HomeMy WebLinkAbout533 E. Mendenhall 2016Montana Historic Property Record
Bozeman Historic Structures Inventory - 2014
3/8/2015
Modification Date:
2/10/2015 5:11:12 PM
Time:
533
Property Address: number
E Mendenhall St
Property Address: street
219 E Mendenhall St
Historic Address:
Bozeman
City/Town:
Site Number:
Gallatin
County
SLC
Intl:
Historic Name:
Archibald and Josephine McDonald
Original Owner
Private
Current Ownership:
Kent Interiors
Current Property Name:
Gary L. and Carol E Lister
Owner:
382 Peace Pipe Dr, Bozeman, MT
Owner Address:
Phone:
Residence
Historic Use:
Commercial
Current Use:
pre 1902
Estimated
Construction Date:
Original Location
Date Moved:
WGS84UTM Reference
497725
Easting:
5058559
Northing:
12TUTM Zone:
Legal Location PM: Montana
2
Township:
South 6
Range:
East
SW 1/4 SW 1/4 NE 1/4
7Section
Lots 9, 10
Lots:
Rouse's Addition
Addition:
1870/1889
Year of Addition:
Bozeman, MT 7.5 min topo
USGS Quad Name:
2014
Date:
H
Blocks
Other
GPS Accuracy:
GoogleEarth Pro
GoogleEarth ProGPS Equipment:
24
Front stepUTM Location Pt:
UTM Reference
Site Name
533 E Mendenhall St
Property Address
InteResources Planning, Inc.505 Bond Street, Suite B
Bozeman, MT 59715
406.587.9477
Montana Historic Property Record
Bozeman Historic Structures Inventory - 2014
National Register of Historic Places
NRHP Listing Date:
Bozeman Overlay District
Historic District:
2/18/2015
Date of this document:
Scott L. Carpenter
Form Prepared by:
Address:
Daytime Phone:
InteResources Planning, Inc.
505 Bond St., Suite B
Bozeman, MT 59715
406-587-9477
No
NRHP Eligible Recommendation:
MT SHPO USE ONLY
Eligible for NRHP: □ yes □ no
Criteria: □ A □ B □ C □ D
Date:
Evaluator:
Comments:
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
PAGE 2
Property Name:
Site Number: 24
533 E Mendenhall St Bozeman
InteResources Planning, Inc.505 Bond Street, Suite B
Bozeman, MT 59715
406.587.9477
Montana Historic Property Record
Bozeman Historic Structures Inventory - 2014
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
PAGE 3
Property Name:
Site Number: 24
533 E Mendenhall St Bozeman
ARCHITECTYURAL DESCRIPTION See Additional Information Page
Residential
Property Type:
Queen Anne
Architectural Style:
Cottage Style
If Other, specify:
Single-family residence
Specific Property Type:
Not known
Architect:
Not known
Architectural Firm:
StateCity Town
Not known
Builder/Contractor:Company:
StateCity Town
Source of Information:
L Plan (Front Facing)
Architectural Form:
Hipped
Roof Form:
Single
Stories:
Wood frame
Materials:
Overall Dimensions:
approx. 58 ft
North - South
approx. 28 ft
East - West
Rear (north) projection with shed roof.Projection
InteResources Planning, Inc.505 Bond Street, Suite B
Bozeman, MT 59715
406.587.9477
Montana Historic Property Record
Bozeman Historic Structures Inventory - 2014
Concisely, accurately, and completely describe the property and alterations with dates. Number the buildings and features
to correlate with the Site Map.
The building is a single-family detached one-story dwelling designed and constructed in the Queen Anne Cottage Style.
The building form is a front-facing L-shape with entry on the interior angle of the "L". The two-bay façade is comprised of
the entry approach to main door into the house in the main block beneath a hipped roof. The covered walkway leading to
the entry door exhibits a recent/modern rounded (semi-circular vault) roof supported at the end by two tapered wood posts
atop concrete supports faced with brick veneer. The entry porch is covered by a shed roofed with a single fixed window on
the east wall. The original entry door has been replaced with a metal-framed full glass commercial door. The concrete walk
leads to a concrete stoop with one step. The second bay on the west side of the façade is formed by a projecting gable-
fronted bay with returning eaves and a recently remodeled large circular window with semi-circular framed awning detail
replicating the new curved porch roof. The frame construction is finished in drop-cove (Dutch-cove) wood siding that
appears to be original to the structure. The front gable-end is covered with random-width wood shingles with
approximately 6" reveal. The north (rear) side of the building has a one-story rectangular projected addition with a slightly
sloping shed roof. The addition has an entry door on the east side and three modern sash windows on the north elevation.
