Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAward Rubric 1 | P a g e Bozeman Preservation Awards Guide HPAB Preservation Awards Guide Overview The City of Bozeman Historic Preservation Advisory Board as part of its mission seeks to recognize and celebrate those individuals and organizations that have made significant contributions towards preserving Bozeman’s unique historic and cultural resources. The Preservation Awards program is a board driven awards program and event. All awards categories are based on the Secretary of the Interior Standards and Guidelines which board members are familiar with. Each award category reflects diverse preservation related projects, though some nominations may qualify for various categories. The categories are broad and apply to the type of preservation work occurring within Bozeman, though certain minimum standards are needed to achieve acceptance as reflected in the Standards. Board member judges will use a rubric scoring card to quantitatively asses various nominations. The rubrics are intended to be used by judges to determine the project has meet the minimum criteria and narrow down the field of contenders for each award category. While the rubric is quantitative in nature, judges are expected to apply their qualitative judgement. Awards winning projects should be decided by a majority vote, not a quantitative score decision. The Secretary of the Interior Standards and Guidelines The Standards are a series of concepts about maintaining, repairing, and replacing historic materials, as well as designing new additions or making alterations. The Guidelines refer to general design and technical recommendations to assist in applying Standards to a specific project. Both the Standards and Guidelines are used to inform and develop the Bozeman Design Guidelines for Historic Preservation, a document used to determine appropriate modifications to properties within Historic Districts and the Neighborhood Conservation Overlay District. The Standards, Guidelines and Bozeman Design Guidelines should be used to quantitatively evaluate Preservation Award nominations. 2 | P a g e Bozeman Preservation Awards Guide Preservation Related Terms: 1. Preservation: The act or process of applying measures to sustain the existing form, integrity and material of a building. Some work focuses on keeping a property in good working condition by repairing features as soon as deterioration becomes apparent, suing procedures that retain the original character and finish features. 2. Rehabilitation: The process of returning a property to a state that makes a contemporary use possible while still preserving those portions or features of the property which are significant to its historical, architectural and cultural values. Rehabilitation may include additions or a new use of the building. 3. Restoration: The process of reproducing in the appearance of a building exactly as it looked at a particular moment in time. This may include the removal of late work or the replacement of missing historic features. 4. Reconstruction: The process of rebuilding a structure that no longer exists as it did historically. Basic Nomination Eligibility: 1. Located within the City limits of Bozeman. 2. Project must be complete. 3. Project must be historic: having significance, intact historic physical integrity and at least 50 years old. Categories 1. Outstanding Achievement in Historic Preservation: Recognizes an exceptional effort in the preservation of a building or structure meeting the following criteria: a. Adheres to the standards of Rehabilitation b. Enhances the character of the property c. Respects its context d. Maximizes the retention of distinctive features that make the building or structure significant. e. Contributes to the building or structure’s continued use. 3 | P a g e Bozeman Preservation Awards Guide 2. Adaptive Reuse: Recognizes an outstanding and creative example of adapting an existing building for a new use that respects the defining characteristics Note: Adaptive reuse is a form of Rehabilitation: 4 | P a g e Bozeman Preservation Awards Guide -A property will be used as it was historically or given a new use that requires minimal change to its distinctive materials, features, spaces and spatial relationships. Ex: Princeton, N.J. Nomad Pizza 3. Preservation Stewardship: recognizes groups, individual’s agencies or businesses that have positively impacted the City of Bozeman by advancing the publics appreciation, understanding, and involvement in historic preservation or the conservation of living tradition. Note: There are no NPS Standards for this category. 5 | P a g e Bozeman Preservation Awards Guide 4. Restoration / Rehabilitation: Recognizes a restoration, or rehabilitation project which meets high standards of preservation, and that respects and responds to Bozeman’s unique cultural history and heritage. 