HomeMy WebLinkAbout410 N Church 1984 MONTANA HISTORICAL AND
ARCHITECTURAL INVENTORY Site
Babcock and Davis Lots 3 and 5 Blk 6 -'
__gal Description: -
Address: 410 North Church
Ownership:name: William B: Smith
[$private address: 410 North Church Roll# 15 Frame# 7A-8
❑ public
i L J v _ 1
(+ Historic Name: Ifaknown
7 �J Common Name: 1 I IQ w
❑ estimated
Date of Construction: 1882-1 889 ®documented
Architect: Unknown
Builder: Unknom
- - - - Original Owner. A. 0. Canfield
Original Use: Residence
Present Use: Rosidenca I Research Sources:
❑ abstract of title ❑ city directories
�platrecordslmaps tract ❑ sewedwaterpermits
❑ tax cards ❑ obituaries
—~ ❑ building permit ❑ biographies
0 Sanborn maps—dates: 1890 _
(J Bibliography:
Q _ Water Permit renewal 1976
Q; —
b -r- 9 1 0L F Y Department of Sanitation
PHYSICAL DESCRIPTION: Describe present appearance of structure/site,then contrast and compare that with it's original appearance,
noting additions,alterations,and changes in materials.Discuss significant architectural features.
This detached one-and-one-half story single-family residence has a greek cross
plan with a shed-roofed front porch. The three-bay facade is asymmetrical
and consists of an off-center front entrance with fixed and 1/1 double-hung
windows. The frame construction is finished in grey asphalt siding and
rests on a cut stone foundation. There is concrete covering the stone.
The gable roof is covered with roofing tile and features boxed eaves and
two brick chimneys. Outbuildings include a shed.
HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Justify how the persons,important events,and/or historical patterns associated with the structure/site
and surrounding area lend the property significance.
Research in the sources consulted in this survey has not yielded any
significant-historical information concerning persons or events
associated with this property.
This structure is an intrusive element within a potential historic district.
INTEGRITY. Assess the degree to which the structure/site,and surrounding area accurately convey the historical associations of the
property.
The historic Integrity of this property has not been retained due to change
In original design and materials.
INFORMATION VALUE: Explain how the extant structure/site may demonstrate or yield information about its historic use or construc-
tion.
None.
FORM PREPARED BY: GEOGRAPHICAL INFORMATION:
Name DAMES R. 1W.CDONALD ARCHITECTS P.C. Acreage:
Address: P. 0. 00;t 8163 USGS Quad:
Date- MISSOULA, MONTANA 59807 uTwt's:
H U
410 N. Church Avenue Detached Shed — Proposed Demolition COA
September 16, 2008
Planning Staff determines the existing detached shed on the property addressed at 410
North Church as a "non-contributing" structure in the Neighborhood Conservation
Overlay District. According to Sanborn Insurance maps, two detached structures existed
on the site in 1943, but neither corresponds to the current shed's location. One of the
detached structures shown in 1943 is similar in footprint size to the existing shed, which
means it could be the same structure but in a different location. Staff determines the
shed was moved either onto the site, or moved on the site, post-1943. The original
materials were also changed post-1943. Both alterations affect the contributing status of
the structure. Therefore, the demolition is approved by the Department of Planning.
a u�v a va a
-D
ik
0.' / ,1
7L x► ! "
a
bl zxi
r /
v N
n
I
�i
II
1160
am. �I
http://sanbom.umi.com/sanbom/im age/fetchimage?state=mt&reelid=ree102&lcid=4944&i... 9/16/2008
ragciuii
5pv"
1912-
y zjoz
43
'` X 57)
�/ z 1
N rl �
x
I!