Foundation is hidden by recent brick planters and veneer. New replacement foundation is presumed to be concrete.
Foundation
The main block of the building has a hip roof with a brick chimney at the center. The front "L" projection is covered with a
gable roof, covered with wood shingles
Roof
A small detached wood-frame garage/shed with original drop-cove siding, and 2-over-2 sash windows, is located near the
northeast corner of the main structure. The west wall of building has a single entry door, with a double hinged garage door
on the north elevation. The garage has a gable roof with ridge line perpendicular to E Mendenhall St.
Porches/Outbuildings
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
PAGE 4
Property Name:
Site Number: 24
533 E Mendenhall St Bozeman
Original front window has been replaced by 6-ft diameter round fixed window centered in front bay. Original front entry
door has recently been replaced by a modern commercial metal-framed, full glass door. Windows on east elevation
appear to be original configuration and shape but have replaced modern sashes.
Fenestration:
InteResources Planning, Inc.505 Bond Street, Suite B
Bozeman, MT 59715
406.587.9477
Montana Historic Property Record
Bozeman Historic Structures Inventory - 2014
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
PAGE 5
Property Name:
Site Number: 24
533 E Mendenhall St Bozeman
The single-story frame building, without the rear shed-roofed projection, appears in the same layout and form on the 1904
Sanborn Fire Insurance Map for Bozeman (sheet 5). The previously published Sanborn Map for 1891 shows no such
building on the large lot owned by Archibald McDonald. The 1902 Polk City Directory for Bozeman (pg. 140) lists Arthur
Herring, a fireman for the Northern Pacific Railroad as the resident at 219 (later 533) E Mendenhall St. Also in the 1902
directory, a Joseph Herron, a clerk for F.A. Maxwell, is listed as a boarder at the same address. From readily available
information, it is estimated that the building on the subject property was built by McDonald sometime prior to 1902, but after
1891.
History of Property: See Additional Information Page
InteResources Planning, Inc.505 Bond Street, Suite B
Bozeman, MT 59715
406.587.9477
Montana Historic Property Record
Bozeman Historic Structures Inventory - 2014
See Additional Information PageInformation Sources/Bibliography
Sanborn Maps:Structure appears on these Bozeman Sanborn Maps:
Nov 1884 Jan 1889 Jul 1890 Nov 1891 XJan 1904
XSep 1912 XSep 1927
XSep 1927/Rev Aug 1943
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
PAGE 6
Property Name:
Site Number: 24
533 E Mendenhall St Bozeman
City Sewer Hook-up Records City Water Hook-up RecordsXDate Date
Polk City Directory for Bozeman 1902, pg 140.
City Directory
Deeds not researched
Deeds
Sep 1927/Rev 1957 X
XSep 1912/Rev Feb 1921
XSep 1927/Rev 1960
InteResources Planning, Inc.505 Bond Street, Suite B
Bozeman, MT 59715
406.587.9477
Montana Historic Property Record
Bozeman Historic Structures Inventory - 2014
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
PAGE 7
Property Name:
Site Number: 24
533 E Mendenhall St Bozeman
National Register of Historic Places
NRHP Listing Date:
NRHP Eligibility:
Yes
X
No Individually Contributing to Historic District
Noncontributing to Historic District
Area of Significance:
Period of Significance:
See Additional Information PageStatement of Significance
As documented in the 1984 survey form, the building has historical significance that justifies a recommendation as a
contributing element within a potential historic district to to association with the residential aspect of the Civic Phase of
Bozeman's historic/architectural development. However, due to the diminished integrity (see below), it is recommended
that the building no longer exhibits qualities and elements that can support an evaluation to recommend listing on the
National Register of Historic Places.