6 | P a g e Bozeman Preservation Awards Guide 5. Continued Maintenance: Recognizes an effort to actively preserve and maintain an historic building or structure for its continued use while respecting the buildings original character and its site. Note: Standards would include both Preservation and Rehabilitation. 7 | P a g e Bozeman Preservation Awards Guide 6. In/Fill New Addition: Recognizes new infill construction or additions to an historic building which respond to Bozeman’s architectural and cultural heritage, follows the Standards for Rehabilitation. Note: Reference The Bozeman Guidelines for Historic Preservation pg. 35, 39-40, 8 | P a g e Bozeman Preservation Awards Guide Scouring Rubric for “Outstanding Achievement in Historic Preservation” 2018 Bozeman Preservation Awards Outstanding Achievement In Historic Preservation: Nomination 1 Outstanding Achievement In Historic Preservation: Nomination 2 Outstanding Achievement In Historic Preservation: Nomination 3 Name of Project: Does this Project Meet the Minimum Criteria? Y or N Did this project utilize Tax Credits? 1 Point Is this Property Contributing to a Historic District? 1 point Is this Property Individually Listed on the National Register? 1 point Was this Property Threatened? 1-5 Points Did this Project Follow the Necessary NPS Standards for Rehabilitation? 1-10 Points Would an Award to this Project/ Individual Further the Cause of Preservation in Bozeman? 1-5 Points Total: 9 | P a g e Bozeman Preservation Awards Guide Scouring Rubric for “Adaptive Reuse” 2018 Bozeman Preservation Awards Adaptive Reuse: Nomination 1 Adaptive Reuse: Nomination 2 Adaptive Reuse: Nomination 3 Name of Project: Does this Project Meet the Minimum Criteria? Y or N Did this project utilize Tax Credits? 1 Point Did this project successfully reuse a structure for a new/Modern use? Is this Property Contributing to a Historic District? 1 point Is this Property Individually Listed on the National Register? 1 point Was this Property Threatened? 1-5 Points Did this Project Follow the Necessary NPS Standards for Rehabilitation? 1-10 Points Would an Award to this Project/ Individual Further the Cause of Preservation in Bozeman? 1-5 Points Total: 10 | P a g e Bozeman Preservation Awards Guide Scouring Rubric for “Preservation Stewardship” 2018 Bozeman Preservation Awards Preservation Stewardship: Nomination 1 Preservation Stewardship: Nomination 2 Preservation Stewardship: Nomination 3 Name of Project: Does this Project Meet the Minimum Criteria? Y or n Has this organization had a significant impact in the preservation/ cultural stewardship of Bozeman? Y or N Is education & Outreach part of this organization’s mission? Y or N Is this an active group or organization? Y or N Total: 11 | P a g e Bozeman Preservation Awards Guide Scouring Rubric for “Continued Maintenance” 2018 Bozeman Preservation Awards Continued Maintenance: Nomination 1 Continued Maintenance: Nomination 2 Continued Maintenance: Nomination 3 Name of Project: Does this Project Meet the Minimum Criteria? Y or N Did this project utilize Tax Credits? 1 Point Is this Property Contributing to a Historic District? 1 point Is this Property Individually Listed on the National Register? 1 point Was this Property Threatened? 1-5 Points Did this Project Follow the Necessary NPS Standards for Rehabilitation & Preservation? 1-10 Points Would an Award to this Project/ Individual Further the Cause of Preservation in Bozeman? 1-5 Points Total: 12 | P a g e Bozeman Preservation Awards Guide Scouring Rubric for “Restoration & Rehabilitation” 2018 Bozeman Preservation Awards Continued Maintenance: Nomination 1 Continued Maintenance: Nomination 2 Continued Maintenance: Nomination 3 Name of Project: Does this Project Meet the Minimum Criteria? Y or N Did this project utilize Tax Credits? 1 Point Is this Property Contributing to a Historic District? 1 point Is this Property Individually Listed on the National Register? 1 point Was this Property Threatened? 1-5 Points Did this Project Follow the Necessary NPS Standards for Rehabilitation & Restoration? 1-10 Points Would an Award to this Project/ Individual Further the Cause of Preservation in Bozeman? 1-5 Points Total: 13 | P a g e Bozeman Preservation Awards Guide Scouring Rubric for “In-fill/ Additions” 2018 Bozeman Preservation Awards In-Fill/ Additions: Nomination 1 In-Fill/ Additions: Nomination 2 In-Fill/ Additions: Nomination 3 Name of Project: Does this Project Meet the Minimum Criteria? Y or N Is this Property Contributing to a Historic District? 1 point Is this Property Individually Listed on the National Register? 1 point Was this Property Threatened? 1-5 Points Did this project follow the City of Bozeman’s Design Guidelines for Additions and In-Fill? 1-10 Points Would an Award to this Project/ Individual Further the Cause of Preservation in Bozeman? 1-5 Points Total: