HomeMy WebLinkAbout433 N Black 2008 MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
For the Montana National Register of Historic Places Program and State Antiquities Database
Montana State Historic Preservation Office
Montana Historical Society
PO Box 201202, 1410 8th Ave
Helena,MT 59620-1202
Property Address: 433 North Black Avenue : Site Number: 24-
(An historic district number may also apply.)
Historic Address(if applicable): same as above '•
City/Town: Bozeman MT 59715 County: Gallatin County
................_.......................................................................................-.-.._.._..-.._.._.._.._---..-.._.._---.._._
Historic Name: unknown Legal Location
OriginalOwner(s): unknown PM: Montana Township: 2S Range: 6E
i
Current Ownership M Private ❑Public NE '/a NW '/a NW '/ of Section: 7
Current Property Name: 433 North Black Avenue Lot(s): 14&15
Owner(s): Lisa&Rob Pertzborn Block(s): E
Owner Address: 518 North Tracy Avenue Addition: Beall's Second Year of Addition:
Bozeman MT 59715
USGS Quad Name: Bozeman, MT Year: 1987
Phone: 406.580.0422
Historic Use: Single Family Residence UTM Reference www.nris.mt, og v/topofinder2
Current Use: Single Family Residence M NAD 27(preferred) ❑NAD 83
Construction Date: Pre-1898 M Estimated ❑Actual i Zone: 12 Easting: 497251 Northing: 5058753
i
i
M Original Location ❑Moved Date Moved: i
---------------------------------------
National Register of Historic Places Date of this document: January 2008
NRHP Listing Date: n/a Form Prepared by: Intrinsik Architecture
i
i
Historic District: Bozeman Neighborhood i Address: 111 North Tracy Avenue
Conservation Overlay District
Daytime Phone: 406-582-8988
NRHP Eligible: ❑Yes M No
...........--------------._.._.._.._.._._.._.._.._.._.._.._ _ _ _ _
i
MT SHPO USE ONLY i Comments:
Eligible for NRHP: ❑ yes ❑no
Criteria: ❑ A ❑B ❑ C ❑ D
Date:
Evaluator:
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
PAGE 2
Property Name: 433 North Black Avenue Site Number: 24-
ARCHITECTURAL DESCRIPTION ❑ See Additional Information Page
Architectural Style: Other If Other,specify: [vernacular/national style]
Property Type: Residential Specific Property Type: Single Family Residence
Architect: unknown Architectural Firm/City/State: unknown
Builder/Contractor: unknown Company/City/State: unknown
Source of Information: n/a
Concisely,accurately,and completely describe the property and alterations with dates. Number the buildings and features to
correlate with the Site Map.
1. The 840 gross square foot residence was most likely constructed pre-1898 as evidenced by the reference
to"improvements" on the property in the 1893 will of Fredrick Edmunds. A rear addition was removed
sometime prior to the 1927 Sanborn Map and a new rear addition was constructed sometime post-1943.
An enclosed front entry was added around 1996 according to the current owner who has lived near the
subject property for the last 12 years.
The Montana Historical &Architectural Inventory states: "This detached one-story single-family residence
has a rectangular plan with a small shed roof over the entranceway. The one-bay fagade is symmetrical
and consists of a central front entrance flanked by two 4/4 double-hung windows. The roof over the
entrance is supported by two wood posts. The frame construction is finished in shiplap and rests on a
concrete foundation. The gable roof is covered with metal shingles and features boxed overhanging
eaves. There is a central metal stovepipe. The axis of the roof is perpendicular to the street". (Note that
the house actually does not include metal shingles or boxed eaves.)The house has a galvanized steel
sheet metal roof. Simple drop horizontal siding has been painted white and the wood trim is painted dark
green. Note that the siding exposure varies on the original structure and on the subsequent additions.
2. The dilapidated alley shed was likely constructed at the same time as the house as evidenced by the
1904 Sanborn Map. It has a 240 square foot footprint and has an "U shaped plan. The shed is located
approximately one foot off of the alley(gable ridge runs parallel to the alley). The gable roof has a pitch of
13.5/ 12. An addition to the east elevation includes a low shed roof. The siding is simple unpainted drop
horizontal siding and the roof has remains of wood shingles.
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
PAGE 3
Property Name: 433 North Black Avenue Site Number: 24-
HISTORY OF PROPERTY ❑ See Additional Information Page
The house and shed are associated with the general residential aspect of the Civic Phase of Bozeman's
historic/architectural development. The Abstract of Title for the property describes some of the property's
history through its owners. One possible construction date is 1883, when James Kelly, the editor of the
Bozeman Chronicle, and his wife, Mary Ann Kelly sold the property to Frederick Edmonds for$1000. This
"consideration" is significantly more than earlier considerations; however, interestingly, it is also more than
later considerations which may make this data unreliable. The earliest reference to actual "improvements"
on the property is found in the 1893 will of Fredrick Edmunds.
INFORMATION SOURCESBIBLIOGRAPHY ❑ See Additional Information Page
1904, 1912, 1927, 1927-1943 Sanborn Maps. Sanborn Map & Publishing Co., Limited. New York: 1904,
1912, 1927, 1927-1943.
Gallatin County Clerk& Recorder's Office, Deed Records. Abstract of Title No. 2169 to Lots 14 & 15 in
Block"E" of Beall's Second Addition to the City of Bozeman. Gallatin County Courthouse, Bozeman,
Montana.
James R. McDonald Architects P.C. Bozeman's Historic Resources: Bozeman Historic Resource Survey.
Missoula, Montana: James R. McDonald Architects, August 1984.
McAlester, Virginia & Lee. A Field Guide to American Houses. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, Inc., 1984.
Pertzborn, Rob. Personal Interview. 10 January 2008
R.L. Polk&Co. Publishers, Polk's Bozeman City Directory(Kansas City, MO: R.L. Polk&Co.
Publishers),
Vol. 1900-1901.
United States. City of Bozeman, Montana. Sewer Card for 433 North Black Avenue. Bozeman: 2003
United States. City of Bozeman, Montana. Water Card for 433 North Black Avenue. Bozeman: 1958
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
PAGE 4
Property Name: 433 North Black Avenue Site Number: 24-
NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
NRHP Listing Date: n/a
NRHP Eligibility: ❑Yes ❑No ❑ Individually ❑Contributing to Historic District ®Noncontributing to Historic District
NRHP Criteria: ❑A ❑B ❑C ❑D
Area of Significance: Period of Significance:
STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE ❑ See Additional Information Page
n/a [The property was deemed "neutral" (noncontributing)as part of the City of Bozeman Certificate of
Appropriateness Development Review Application#Z-07248.]
INTEGRITY(location,design,setting,materials,workmanship,feeling,association) ❑ See Additional Information Page
The 60'xl40' property is located several lots north and west of Beall Park. Mature hedges and trees line
the property. A narrow concrete pathway connects the central door to the sidewalk along North Black
Avenue. This small house sits a few feet above the grade of the sidewalk. Structurally, the residence is
dilapidated with a substandard foundation, bowing walls, sloping floors and other significant decay. The
shed in the rear of the property is near collapsing. Refer to attached drawings and photographs.
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION PAGE
Property Name: 433 North Black Avenue Site Number: 24-
n/a
T
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
PHOTOGRAPHS
Property Name: 433 North Black Avenue Site Number: 24-
My
Pon
Roll# u
Frame# _
Feature#
Facing:
Description:
r - .
,f
Roll#
Frame#
Feature#
Facing:
Descri tion:
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
PHOTOGRAPHS �
EP,opertye: 433 North Black Avenue Site Number: 24-
rD ' -
r
Roll#
Frame#
Feature#
Facing:
Description:
moor
n
r
Roll# /
Frame# r
Feature#
Facing:
Description:
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
PHOTOGRAPHS
Property Name: 433 North Black Avenue Site Number: 24-
Roll#
Frame# 1�
Feature#
Facing:
Description:
I
�� �rs W � ,•��
Roll#
Frame#
Feature#
Facing:
Description:
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
PHOTOGRAPHS
Property Name: 433 North Black Avenue Site Number: 24-
dig
NEW
t
Roll#
Frame#
Feature#
Facing:
Description:
� I �
Roll#
Frame#
Feature#
Facing:
Description:
1
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
PHOTOGR-APHS
Property Name: 433 North Black Avenue Site Number: 24-
_ V
Roll-9
Frame� " -
Feature ft
Pacing:
Description:
i
I
J
tr
Roll#
Frame#
Feature
Pacing:
Description:
MONTANA HISTORIC1RECORD
PHOTOGRAPHS
Property
' 4;, \
a } A
j i.Y
iry
v`' -�
4^
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
SITE MAP
Pro ert Name: 433 North Black Avenue Site Number: 24-
Sketch a map of the property. Label and/or number buildings and described features.
Include a North arrow,street names,and property boundaries.
[See attached site plan. ]
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
TOPOGRAPHIC MAP
Pro e Name: 433 North Black Avenue Site Number: 24-
USGS Topographic Quadrangle, 1:24,000 scale. Do not reduce or enlarge map;keep the
map scale accurate because legal locations are checked with a plastic template. Label the
property location,including the SITS number,in a method that will photocopy well. A
highlighter marker is not acceptable.
[See attached map.]
0
§ �
$ 00
o �
000
2
Z DS
O
> �
W �
� W
co
W �
LLJ
\\
I z °
IET:ll
0° je Z
�� - W
� \} z > / \�\ Q
} ] } \_ <( \ \k \}/
CDy r\ s $\ j\
J2
� 2
� >
0w
w
Z w
S
m
) � 0
cn
Z
0 O
� y �
> c > 2\
� � \
-
-
) W W \\u
$ .
� 6\
oOf Of}\
O o
m -
$\)[
/9\
&e\
_ [\}( �_ W:
® � /I
Of U)< a C,L;
\ \ 'LLi
r;
/U,
�)w* 4
0
Go
k00
o �
k -.1
§ O ■
k=
)r
(§
,-- - > -
�- -
_ : W
W �
\\ j.-
~ J
�Ld
� q
� w
� w
\ 3
Zw
� Q
2
2(f)(
0> - -§
W � 0�\\
so 2 )«gC)
/ /° \
Z®
� $}\\
O z§
Z LLJ>e �:
b/ U)
\\=� C.w;
§\[ }\§ ) '�
kG% i
B CLIL'
-,- C:CD
$/
3- 6
�w \2-<0
I
1
I I + G EVERGR2ENI IIl \
+ EXISTII�G
+
> 1 + + +
TO REMAIN EDGES + + + tt
_ J + J J J J 140'-0" PROPERTY LINE J
1 r + * + ' c
EXISTING
HE
TO S J 1 + l
-y-y_y_y tt
EASTIN
GAS-VERIFY ROUTE > T�E
ALLEY=i \o1\11�vII
(15' R.O. V.)
TO BE TO BE t I - REMOVED REMOVED—
[EX
= ]REMOVED
I T
EXISTING HOUSE a Elt
tt
w. r i ��\ TO BE REPLACED
_. % � j NORTH BLACK AVENUE
= I 60'
R.O.W.
I EXISTING MATURE"-
a M EXISTING ASH TREE rs �< 1` >IDEWAIZ
�) GRAVEL PARKING EXISTING �I
a sa XISTING(8/03)
>E (TO REMAIN) y` SEWER LINE TO EXISTING(6�03)4"SEWER LINE TO NEW GARAGE
= I rr EASTNG HOUSE ss —ss
Est—st —u —as a st ss—ss—ss —ss
EASTIN MATURE ULA BUSHES TO AIN —�
PgRK
SIGN
= 140'-0" PROPERTY LINE M
€ EXISTING I
SHED
I EXISTING
HOUSE I
I
NOTE: THESE RECORD DOCUMENTS ARE DRAWN BASED ON FIELD AND
ASSUMED MEASUREMENTS IN JANUARY 2008. THE CURRENT CONDITIONS
OF THESE STRUCTURES HAVE WARPED AND LEANING PLANES, WHEREAS
THE DRAWINGS REFLECT THE PRESUMED ORIGINAL CONDITIONS.
inGr:nsiK 433 NORTH BLACK AVENUE DATE: 01.10.08 N H
DRAWN BYRCHIT ECTURE SITE PLAN SCALE: 1/16" = 1%0t'
A
I N C 0 R P 0 R R T E O
I s �
f wT3 ` 'I BOZEMAN, MONTANA
I _ _
.2;1 PROVISIONAL EDITION 1987 `
T�alcr I �476BAT •. , / •i1 -- = _
Pork Ix ` �� �nl qn d • 2a�` - -
. . A Ale '�7�i l
• • - � Subject -i ! ) �,� 0, •
•�' Property •� _•.
• . i t � f x � • 1
_ ,If •
If ry �1
. - -�— -.-- - - - .v 1 • J
r.�-.-
1
Die
1�IIq`r��I 1
Fi
• �IW � - - - 1 --
Mnlr
•him-
as r
— _ I go 1H.
p
A rK � • r
•• ?� I /
r
. +ra ••• I j ' r ••
Y t
� -' V•• yf N7EMi CM-4R QI�OO.CIL iU.vC Y.�K1Ti
SCALE 1:24 000
1 1
S
logo 0 111111111 IOOo 3000 1000 Woo 6000 7000 0000 90 0 I DODO
EEI
.S 0 KILOMETERS I 7
logo King 1060 100
CONTOUR INTERVAL 20 PEEL'
Page 1 of 1
6, 9oZ¢MAN fi n AV. N. --•-•--• ��--
- - - 2 ea — `may �►
75
C
16i
- -•---- -�- - e - - - .-ter ems.-- -- — A�.w -` - - �'� '� - --
r .a
• � � I TT �
TRALY AV-__n_
14
_I ♦ n • fib/1 .—
CENTRAL AV. N. a«.C#.r• � e
19
v r
http://sanbom.umi.com/sanbom/image/fetchimagc?state=mt&reelid=ree102&lcid=4944&im... 1/8/2008
Page 1 of 1
11
I
�Mam
- — -
" V9m k
.
I js
RJ
+[YS
+ � 1
UW
t y a
ELACB(, $ ��
_ rA�
I
wr •
r cr
x �y1 �j}r tIf
I
. I
�- -_^•----e ..-M---__....._TRA.CY '� _q _dac ...........
•r. ion s
�^ t QQ
L _ � • 1 f
• �J h. —�
df' I=puir
T W
CENURAL
k�
http://sanbom.umi.com/sanbom/image/fetchimage?state=mt&reelid=ree102&lcid=4944&im... 1/8/2008
Page 1 of 1
� lI 907C.MN .-__.AV-.....N,.. ... .............17J..............- MONT ..k.,... .1
tii........�... .. _...-............... •eLACN...- .._.._..... ..j/_.... ,_..._........_.__..... . .. •
29.
70
W d f�
�1. U J --
y T• l]r iP ro-1 .. •11 ,
h www111 I.I - � •1 r�
k �♦ S 1 I t' � � F I.' I] 1
E•>I 2 LI ;I h
t • ._ H
pal
330
•1 j
rq W I L.L.%Rt AM
-- - ----� — 7--� r---
http://sanbom.umi.com/sanborn/image/fetchimage?state=mt&reelid=ree102&lcid=4944&im... 1/8/2008
Page 1 of 1
.�r• MoKt .s.. .{ .f
At
9 LLJJ 3
AiT S
-�-dl m ,
.Y.... ....... ..........._... .. .. .BU4CIi- ,F,ld....,-NY-_,. _N.• _•• —................................................
or
—X.
r +
r 3
!fir'a 0 [r
A................. .....................7A6CY....... ......W-1. ..N..... .... ...............In
...