NRHP Criteria:A B C D
See Additional Information PageIntegrity
(location, design, setting, materials, workmanship, feeling, association)
Since its original documentation during the 1984 survey, this property has undergone major changes and remodeling that
has diminished the historical architectural integrity. Due to the replacement of the original front widow with a large circular
modern window, replacement of original front entry door, and the construction of semi-circular covered walkway structure,
brick veneer details, replacement windows, and other details, the structure no longer exhibits integrity of design,
materials, and workmanship.
InteResources Planning, Inc.505 Bond Street, Suite B
Bozeman, MT 59715
406.587.9477
Montana Historic Property Record
Bozeman Historic Structures Inventory - 2014
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION PAGE
Property Name:
Site Number: 24
533 E Mendenhall St Bozeman
InteResources Planning, Inc.505 Bond Street, Suite B
Bozeman, MT 59715
406.587.9477
Montana Historic Property Record
Bozeman Historic Structures Inventory - 2014
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
PHOTOGRAPHS
Property Name:
Site Number: 24
533 E Mendenhall St Bozeman
Façade Photo
IRP_122_021515_02038.jpgExposure/File #:
NorthFacing:
533 E Mendenhall StFeature:
View to north at façade of detached dwelling. Note recent addition of large circular window,
semi-circular vaulted covered walkway, commercial door, and brick veneer. Note small
garage/shed with gable roof off of rear northeast corner of building.
Description:
2/10/2015 5:11:12 PMTime:
InteResources Planning, Inc.505 Bond Street, Suite B
Bozeman, MT 59715
406.587.9477
Montana Historic Property Record
Bozeman Historic Structures Inventory - 2014
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
PHOTOGRAPHS
Property Name:
Site Number: 24
533 E Mendenhall St Bozeman
Reference Photo
Exposure/File #:
Facing:
Feature:
Description:
Time:IRP_122_021515_02037.jpg
Northwest
533 E Mendenhall St
View to NNE at façade and east elevation of building.
InteResources Planning, Inc.505 Bond Street, Suite B
Bozeman, MT 59715
406.587.9477
Montana Historic Property Record
Bozeman Historic Structures Inventory - 2014
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
PHOTOGRAPHS
Property Name:
Site Number: 24
533 E Mendenhall St Bozeman
Reference Photo
IRP_122_021515_02041.jpgExposure/File #:Time:
SouthFacing:
533 E Mendenhall StFeature:
View to south at rear of building with shed-roof rear projection and detached garage on left.Description:
InteResources Planning, Inc.505 Bond Street, Suite B
Bozeman, MT 59715
406.587.9477
Montana Historic Property Record
Bozeman Historic Structures Inventory - 2014
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
USGS Location Map
Property Name:
Site Number: 24
533 E Mendenhall St Bozeman
Portion of USGS 7.5 Minute Topographic Map, Bozeman, MT, 2014, scale 1:24,000 (red square indicates approximate
location of property.
InteResources Planning, Inc.505 Bond Street, Suite B
Bozeman, MT 59715
406.587.9477
Montana Historic Property Record
Bozeman Historic Structures Inventory - 2014
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
General Location Map
Property Name:
Site Number: 24
533 E Mendenhall St Bozeman
General Location Map
Red shape denotes project boundary, red arrow indicates property location.
InteResources Planning, Inc.505 Bond Street, Suite B
Bozeman, MT 59715
406.587.9477
Montana Historic Property Record
Bozeman Historic Structures Inventory - 2014
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
Detailed Location Photo-Map
Property Name:
Site Number: 24
533 E Mendenhall St Bozeman
Detailed Location Map
Red shape denotes subject property.
InteResources Planning, Inc.505 Bond Street, Suite B
Bozeman, MT 59715
406.587.9477
Montana Historic Property Record
Bozeman Historic Structures Inventory - 2014
MONTANA HISTORIC PROPERTY RECORD
Building Sketch Map
Property Name:
Site Number: 24
533 E Mendenhall St Bozeman
Property/Building Sketch Map
InteResources Planning, Inc.505 Bond Street, Suite B
Bozeman, MT 59715
406.587.9477