center for the homeless for up to 36 people per night, from November to March.
While we fully recognize, appreciate, and support the need for such a facility, the proposed location
is unquestionably not the right fit. This home is 287 FEET from an elementary school playground.
This is a high traffic area that hundreds of schoolchildren pass daily on their way to and from
Morning Star Elementary and Sacajawea Middle School daily, including our eleven-year-old son.
While we wholly understand and appreciate that people requiring the services or a warming centerare in need, we cannot overlook fact that, according to the U.S. Conference of Mayors, mental illnessand substance abuse are two of the top five causes for homelessness (source: National Law Centeron Homelessness and Poverty, attached for reference). HRDC states that they will house up to 36people per night and they will not perform background checks on the occupants. The non-evaluatedoccupants, who statistically have a high probability of being mentally ill and/or substance abusers,can leave the facility at any time. The risk that this poses to our young children is unacceptable tothe hard working, voting, and tax paying residents of the surrounding neighborhoods.
Please deny the request for HRDC’s Special Use Permit for the proposed location at 3025 Westridge
Drive.
Thank you,
Klett and Jennifer King
515 W Arnold St
406-581-9379
2000 M Street, N.W., Suite 210, Washington, DC 20036 │ www.nlchp.org │ PHONE: 202.638.2535 │ FAX: 202.638.2737
NATIONAL LAW CENTER
ON HOMELESSNESS & POVERTY
Homelessness in America: Overview of Data and Causes
The National Law Center on Homelessness & Poverty currently estimates that each year at least 2.5 to 3.5
million Americans sleep in shelters, transitional housing, and public places not meant for human
habitation. At least an additional 7.4 million have lost their own homes and are doubled-up with others
due to economic necessity.
But data related to homelessness are far from exact. Part of the difficulty is that there are different
definitions of homelessness now in use. For example, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban
development (HUD) uses a narrow definition largely limited to people living in shelters, in transitional
housing and in public places.1 The U.S. Department of Education (DoE) uses a broader definition that
includes families who are doubled-up with others due to economic necessity. Another difficulty concerns
methodology. HUD reports annual “Point-in-Time” counts of the “unsheltered” homeless population;
however, the methodology used to collect those numbers varies by community and is often deeply
flawed.2 HUD also reports annual counts of the sheltered population; this number varies with shelter
capacity, which depends on variables such as available funding. 3
The numbers and percentages below derive from different sources; many are from the HUD counts and
thus must be viewed with caution. Others are based on DoE data, and reflect the more expansive
definition; these also are likely undercounts since not all homeless children are counted. The numbers thus
may not be consistent.
Overall population
Before the 2008 recession, an estimated 2.5 to 3 million men, women, and children were
experiencing homelessness each year (using the HUD definition), including a total of 1.35 million
children, and over a million people working full or part-time but unable to pay for housing.4 Since
then, indications are that the crisis has deepened:
o The number of people who have lost their homes and are living doubled-up with family or
friends due to economic necessity remained at 7.4 million people in 2012 (the last year for
which data is available), consistent with 2011, but some states saw as much as an 80%
increase.5
o Over 1.2 million school children were homeless (using the DoE definition) during the
2012-2013 school year, an 8% increase over the previous school year.6 Almost 2.5 million
children overall were homeless in 2013, an 8% increase over 2012.7
o A 2014 survey in the Law Center’s report, Welcome Home: The Rise of Tent Cities in the
United States, showed media reports of tent cities in 46 states across the country.8
o According to a June 2014 report by the Joint Center for Housing Studies at Harvard
University, there is now a crisis in affordable rental housing.9 In 2012, more than one out
of every four renters (27%) paid over 50% of their income in rent.10 The number of cost
burdened renters has increased each year since 2007.11
o According to the same report, racial and ethnic minorities are disproportionately affected.12
In 2012, 27% of African-American households paid over 50% of their incomes in rent,
along with 24% of Hispanic households and 21% of Asian households; only 14% of White
households paid over 50% of their incomes in rent.13
o The safety net has failed to provide adequate resources. Only one in four of those poor
enough to qualify for low-income housing assistance receives it.14
Demographics
According to data collected by HUD, over the course of 2012 the “sheltered” homeless population
was:
o 63% male; 37% female15 (data based on sheltered adults)
o 83.7% non-Hispanic/non-Latino; 16.3% Hispanic/Latino16
o 38.9% White, non-Hispanic; 9.5% White, Hispanic; 39.4% Black or African American;
5% other single race; 7.2% multiple races17
o 22.6% under age 18; 23.5% 18 to 30; 35.0% 31 to 50; 15.6% 51-61; 3.2% 62 and older 18
o 63.1% single-person household19
o 38.6% disabled20 (data based on sheltered adults)
When compared to the total population and those living in poverty, those who are homeless are
more likely to be adult, male, African American, not elderly, unaccompanied/alone, and
disabled.21
o In 2010, one out of every 141 persons in Black families stayed in a homeless shelter,
compared with one out of every 990 persons in White families.22
o Black persons in families represented 38.8% of sheltered persons in families in 2010,
though they only made up 12.1% of the entire U.S. family population.23
Children, youth, and families
People in families made up 37.4% of the total sheltered and unsheltered homeless population in
2012.24
The proportion of homeless people who used emergency shelters and transitional housing as part
of a family increased from 30% to 35% from 2007 to 2010, with the majority of homeless families
consisting of single mothers with young children.25
About 2.5 million children, or one in every 30, were homeless in 2013, an increase of 64% since
2007.26
From 2011 to 2012, the number of unaccompanied children in shelter increased by 28%.27
For the 2012-2013 school year, 1,258,182 students were identified as homeless, an increase of
7.6% over the previous year.28 Of those students identified as homeless, 75% were living
“doubled-up” with family/friends; 16% were living in shelters; 6% were living in hotels/motels;
and 3% were living in some type of unsheltered location.29
Veterans
On a single night in January 2014, veterans accounted for about 11.3% of all homeless adults.30
During a 12 month period from October 2011 to September 2012, homeless veterans accounted
for one in 156 veterans.31
Domestic violence survivors
In a 2014 survey of 25 US cities, 15% of all homeless adults were identified as survivors of
domestic violence.32
In a national census of domestic violence services conducted in September 2013, 36,348 victims
of domestic violence received housing services from domestic violence programs, which includes
emergency shelters and transitional housing, in a 24-hour period.33
The same domestic violence services census found that 60% of requests that service providers
were not able to meet were those for housing (emergency shelter and transitional housing), with a
total of 5,778 requests unmet.34
Causes of homelessness
Insufficient income and lack of affordable housing are the leading causes of homelessness:
o In 2012, 10.3 million renters (approximately one in four) had “extremely low incomes”
(ELI) as classified by HUD.35 In that same year, there were only 5.8 million rental units
affordable to the more than 10 million people identified as ELI.36
o Additionally, only 31 out of every 100 of these affordable units were actually available to
people identified as ELI.37
After paying their rent and utilities, 75% of ELI households end up with less than half of their
income left to pay for necessities such as food, medicine, transportation, or childcare.38
The foreclosure crisis also played, and continues to play, a significant role in homelessness:
o In 2008, state and local homeless groups reported a 61% rise in homelessness since the
foreclosure crisis began.39
o Approximately 40% of families facing eviction due to foreclosure are renters; the problem
may continue to worsen as renters represent a rising segment of the U.S. population.40
For women in particular, domestic violence is a leading cause of homelessness.41
According to the most recent annual survey by the U.S. Conference of Mayors, major cities across
the country report that top causes of homelessness among families were: (1) lack of affordable
housing, (2) unemployment, (3) poverty, and (4) low wages, in that order.42 The same report found
that the top four causes of homelessness among unaccompanied individuals were (1) lack of
affordable housing, (2) unemployment, (3) poverty, (4) mental illness and the lack of needed
services, and (5) substance abuse and the lack of needed services.43
1 The McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act, 42 U.S.C. §§ 11302(a)-(b) (2012). With the reauthorization of the
McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act in 2009 as the Homeless Emergency Assistance and Rapid Transition to Housing
(HEARTH) Act, the HUD definition of “homeless” was expanded to include an individual who is exiting an institution where
he or she temporarily resided; an individual or family who is at the imminent risk of losing their housing and has no resources
to secure new permanent housing; unaccompanied youth and homeless families with children and youth who are defined as
homeless under other federal statutes; and an individual or family who is experiencing domestic violence and other dangerous
or life-threatening conditions such as dating violence, sexual assault, and stalking, etc. However, HUD uses the older, narrower
definition in its counts. The narrow definition is sometimes referred to as “literal” homelessness. See U.S. Department of
Housing & Urban Development, THE 2014 ANNUAL HOMELESS ASSESSMENT REPORT TO CONGRESS, PART 1 POINT-IN-TIME ESTIMATES OF
HOMELESSNESS 2 (Oct. 2014), https://www.hudexchange.info/resources/documents/2014-AHAR-Part1.pdf. 2 Maria Foscarinis. Homeless problem bigger than our leaders think: Column, USA Today, Jan. 16, 2014,
http://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2014/01/16/homeless-problem-obama-america-recession-column/4539917/; Kim
Hopper et al., Estimating Numbers of Unsheltered Homeless People Through Plant-Capture and Post count Survey Methods,
98 Am. J. Pub. Health 1438, 1442 (2008), http://ajph.aphapublications.org/doi/abs/10.2105/AJPH.2005.083600. 3 The most comprehensive and reliable data are from a survey conducted in 1996 by Martha Burt [Laudan Y. Aron, Edgar Lee,
and Jesse Valente] and published in 2001 by the Urban Institute, [Martha R. Burt et al., Helping America’s Homeless:
Emergency Shelter Or Affordable Housing? 47-50, The Urban Institute Press (2001).This study found that, using a narrow
definition of homelessness, about 1 million were homeless at any given point in time and about 3.5 million were homeless over
the course of a year. Unfortunately, it has not been updated since then. 4 See National Alliance to End Homelessness, HOMELESSNESS LOOMS AS POTENTIAL OUTCOME OF RECESSION (2009),
http://www.endhomelessness.org/page/-/files/2161_file_Projected_Increases_in_Homelessness.pdf. 5 National Alliance to End Homelessness, THE STATE OF HOMELESSNESS IN AMERICA 2014, 41 (2014),
http://b.3cdn.net/naeh/d1b106237807ab260f_qam6ydz02.pdf. 6 National Center for Homeless Education, EDUCATION FOR HOMELESS CHILDREN AND YOUTHS: CONSOLIDATED STATE PERFORMANCE
REPORT DATA 2 (2014), http://center.serve.org/nche/downloads/data-comp-1011-1213.pdf. 7 The National Center on Family Homelessness, AMERICA’S YOUNGEST OUTCASTS: A REPORT CARD ON CHILD HOMELESSNESS 6 (Nov.
2014), http://www.homelesschildrenamerica.org/mediadocs/280.pdf. 8 National Law Center on Homelessness & Poverty & Yale University Law School Allard K. Lowenstein Human Rights
Clinic, WELCOME HOME: THE RISE OF TENT CITIES IN THE UNITED STATES (2013),
http://nlchp.org/documents/WelcomeHome_TentCities. 9 See Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University, THE STATE OF THE NATION’S HOUSING 22-26 (2014),
http://www.jchs.harvard.edu/sites/jchs.harvard.edu/files/sonhr14_txt_bw-full.pdf. 10 Id. at 27 11 Id. 12 Id. 13 Id. at 27, 28.
14 Id. at 30. 15 U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, THE 2012 ANNUAL HOMELESS ASSESSMENT REPORT (AHAR) TO CONGRESS
VOLUME II: ESTIMATES OF HOMELESSNESS IN THE UNITED STATES 1-8 (Sept. 2013),
https://www.hudexchange.info/resources/documents/2012-AHAR-Volume-2.pdf. 16 Id. at 1-9. 17 Id.
18 Id. at 1-8. 19 Id. at 1-11. 20 Id. 21 U.S. States Conference of Mayors, Hunger and Homelessness Survey: A STATUS ON HUNGER AND HOMELESS IN AMERICA’S CITIES –
A 25-CITY SURVEY 2 (Dec. 2014), http://www.usmayors.org/pressreleases/uploads/2014/1211-report-hh.pdf. 22 Institute for Children, Poverty & Homelessness, INTERGENERATIONAL DISPARITIES EXPERIENCED BY HOMELESS BLACK FAMILIES 1
(Mar. 2012), http://www.icphusa.org/filelibrary/ICPH_Homeless%20Black%20Families.pdf. 23 Ralph da Costa Nunez, Homelessness: It’s About Race, Not Just Poverty, Citylimits.org, Mar. 2012,
http://www.citylimits.org/conversations/159/homeless-the-role-of-race. 24 U.S. Department of Housing & Urban Development, THE 2014 ANNUAL HOMELESS ASSESSMENT REPORT (AHAR) TO CONGRESS,
PART 1 POINT-IN-TIME ESTIMATES OF HOMELESSNESS 1 (Oct. 2014), https://www.hudexchange.info/resources/documents/2014-
AHAR-Part1.pdf.
25 U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, The 2010 ANNUAL HOMELESS ASSESSMENT REPORT (AHAR) TO CONGRESS
iii (2010), http://www.hudhre.info/documents/2010HomelessAssessmentReport.pdf. 26 See FN 7 at 15. 27 See FN 15 at 2-8. 28 See FN 6 at 1. 29 Id. at 2.
30 See FN 24 at 40. 31 See FN 15 at 4-6, 4-7. 32 See FN 21 at 2. 33 National Network to End Domestic Violence, DOMESTIC VIOLENCE COUNTS 2013: A 24-HOUR CENSUS OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
SHELTERS AND SERVICES 1 (Sept. 2013),
http://nnedv.org/downloads/Census/DVCounts2013/Census13_FullReport_forweb_smallestFileSizeWhiteMargins.pdf.
34 Id. 35 National Low Income Housing Coalition, HOUSING SPOTLIGHT: THE AFFORDABLE RENTAL HOUSING GAP PERSIST 2 (Aug. 2014),
http://nlihc.org/sites/default/files/HS_4-1.pdf. 36 Id.
37 Id. at 3, 4. 38 Id. at 4. 39 National Law Center on Homelessness & Poverty, STAYING HOME: THE RIGHTS OF RENTERS LIVING IN FORECLOSED PROPERTIES 2
(June 2010), http://nlchp.org/documents/StayingHome. 40 National Law Center on Homelessness & Poverty, EVICTION (WITHOUT) NOTICE: RENTERS AND THE FORECLOSURE CRISIS 6 (Dec.
2012), http://www.nlchp.org/Eviction_Without_Notice.
41 Tischler, et al., Mothers experiencing homelessness: mental health, support and social care needs, 15 Health Soc. Care
Cmty. 3, 246-253 (May 2007); see also Ellen Shelton, et al., Homeless Study Fact Sheet: Long-Term Homelessness, Wilder
Res. Ctr. (Apr. 2013) (finding that at least 32% of homeless Minnesota women reported becoming homeless due to domestic
violence).
42 See FN 21 at 2. 43 Id.
updated January 2015