I 'I
— -� - - -=47iDI
3
y r l II •I
I ,
y ..j1C0•, rY1 Li60Sf MV,
I
Ob
http://sanbom.umi.com/sanboni/image/fetchimage?state=mt&reelid=ree102&lcid=4944&im... 1/8/2008
m
syul 5
ow > a Z n1
cd N O lip
�' cc
y > M Cd •" • a G .tir
bri
U pl n cd m w N 0
C w R O n Cd U N N aj O d �
F C U �-1 CO ✓ P n U H a % a
bU�, �, cd .q °d O x cd U O N N bbl) .^
3 � " 0
7 ° U W U M O ° y c��d w 0 V
0,0 d ° U Q Pa T Z " U O N cd q H
� FeA
C Z a cd � a; N " NO c3 > a in --
°w ° •y. Z °'
in
" Q, a 0o `d HC +zu U HbA Wa c � u d Go
C =dc u vO
C" ° gv HoCISo
104•Acd N N 3. cd
WHtifA
Q0at
—°� O O` Ua m U ° x ° M m
rnU � a MZ 0 �
,0 " 0) 'cd
Cd 't N "n Z E a A 0 cdC1 U N O Z V
ho
a� b aMZ ro � ub , ° •
o ;o
a o u i ►-1 a VC cd cd bn -o ( 41 p >
�� +a cd 4-4mac OD (l] .� d vi a M Z C•
G� 0 Q (� .o 0 O b o O,� � W W E-+.`� v b��o b o� (7 - w
V Y, rl ✓, >, y, `� O O O O 1b W
q a: .°b xa mod. ti ... C a ., G4 bA v) n N v, a n H, N
�a 0 4 0 O o 4.2 O cd cd W (" ' v ,, w Z 0 ^w .o
V r ZZz ZZZzZZZ
•p 'd '6 H 5 vim, v •0 z
a ead � o �; � � u ao `� O Z
r u �, PA > en M �C
r � ou
pp U bn o DD e►
C M �i tt1 ONO a�i —0vn
v
NO y M H N (U 4 N U
U o E v ?• C 0 co cisb o R
CJ «+ o U W cd cn > rn V' Fi > ,� II� 0 cd cd •N b
ca x b U cd r bEn
co cd
O 0 cd n v H V i, F—, NQo I.- N �" : f. .1 � W ,01 C (�4 W o � dpq �H NcqsH NpQ N 4. ►N � "vG ,C] � N b0� p R U �
w ✓ f\ L' ^H Np p �` `� a w bn a"i a a N a A C W "
d .n y 40 ► �' N .0 C� C " A w
04' d hr+ t^\ Lv+ G y M�Qy, " ^� p c .`G`tltl xp lr H�( �, c—, tn ,
ti
Ce
to y W -"v. p •d �.' .. G.H v U co
o CN v C v cd G " u
W N v, c+ C v o v C C 1
N �;¢ � .- � ° �wc� x .°,°ao � 3: C a 0 °tea N O V �1
0 V, C v 'Cf' Cc: C cd �\ w ,� `n H •� v •N K
cd
Cz � zz
W
i
CAP TIO TST
No
Abstract of Title to the following described land situated in the County of Gallatin, State of
Montana,to wit:
I-N-D-E-X
No. 1 sbo„'s 1) prr-1In LOce-tio;l of lo' s describer, In c"mtion 1-erein.
No. 2 P;t n t e The U.S.A. to uvilliam J. Beall -
No. 3 rt Levy Ilill.iam T.Beall,Deft. by nelson Story;,Pltff,
No. 4 'r �rt.Of S`;l_e Sheri :' 0f Ilotin ' O. , to Nelson Story
No. 5 " Sheriff's Deed Sheriff of "e11:--tin Co. to TTnI_son Story
No. 6 .C.Deed Nelson Story,et ux, to iiilir n J .Fe�l1
No. 7 It Platting P,'i11i ra J. Bey ll,et al, to 7eall'-. ".canal r'ddn_.