i'
h
Y
�, Nen No
U
� �� -�i• 2802 z x 2� x 1 q/3�
T X r
j
1
II a
Nn
U �
x 1x
II �oiP
n N
6701 ?[71
IVAP
�u
http://sanbom.umi.com/sanbom/image/fetchim age?state=mt&reelid=ree102&lcid=4944&i... 9/16/2008
ra�C i ui i
Il
x xx 343
II Lx x
II "
u
>i
� A
x
� � x
�I Lx x xj
Peg
a
' x x
III
�f
X FLO
D. r 9s
x �
20
vrDl 549
q
http://sanbom.umi.com/sanbom/im age/fetchim age?state=mt&reeli d=ree102&l cid=4944&i... 9/16/2008
yt' 65c&" JV�v ra�C i ui i
343
II
b IN- lx x
II x X
it
n •� A2
Ii
if 7 7k
x
I! LX fx xj
� E
IS x i
X X
, x x
EXI ,
zo
fA SO/ MY
91
u
wo
�r�qll
�I
http://sanbom.umi.com/sanbom/image/fetchimage?state=mt&reelid=ree102&1cid=4944&i... 9/16/2008
f
High Country Construction
of Montana
September 14, 2008
City of Bozeman
Department of Planning and Community Development
Alfred M. Stiff Professional Building
20 East Olive Street
PO Box 1230
Bozeman, MT 59771-1230
RE: Request for Amendment COA Z-08186 410 N. Church, Bozeman, MT
In response to questions about the Request for Amendment, we have included an elevation photo
of the shed as well as the following answers.
Rehabilitation is not being considered as originally proposed since the building was found to
have structural defects in addition to health concerns with rodents, mold, lead and extensive
water damage that were not evident on initial inspection. The owners and we see that the cost to
salvage this structure for future use, which would entail gutting the structure down to it's floor,
wall and roof lumbers, replacement of damaged wood and subsequent reconstruction would be
out of the question. Even with such measures we cannot assure the absence of mold spores,
rodent droppings and leaded paint.
The feasibility of rehabilitation is limited when all of the problems are considered and the safe
use of this structure is not possible due to the mold, rodent and paint issues.
Sincerely,
Bernhard Uhl
Owner
1627 W. Main St. 352 • Bozeman, MT 59715 Ph: (406) 763-4656 • Fax: (877) 890-7776
www.hccmt.com
,Axx.
rAl-' a �1^' ttiF` • y •• (•.1' 3_7r i '
'� �- -'y ••`fir. .a ' •'•�%�
lb
t`t• .�+a ice. , tt .• - 1. •• bp ' " - t �'" f �`-�!• '�
1. - a• r+ 4i /�Fj _l, sc..i>' _ + •� t t is ` .
�� � •* �:' Shy �•. - •� �t. •n• -!•# 'IAA.
\ �. :'� tii��""+��77 :r+ � �.` { t c.�i.k/�.jw��w• r � (j,[��••r�4�. .1w!�•. :.*
-�, .:�� r}�r �' ai .i-• =�' y:;. oft. t�•�,.•f'7 �(, I�;�•'f•7�1�1� +4__�1:•-�� w� .w • �/, r+�Y•,� r'.Y w�,�, ,' "�,`, ',4
'I t 1�� � tom,'"'?': �:n. I� r�' • � � `1 � �' .t:�+t'• tt, �'i'�zi1C= t
41
-. ._ }1 _ ,�. ;; ` - r `7t4.F'r+`�,L" �'1'ft r �-V ..1'ra•!„'„ ,_ ,.., - -
' .,i ••�'� R�� �rr`w .,,�_'+e'••��;.<. . 'r �.. fir, 't�,'
f -�'•c�✓<,jF\��,y�/1 i. •� �, {t � r�� ;'�j1!- 1. tl r t �,
+ 1 14 ,�•' t-- r .� ?�,' ;Y Sa rin:' . '.-t•r' I • of
iu •;�• � � t �'I:b ' � � r �-,fir` .n �� * •`L .a �+� 4.i _
r' r. f - � " - - - -- . t ^r �`•, rfl.. I�������� .d µr.^ f� i yr�.' r
High Country Construction
of Montana
�
September 14, 2008
�ODU
DEPARTMINl OF PLANNING
City of Bozeman AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
Department of Planning and Community Development
Alfred M. Stiff Professional Building
20 East Olive Street
PO Box 1230
Bozeman, MT 59771-1230
RE: Request for Amendment COA Z-08186 410 N. Church, Bozeman, MT
We are requesting an amendment to the issued COA referenced above to demolish existing shed
on the aforementioned property. The reasons for the requested demolition are as follows:
1. Metal siding was improperly installed on the shed which created moisture intrusion and
subsequent rot and structural deterioration in the structure.
2. The moisture has created mold evidenced by intense mold odor and presence of mold
spores. Since no standard exists with respect to mold and individual tolerances vary the
presence of mold and or mold spores in any concentration is a definite health risk.
3. Because the structure was build before 1978 (when lead paint was banned)there are
many layers of paint, and there is lead-based paint present on the interior and exterior.
Lead paint poses a health threat to children and is the leading environmental health issue
for children in the US. The owners are expecting a child and the paint cannot be easily
mitigated.
4. The floors are rotten.
5. Moving the structure would cause it to literally fall apart due to the lack of structural
integrity.
6. There are visible rodent droppings and risk of HANTA VIRUS in this structure.
We have attached photos documenting the aforementioned conditions and request an amendment
to olish the structure. Your prompt attention to this matter is appreciated.
' er ly � 6�
W wner
1627 W. Main St. 352 • Bozeman, MT 59715 Ph: (406) 763-4656 • Fax: (877) 890-7776
www.hccmt.com
+ «i�....v�-t� / ., .may +���s-. _ _ •.�
... :,� t,t�1• , - �.. �,• ..fir' N�-�r �,," •,_
1 % r� �-}.'� .�[ ter,- �jj♦ -.. �1 1 ,
ol
lip
As
/ � . .• � .�Irk .- � �,r�• - �,,i• �iC' `(
"` t1� �' � y. • ...) ,
3 1 ti 1
_ �
s
_ ` ��
:%
�,'�►,_
�r '
♦� - .- - .._ - -f;-• � T"t. ;ter -�.4,� .vet--�-�• -� -
14.
Z •t_ �-- _ t t..t�.. . r.. r
40
�, � �, >.,. �t --�...'R_ --a ''ryas '-! � _ � � a. � `1_T '._._-1 •'� ` � _�1K' t
OV
'.� t.c - •♦�. a '� i �� _ �. �•L••' •-�.....�.`-.���1, � � �
:\� t`` . tf .._.. •tea.. �; - �.� „, '=y1 -
M
ti .y 'ram _ _ .• _ _ .� � - ._�_� Lt - . � -�.
A7. �Ul
1� L1r 1' 'r,j 1 '-- .� �`l •'` "�F::rJa— , - `?. �,{ .'^:.�
`_a a x�� k - - �-'.1 t `�li'♦- .1 a� -1.__.�X.•r- L�. W�-, - `- � � ` �` i t�-. � a .J -
AL
' ',. ti�'"'r�-`a7 �' •-_^--ems.-.- -y"�y�F�{i,.�`, �'�` �1+' - a �.. � • ',� _ ;---. � --a '� '. —1: _ ! ...
..-•r�`-1 �.."�'--►_.....}.w Q,a�tSt _� t_ k=�-a,��y4-a_ �.�.r.►-• .�'w��. t_._ _ �,,, �.'. -' '_�. ' `t
•.d -' ..irk`��4�Fi-ss+++ vw.� L��•r,►`+`a�r.. a�`,�`•,�•��.',.ii� .a►.l�~I�- � ati � a -� - , a -
L_ i L '+'►� Ly, br.►Lt► �i_-►L a s i�tyci iL ' i L�.,►
L -. --�•-t lam{ t.
i - �r`Y�L'(C.� ...a�r .�.�. �4-: '}c}�1s6�..r��•"'T ter_.... ;• la �, y _, ., . - .-_-_ _ �. -
y�•'� ��LL�mow-_ w r ..�► -� i T~ Y - :.r 4_
.....,L �_ �.aary'�T'^T..' �•�rr`v_' �"r+-.t•I"•'^1 - `r- 1,-
1�1._•Y"�.i, t . '•fir. t i :-tt. _�. is ...�.r
' � Ii•.� a�'C} -t •`�1'•"�''ia� ' ,� , { !s.�Z-��4•. t�{��w ��LiI i���t _- -- - )�
rr= : raj f:•' '� ? -''<Ce
�� fir. i �� � 4t ti t :ti .: t' ��•�. � • y5.���
41
13*
lool
\titi ^x
.441 `
r
r.
. •I y.. ..ram ��r• ��� ��_ �� h
1
IT
• a � �
40.
}
tlb '
r r 1
Y'
r
Wk
40
Who-
r
.. '�. 40P
106
Opp
.1
•
Vt �
1
l � Y
I
1 _
1 1 �
1
� f
1
. 4
1 �
♦ _.rr -�.. - , - �b. ' -�'�S � `t'. tar. i3���
.. .� \ � � 1• � J' of
a t f'