tt 1 r ll t 'a x to Jt'.me s Kelly
No. 8 Wurlanty Deed ll_ia. .Bea ,
No. g " PJ^rr :nty, Deed J�.nies Kelly,et ux to Ireder ck - unds
No. 10-14 Ci..Proceedings Estate of :Fredrick rdmunds, to -liza Edraun7_s
No. 15 " 'Tarremty Deed Eliza Edmonds,T,„ido,.�a, to Eliz<abr;th r':'ouch
No. 16 " Yort:-a!;e & Rel. Elizabeth Uouch, to Eliza lmond._
No. 17 " Tarre.nty Deed Elizabeth Moueb to Me rcius Guirand
No. 18 TVort e,me pk Re1. Mlary E. Callantine to TlRarcuis Guirand
rlo. lg yiarr^nt`r Deed 'Marcius Guirand to Mary E.Callantine
it t 1 t e t a z, t o Francis jl.l m..an
No. 20 ..arrant-:= Dead D,�vid �. -1_en in; ,
No. 21 't iTort. e, %L ,e t; u,7, to 'Marcui: v-iirsnd
ir��•Te Rel Y'r=ands �,� offer_
No. 22,232 Affidavit C.M.Thorpe re Idetity
No. 24 W.Deed- Francis M.Logan,et ux, to Loretta Sponsler
No. 2503 Ct.peoceedings Est.of Loretta Sponsler, to Ivor W.Sponsler,et al
No. 34,43 Ct.Proceedings Est.Ivor W.Sponsler, to John W.Sponsler,et al
No. 44,54 Ct. " Est.Gu2rdianship of John W.Sponsler
No. 55 Order n to Anton L.B:1rta,et ux
No. 56 W.Deed Eunice Sponsler Stevens, to
C,A,.Prrl0l%#T
NO
Abstract of Title to the following described land situated in the County of Gallatin, State of
Montana, to wit:
I.. 0 7 N - mIT OJT T TP E C 1 OF B 0 ZEc j,
_.T. 1;'r BLOCK "E" OF BEAI 'S S) C C�M ,E-DT
D T,�`
E P RCT T RED.
G,,'d;L Tj N C"Gi NTY, ivll ONITA 11 i, ','I I II m-- L 0 IS U ND E T� 1"S COLO,
.-'T. I
No �ne o Z F-y-,-,7--7--eS IX
I-? S1100477 -S r.
14
19 0 NO
rh IG
"If
27
-9
7
------------
F f
-3
1 14 1
3 6 37 36 3� o
"ICA L z 4 A0L)1r101.v
^10AI 7.
Address----- AJ g
RECORD OF WATER SERVICE
Now------------ Renewal---X------ Appl. No---------S__7 -----
-------
Owner-i —--------- Date------
Lot --ji-IL-57................................................................................
Block _-E-------- -—---------------- ------------------- Addition 7-
----------------Service from main on---.- ------- - ----- - ----------------
Deposit - -----------------------------
Charge (over 60') .................
Total ---------------------------
Date MAINTENANCE Cost
-- - ---- -------------- ---- ...------ ----------—------------
----------------------------------- ---- -----------------------
... ............ ----------------------------
Application and Record of Sewer Connection File Number
Owner Addre____47,'-i
Lot Bloch
Addition
—Inch Sewer In 51
C!
Y-StationDistance
Manhole
13 W,L K
n,,, H
rafT ID -77'
Owner 011" 5 H G PIT
i
l~D T P_ C �G- �G- (D (D i y H >4 �i cD
B rr rr °
0 4 m ((D y f o 0 p W •°
�? I �, o
p`° '
i (D 1 1 �.
'
i en ce7 f® l� c® !a7 (7 c7
0
i h k3 'r I�-.
i o I lei
I 'J pw�
I t E I I rk i �1
i 0
LZ
COST and MATERIAL
MATERIAL LABOR AND EQUIPMENT
u IT5 EkLL eegplegot.E aQd .a9 :5 rs. @ _ 30•��
4N �.uqn sac &Ual k o L'7 a0 a�Hn. @ d3-115 ao7A6
4" -eap k SEu1g2 APE ffz ob Firs. @
1601 Hrs. @a 7.70 ,-70
WA-010 -Rock E 1q t, -1.gL v7n Hn. @ a .oD
?A�P- sm o6 2w H,. @ a5. 00 ED .DD
ars7 a ua ( arQ.00 5 a .oo
Data Total Labor r/o�(•(O�
�j Total Equipt o2
Total Material (�� " Foreman Total Material
Total Cost- I 0r7 —